Panel on Investing @500altcoins @lemiscate @5irechain @riteshkakkad @KavitaGupta19 @eking0x

ETHDubai 2023 · 15 Mar 2023 · 32:37

A panel at ETHDubai 2023 on DeFi investment, held days after the Silicon Valley Bank collapse and USDC briefly losing its dollar peg. Panelists discuss regulatory uncertainty and limited banking access, with some expecting regional rules and friendlier jurisdictions such as Hong Kong and the UK, and others pointing to fiat off-ramps as the real pressure point. They then turn to the Euler Finance hack, arguing that audits alone are not enough and calling for shared security standards, a security score, and reuse of battle-tested code. The panel ends on cautious optimism about DeFi.

Speakers

Topics

From ETHDubai 2023, hosted by DeFi Dubai.

Transcript

GM GM I hope everyone's well a bit better week this week um welcome to the talk on defy investment um let me do some quick introductions of the panel I'm Gareth I'm from our Ventures full-time dgn from Exiles blockchain infrastructure for financial services uh I'm Mark zitter I work for the average initiative we are the main RV protocol Dao delegates hi my name is Kavita I'm the founder of Delta blockchain fun uh started consensus Ventures and tachyon hi my name is ritesh kakkar I am co-founder for the XGC Network which is

layer 1 evm compatible decentralized network thank you hello my name is Akin I'm the managing editor at TL news the journalism arm of defy Lama so I think this week's been a fairly interesting week already not just for the crypto will but the wider VC world as well there was a collapse of svb bank then Signature Bank usdc going off Peg which probably we all thought was impossible until this weekend um so I just thought I'd pose a question to the panel in these kind of Uncertain times with attacks from Regulators Etc what do we see as the biggest challenges facing the defy industry in the coming

years and how are we going to overcome those I think from my point of view one of the we actually are very positive on D5 especially given we work with a lot of financial institutions who are adopting a lot of the D5 technology to bring on board a lot of these assets and real world assets on chain I think the only thing we see the differences there are legitimate concerns for financial institutions to put these assets on public chains as simple as transaction data privacy so there are a lot more Technologies now out there which are trying to change those things

and we believe that should be perfectly fine I think it's a very interesting time right as we were talking right before this um so we are talking about an American unbanking system for blockchain or crypto uh even though if you have been kyc before even though you have all the regulation compliance which is also getting very stricken in UK and following the path and how does the rest of the world follows is going to be very

interesting so as some of us were talking right before the panel that we can go with the loopholes today as a VC fund or as a company to say oh this is a tech company and no more detail about it but the Crux of the matter doesn't go uh you have worked at Ave we have bunch of token projects in our portfolio um at what point do we just accept it and go towards a simple banking while paying and we still pay taxes on it so it's not like we are not paying taxes on any of our income whether that income is coming from crypto or from Equity capital gains but while paying the taxes I cannot

actually have banking basic services for it so I think the question which I put out here is uh what does the future looks like when it comes to specially defy because if we are thinking about D5 farming eels uh a lot of different returns and you can never take it back to fiat currency what does that future looks like for you guys I think one of the the main issue right now is that you know in the in the history of the US you have this concept of no taxation without representation as a Dao am I represented right now in the U.S what is my statue was my legal representation

and it's actually a huge problem and I think the cycle we are getting in right now will be the cycle of maturity for the ecosystem because we need to have adult Frameworks for what a Dao is what are the responsibility and what are the rights of the Dao because I don't feel represented as a dow delegate right now I work for an entity that doesn't have any legal existence it doesn't make sense it's not about we don't want any rules it's not about we should apply in one of the rules that exists right now it's just that what we are doing is brand new so we need brand new rules so I I like to tell you very clearly like you know if you look at New York's

location it started on 50 years before and SEC came in after almost after 150 years so here in defy it's a very initial stage so if you say that you know we'll go to Regulators but regulator don't know how to regulate it the D5 space because everything is so new it's not many parties not written on their book itself so looking at the current condition I feel it's more like a evolvement so Regulators they are against to those who are taking users fund they are not against you any kind of innovation my personal experience I meet many Regulators they are always open for the regulation the only problem they don't know how to regulate so Defy is a very interesting space and everybody knows it's going to kill the traditional world because of a low fee

and transparency none of the banks gives you full transformation end users like say you have money and you put on a bank account you don't know where the bank is using your fund until there will be a collapse so I think D5 regulation will take some time maybe a little bit so we have to keep developing we have to keep going to The Regulators with our use case and finally we'll find out something like the their Regulators so they will regulate it like tomorrow or day after tomorrow but things will come like it would be stabilized gradually okay as the last person commenting on this I want to offer some optimism at the first point I'll make is um we're in Dubai um and I met lots of people who are just

moving here setting up companies here or who've been here for years uh there is so much there's so much emphasis on what the US does um it's like the Ramstein song we're all living in America we're constantly bombarded to um American news I work at the news organization so I have to deal with that myself on a daily basis even though I live in the UK myself um The World Is Not Just America there are other jurisdictions and there's so much America can do before it rugs itself completely and the capital and talent flee to other jurisdictions if you look at the UK hmrcs or the treasuries consultation paper you'll see um that actually it has a very reasonable take I highly recommend if

you're interested in D5 go read it it talks about for instance the degrees of decentralization um you know like how much the core team owned uh it went like how much of the Dow treasury is in its own tokens or how much whether the contract is upgradable things like that that we discuss in this industry policy makers are also aware they had a good crowd of I guess experts who informed their you know informed this paper so that is good news if you hate decentralization theatrics uh in in defying you know there will be jurisdictions like UK that will be on your side and quickly I'll also say our industry has a

history of innovating you know if all Fiat off-ramps on reps close I'm I'm optimistic maybe toxically optimistic that there will be some sort of solution you know Nigeria has had that solution P2P markets so we could see the same in the West yeah I think that's an interesting point and something we touched on as well before the panel started in terms of if the US is closed for business how do you see the future of the D5 space shaping jurisdiction wise who's going to take the lead there where are we going to see legal recognition of dows in the future how are we going to interact with traditional financial institutions from the crypto side can I underline just one quick thing I think

the regulations are only at the off ramp and on-ramp as Eula mentioned right the rest of the D5 world it's very very far away and even the understanding forget about regulation so the only piece of it which we are looking is you may be a billionaire in your D5 eel but how do you convert it to buy a house you want to buy for three million dollars so if U.S closes down that off-ramp solution let's say 10 other countries closes down there's always going to be two countries which is going to allow you and then you go through the banking movement so the money will find its place is just going to be interesting to see does over time us as a country wants to lose those taxes

completely that's how I look at it it's also an interesting challenge for the U.S banking system because the main stable coins and that was part of the show we got this week with usdc is us-based and minting a U.S related currency and the thing is that if you closed on every banking partners of a circle or do you redeem usdc for actual USD and OU maintain the bag and that's actually one of the main challenge of 2023 is that three of the six partners of them now what happened for the three next ones there are big ones and probably safe but uh that's that's something that creates a bit of concern in the

ecosystem at this point yeah yeah I like to point out one more thing if you look at on-rem and offline that's not the only thing but regionally if you go to Japan you can easily convert your crypto to Japanese Yen you go to Singapore you can convert your crypto to Singapore dollar it's all regulated by The Regulators so in future I see there will be a regional regulations when it's related to like you know online frame and I am very optimistics and I I think it's the future like every like on-ramp will be very specific to the region like say if you are talking about UE it will be like crypto to say AED where I will come out with the regulations and bank will support today or tomorrow so it will become a more like a regional specific in future

and actually some of the large Global Financial Centers right Hong Kong actually came out with very clear guidelines earlier this year and it's perfectly fine there so they were kind of out of the game for for a couple of years and now they're back so I think a lot of the regional Financial Centers which are still home to some of the biggest banks where you have open Capital something like Hong Kong would probably be the place where you start seeing uh movement of uh people out of us if if such a regulation kind of becomes very stifling for the industry

yeah so if you talk about Singapore DBS bank they are the authorized people they convert crypto to a Singapore dollar so similarly it's one of the biggest bank in the world so as he mentioned us is not the world but there are different region as well they are also going to play very important role in future when I get inside the ecosystem the main trading volume for Bitcoin uh on uh on socialized exchange was actually a Chinese platform So I entered the ecosystem in a weird era where we were pricing Bitcoin in Chinese in Renminbi like it was like the in everybody Minds The the price of Bitcoin the unit of account of Bitcoin was the Chinese Yuan

do you think that this year we will start pricing the Bitcoin ethereum not in dollars anymore but in Euros or other currencies there is an econometric report which came out yesterday which talked about that one of the biggest reason for USD to stay in power actually in last two years has been stable coins because the amount of collateral between the top seven stable coins are pretty much equivalent to the debt which China has been maintaining on press reborns so if those stable coins are not going to be in USD Peg and let's say tomorrow they move to Euro pegging or other places whomsoever is much more comfortable with

the jurisdiction we're going to see a huge movement um which is actually can shake the U.S economy completely and going forward I wouldn't be surprised if Dubai Middle East or Hong Kong want to be the leader and just start with their stable coins and let all the conversion happen and it can happen very fast like in the mind of everybody people nobody is that attached to the USD so it can be AED in the future that everybody will say yeah Bitcoin is 100 Ties on the AED and that's it and it's gonna push in the ecosystem and then you can just transfer it back to your Bank of America in the normal simple Fiat transaction which doesn't even actually can give you a more Arbitrage opportunity yeah

I mean it's been seen as a somewhat radical concept so far but maybe with what we've seen with dollar pack stable coins and potential regulations do we see a move away not to pegging to another currency but a move altogether away from a peg towards something like rye and being a decentralized non-pegged currency that's just for defy natives the problem with Dai was that it also had 70 treasury in usdc right because nobody thought usdc having all the collateral one-to-one mapped would ever debug right but I think what we forgot is it's not no more a question of having and having an audited pegging collateral it's the question of now the government

issued money too so this wasn't a crypto failure this was exactly a fiat currency government issued currency failure I think I like to tell about sorry about dye IC is one of the great solution uh the only problem people using the eye for a speculation like they use for a trading they use for a leverage product so one of our ecosystem Partners fathom they are developing like similar concept but they are going to use entire money like stable assets for the real world transaction so they are going to like you know fund for to the invest which like SME need a like financing so they are going to use those currency for the real world usage so I think the major problem is disconnection with the real

world whether it's a real world tokenization or it's a real world business or like you know empowering to SME so I think here that is missing something recently they took exposure into the T bill but that's not the solution if you look at the long term like you have to help your currency with the like GDP it should help to the SME it will help to boost the economy so I think we have many such projects which I feel is going to be a great thing for future and Phantom team is already here I think it's going to be a mix of what the gentleman was saying of of this being very much regionalized country specific you know and probably the community itself deciding that okay we

are not going to do anything with the Fiat at all right totally I mean for example uh if I have a million dollar in usdt right I really do not um and if the community actually comes together we really do not need a Fiat element attached to it is it is it okay yeah right I think there would be I know I I really hope for that this is going to be a time where we have nothing to do with the fiat currency all together we don't need to you know worry about the Deep packing right and I think I think that's the ideal scenario which which I see you know as as an investor in this space as an investor in space we have all established on-ram off-ramp is a problem

um Gareth I'm sorry I'm taking over your question but very quickly and you you have been a Degen in the space so I'll include you in the conversation how you guys dealing with all the hacks of this week yeah I think that's a good question I mean I personally saw a lot of friends um within the d-gen school Citadel which uh supposedly the top on-chained degen's defy Natives and so many people were caught offside in Euler Finance like they didn't see it coming it had been audited 12 times how do we as investors what do we see as the protections that project companies should be putting in place to protect against these kind of hacks and exploits how can we better protect investors in the space

I think it's there's definitely a safety culture in D5 at least the main protocol and I just want to say that it's very unfortunate what happened to Euler uh they were obviously our competitors with Avi but we like to fight competition is good for the ecosystem it brings Innovation and we want to win because we are the best one not because the competitor got a very unfortunate event and what happened to them could happen to everybody like uh they wear as much in the safety culture that we are they were doing like many Audits and they are very great Engineers what happened to them is unfortunate but that's life and obviously it's brand new tech and we do everything that is humanly

impossible to protect our user and for are they that mean that nobody lose money for the past three years but there's still going to be risk on chain there is no way you can say it's zero risk so it's something you have to accept with brand new technology I have something to say like if you look at the traditional financing system it takes 250 years to reach here ah so if you are talking about D file you know how consumers they are protected if you look at any platform D5 platform they don't want to lose users money they want to do lots of experiment which is already done in traditional world now they want to do on chain they just want to remove all the intermediaries they want to remove all the fees so one system tooks 250 years to reach here uh

it will take another like you know five years give us a five years to the device system to evolve and reach to level where everything is very secure smart contrary is very much evolved and people have full fat they can also invest like you know few billion dollars in a different ecosystem right now it's a very much on Innovative stage so it's very early to say like it's Totally Secure it's a total Innovation and we have to wait for the evolvement of a technology I think only I think the only solution is more and more education and awareness I think that's that's the that is the only solution which IEC for hacks right now I mean even anything even in the Contemporary Finance there are hacks which happen even even today right uh so you know probably if if the community of

developers can come together especially Security Experts and come together and you know and put together a you know probably a standards you know where where every D5 platform you know goes through you know and and it can be really really stable and secure and that's the only that that's one solution which I see as a developer also I I in my personal opinion I think difa is not that cannot be that simplified right uh first of all I do not agree that everything which has been done on the trading flow traditional space is the only thing which is happening in D5 I think there is a way many more Innovative products which are way more complicated than what exotic options swaps Etc are doing um the second thing is I think the point

of failures or the point of a vulnerability actually is a better world word than the failure are too many right now on D5 you have all the web 2 uh security issues and then you have different issues from your individual wallet hack to the company multisex to then on the platforms phishing activities coming from just the website to then your smart contracts auditing issues now if we just stick to the smart contract auditing issue unfortunately what happened with Euler where you have one of a very very reputable product uh has gone through all the smart contract auditings for five six different level and of one simple feature which is not

even being used is just a part of a new feature costs the 200 million plus hack um is there a type of uh a standard and this is something as a VCB have been thinking about for our portfolio companies that what do you establish a standard that there you cannot you cannot go and actually launch something without having these type of certificates or some sort of a standardized report which if you don't have it no user can use it I like to add to one more point if you are talking about D5 like you are hosting on certain Network and the network they only have 20 nodes run by

like few people two or three people so go one step ahead as well you know from a like platform side as well there are there might be lots of vulnerability when the platform is not very decentralized like many top five change or tough tension if you look at they have only 20 25 nodes so it's so easy to manipulate not only this defy smart contract but you can like you know do lots of manipulation within like blockchain itself in terms of Standards obviously I will chill have a bit because obviously but uh the more and more there's people in the ecosystem that say instead of just starting from scratch we're just gonna wait like and that's

basically what happened with some Refuge with the real world asset does karate all what happened with Will tea with realistic tokenization it's the avocad base so it's the same smart contract that had been audited after dozens time that our life for the past three years and they just take the code deploy that with their own kind of karate also there's always risk obviously but uh the end they just say to the Dao we're gonna give you 10 of the profit or 20 of the proceed it's an Unchained agreement and I think it's part of the solution that instead of Reinventing the wheel with every protocol we can do like make a dollar is launching spark land as well that's gonna retake the rav3 code base and do their own products I think

there's a way to standardization to just relaunch the same code base because what we do is like already battle tested and just have a deal with the download and uh you still have your own product that is interesting your own value add but you come from a technology that is already proven but Mark that's not feasible for trade we are talking about what we do like liquidity protocols yes they are using most of the D5 products by the way are using big chains like polygon or ethereum or Avalanche like

really big ones which are responsible for their thousands of notes um but I still feel like the like a particular standard whether it comes from Ave it comes from maker Dao uni swap or all of them come together and have some sort of a security standard um is one of the biggest missing piece right because everybody has come down on most of the projects which we have been looking at is like wallets who are just trying to get all of them together and actually create more security issues by having so much of aggregated at one place without solving the security issue and most of the smart contract auditing firms which we have worked with or invested constant album hexen they all work on individual security audits uh

even to get a firm which does web 2 web 3 security at the same time and take responsibility for both is so hard to find so so as the D5 product Builders there hasn't been a movement or the focus which we have seen I guess there are many Bitcoin maximalists in this room or at this conference uh but I think we can we got a lot to learn from BTC Maxis not because they've been around for so long but they had to you know build this culture from scratch I think it was Andreas Antonopoulos in 2017 who said something like Bitcoin is a sewer rat it exists in this adversarial environment where everything is trying to kill it I

think Defy is a little bit like that too it's uh it's a swarm of civil rats we're surrounded by we are we exist in adversarial environment internally or externally internally uh it is you know it's like an open market for bug buntis or uh it's like a money glitch so you just need to you just have to hit it right today I saw gpt4 was released and now it's able to perform uh code audits on live ethereum content tax and it also tells you exactly uh where the exploits might be and how you can exploit it it literally walks you through I think you know these capabilities will only get

better over time but I'll also offer a dose of optimism or a bit of hopium um you know a basic defy primitive or lending protocol can be shaped in so many ways that compounds won't have the drip function um exploit again Euler won't have the reserve uh donate reserves or whatever that line of code was they won't have it again they were already you know six times audited unless you know we innovate new products and that will happen of course and then more you know degeny types can go you know ape into them but if you stick with I think um with protocols that have been around

for a long time I think the the risks are much much lower that something will happen to them I mean if they are upgradable of course and we solve that with maker dial osis if they're upgradable and there are still a lot of upgradable contracts then the risks still you know persist but if they are immutable you know like curve is immutable you know swap is immutable and stable metal tested I mean if there's a curve exploit tomorrow don't blame me but I think it's just reasonable to assume that the risks are not evenly distributed in the industry and over time these things will have to get better I think it's even

better than tradfy where they have to make these decisions in closed doors whereas in D5 everything is open um you know um Andre cronius at the conference as well he called difa he was saying that we should call defy uh open FI open source Finance instead of distress Finance I think that points to the right direction and gives us a reason for optimism yeah I like to add one last point if you look at Unison is a classic example of a D5 where everything is a decentralized it's open source people knows like who is contribution you can put your own liquidity uh you can see all the like you know transparency you can see everything very transparently what's

going on and it's replaced yesterday I was reading like you need so I've already crossed the volume of almost like a coinbase so the system is already evolving and it's like we can see the progress as well so today is a unicever tomorrow might be Phantom or day after tomorrow might be some other uh defined network will come and it's going to like you know lead the world in future okay I think unfortunately uh on that a bit more optimistic node at the end there uh we've probably ran out of time is not optimistic he's worried about her money I'm very very optimistic about D5 but I am not afraid of asking the tough

questions and I think those things have to be smart people ask dumb questions very happy to be done but I think the main point is um what we have seen in the crypto industry being here since 2013 and have seen three Cycles in the space and pretty much the whole ecosystem being built um in the bullish cycle we only focus on what's working when it comes to eels and money bearish cycle is when we actually sit down and talk about the infrastructure to make sure they survive and they Thrive and I I don't know whether we are in bearish Market already or not I mean looking at Bitcoin prices

today um but the question out here which I am more concerned and I think will be a great opportunity for D5 to become what the potential is is if we don't work on the infrastructure of security we don't work on the uh infrastructure of adoption without the regulation risk and the third and the most important part is actually have the right compliance for the eels to be realized as a capital gain irrespective of where you are in the world um then D5 we always have something which will push defy down and I think I'm bullish in the sector given that every put every individual company and we come together to actually make sure there are standards for these three

absolutely and I think we should also take some inspiration from web2 or probably the usscc you know when they built the Hobbies test you know for uh for for these tables right um and utility tokens probably we should take some inspiration from that right and and set up a standard uh to ensure that infrastructure the security infrastructure around D5 you know is more secure and I think because it's more important because there's so much of tvl you know actually logged out there ah and and the only only people who can do this is the community of you know developers out there right we we can just I mean probably the advocacies which is only going to happen if the developers you know actually come

together irrespective of what change they build on irrespective of what change they focus on what's their what's their favorite if they come together and build probably a standard which can also give you give give you a security score maybe that's that's the that's the most element you know Elemental one and and and probably if there is you know if there's an AI thing which can get built and suggest that okay this is what your platform should do more to ensure that security is better and then people people's money is safe the the end note is that we can take inspiration from web to there Mark as a developer D5 Builder and Dao guy last words I don't know it was like a very good

speech yeah regardless of every chain any chain as long as it's evm obviously because I'm a maximized but uh outside of that basically the wall feature of the past 12 months is a huge tritify and C5 advertisement that D5 works and I think we should continue to focus because obviously we are still immature there's still a lot of things to build it's also akaton this conference so let's start building the future of friends I'm gonna do some marketing and I'm going to invite people to come and build on fire thank you thanks a lot everyone thank you thank you so much