Supply Chain on Blockchain Conference 2020: Part 1

Supply Chain on Blockchain Conference 2020 · 13 Jul 2020 · 1:22:29

Part one of the Supply Chain on Blockchain Conference 2020 opens with a keynote by John Blackburn on national resilience and trusted supply chains after the pandemic. Alessia Falsarone then looks at how blockchain provenance and due diligence can serve responsible investors, including environmental and social data. Tyler Mulvihill closes with sustainable luxury supply chains, where traceability, digital certificates and tokenized ownership of collectible goods help build consumer trust. Each segment ends with audience questions.

Speakers

Topics

From Supply Chain on Blockchain Conference 2020, hosted by Ethereum Engineering Group.

Transcript

however the need for compliance tracking of provenance in the pharmaceutical and medical equipment sector is now more evident than ever you'll recollect the issue of counterfeit facemasks has been highlighted repeatedly in recent months now the ideas raised last year in the cero data 61 and SW presentation on blockchain solutions for traceability and trust management supply chains appear particularly applicable to the issues that we're seeing now the relate to our own resilience Trust is a quality in short supply in many instances today a technology that can improve supply chain reserves without the need to presuppose trust in a foreign government

or business entity would prove invaluable it's something that we really need so where should we focus the discussion of smart sovereignty and trusted supply chains has emerged during the pandemic he's an opportunity possibly to reframe a part of the blockchain discussion priority is likely going to be afforded to critical infrastructure areas such as communications energy health care transport systems banking and financial services food and agriculture and of course information technology given the current focus on medicine and medical equipment supply chains targeting this domain could provide an opportunity to highlight the significant benefits of blockchain technologies getting the

wider public to understand what the hell that is that's another challenge now what I'm going to talk about now is the broader issues of national resilience and what we're looking at adapting some of the narratives that I'm going to cover might help explain the potential of blockchain to improve our resilience it might be useful to so where to as a country our resilience has to be addressed by individuals communities businesses and all levels of government it's about being better prepared and having the ability and will to act collaboratively wherever possible we've got to make sure that resilience is not perceived as an inconvenience or a cost that gets in the way of living it is an inherent

essential part of living in the modern world of course our resilience is interdependent with that of our regional neighbors so we need to address also not how we look just after our resilience but how do we help our neighbors improve theirs so this interdependent partnership will be a foundation for building resilient and trusted supply chains and it's not just a matter of the supply chains that we receive should be trusted we have to demonstrate and show to countries that will depend upon us not only for day to day trade but in a crisis that we can be trusted as well so that technology has to apply I note last year's discussion of verifying and having trusted supply

chains in mean exports is a good example of that so what are we doing the Institute Archana we're working on a national resilience project in collaboration with another think tank in Sydney global access partners mm-hmm what we're trying to do is to make a contribution for conversation we're going to have to have in Australia and offer some constructive suggestions on where we as a nation need to head when we emerge for the pandemic crisis sometime next year we hope the challenge we're going to face then is building the next generation economy more resilient societal systems and thus improved sovereignty and security so a couple key things that are coming out in

our project the first is you can't be resilient and prepared and if you've done a comprehensive risk and vulnerability analysis and so we're going to take that home affairs profiling strands of vulnerability report and try and expand that a little bit to look at unnatural disasters we have to identify what are the sovereign capabilities knowledge and skills with which we have to have a degree of self-reliance in a time of crisis like we're going through now and also where is it proved to be able to guarantee a degree of domestic supply we then have to look at the critical supply chains that will be depending on global sourcing and how are we going to make those trusted transparent and verifiable

those capabilities of systems also which open glass supply chains should be maintained and encouraged but necessary to have the same trust level I don't need to guarantee that t-shirt coming in on time but what the corn falls to develop an integrated national sovereignty or resilience framework strategy an action plan based on that risk analysis that addresses what is critical to our way of life and the functioning of our society and then determines how to build it this will take time and it will cost us but we're going to have to convince the Australian public if we keep going for the lowest cost take critical supply chains offshore lose our skill sets then in a major crisis the price is something

that we don't want to be now implementing the plan is going to be a challenge because it will take an integrated model collaboration across all levels of government industry the public and private sectors and community organisations now we've seen a very good example of how that's worked to date in managing the early phase of the pandemic how to take that model of cooperation and apply it into the future is going to be a challenge but we're going to have to face reality we can't for example isolate ourselves or quarantine ourselves from the global economy so even though we can do that to a degree for the pandemic we're going to have to face the reality of dealing that hopefully a vaccine emerges but in the

way that we're going to have to deal with the economic crisis we can't quarantine ourselves it's not going to go away and we're gonna have to face that reality what can you do I think in the industry sector you're in you've got a technology that could certainly be a key player in looking at that trusted supply chain area and that is something we're gonna have to find now it's gonna be a real challenge for the political system to address this because it's often hard for a politician to go hey here are risks and vulnerabilities because some smart character in the media will go why haven't you fixed it well you haven't fixed it because the world's a complicated place and we've been caught by surprise we Australians need to insist that our

politicians do address this we can't be truly resilient unless we're prepared and we can't be prepared and if we take an honest look at our risk and so a paper that covers what I've said today is on the website and I'm happy to take any questions if you want to do that better thank you for sure for sure and thank you thank you so before we go any further and for those who are not familiar with thumbs own there is a reactions think when you actually can clap without making lots of noise if you want to do it that way too

so yeah so are there any questions for John I'll throw it out John I know blockchain technologies are relatively new and they're relatively new to you but one of the most interesting areas expiration in the technology doesn't have to do with the technology itself but the social ramification of the technology and that is being able to create a technical environment in which

the system itself is unsuitable you might be able to cheat the on-ramps but the underlying technologies have have not been broken to date and that's by design this allows us to set up systems of social trust where before social trust was hard to come by certainly in the current world social trust is often hard to come by the technology community is telling the supply chain community that this is an opportunity because supply chains are

full of people who don't know each other don't trust each other have economic incentives not to trust each other have economic incentives not to trust authority don't even necessarily wish to trust national authorities and their in national authorities aren't necessarily central to this bloodshed so it seems to us that there's a natural fit here but we always run into these chicken and egg issues where sometimes technology is a a notional solution to a problem but it's not a practical solution to the problem

because of politics or extending existing financial interests or what have you so with all of that said where do you think the opportunities lie for things like supply chain management supports and where do you think Australia is challenged in taking up that kind of new technology in front of countries like the United States or the UK or can there are other places where we typically bought solutions that have

been proven elsewhere I think your opportunity in this holler is because we're in a crisis Australians tend to be a bit too complacent so until they get a crisis yeah she'll be right don't worry about we've had it good for 30 years it's not a problem and that then bleeds through our political level I think what we're seeing right now is a fundamental loss in confidence and a fear factor that's visceral so we're reacting pretty well but trying to solve the longer-term problem is going to be a challenge so if you have this conference last year what I say to you is the chance of hooking this into a public narrative that explains to people the significance of

this would have been much harder last year than it's going to be now and next year so I think you've got the opportunity to put it out there because the expectations of our politicians dealing with us right now fairly unrealistic you see what's happening in Victoria there now when I hang the PM no the premier which is crazy when we see the next stages of the rest of the supply chain problems because we haven't got at the bottom of those and we see the problems in getting the vaccine and the global distribution because someone like America buys everything up then this is going to create a huge emotional surge in the country so the opportunity is there to highlight where the technology fits the challenge you're going to have is being able to tell the

story the narrative in simple English that somebody who doesn't have a technical background can understand because I think you need to create an understanding that your technical solution to this is fundamental to having a more resilient and trusted supply chains the Prime Minister was using the trusted supply chain language in Parliament two weeks ago I'm sure he doesn't know what it means but it was using him so I think the opportunity is there you're gonna face the challenge of every other deep technical expert hands you don't speak English so you're going to probably need some allies there were storytellers narratives people from the

art syrup' to try and put this into a simple story but this is what the world looked like today and while we're having these problems and why you've got counter feeding of drugs I'd particularly pay up on the medicines one because that is that this real problem for people today and you tell the story this is why you've got a problem now here's a picture of the world in two years time or a year's time with these types of technologies this is what the difference it makes so that mother who's about to put a pill or a drug down a child's throat so that's sick individual who's about to take a medicine or someone who needs a critical medical treatment you need to put that story out there and what a

difference it can make but whilst there are still problems having an ability to have transparent and trusted supply chains changes this dynamic we're far better off than our neighbors I think a study that was done about Papua New Guinea's drug area 40 I think percent of basically there with either unusable or counterfeit now thankfully we're far better than that here but there are counterfeit drug problems going on even in Australia our distribution of temperature controlled drugs is problematical I know her study in the Northern Territory that a significant proportion of the temperature controlled drugs and vaccines are not maintained at that temperature during distribution and

therefore they're not going to be effective when they used you have the technology that with the appropriate sensors can help us track things like that so crisis is the opportunity fear is going to be the motivating factor from the public your challenge is to turn your story into a narrative that can be understood it can even be taught yeah by the talkback radio hosts well so we've got to do something about this but I think it's the time is about right where they might listen thank you thank you John are there any other questions

not a problem thanks for the opportunity to talk to you guys as I said I've certainly learned something in reading about last year's conference and some your preparations in here I think you've got an important message to be on the cell so good luck with sending it and it's taken me over the last seven years to try and get the message out there about fuel security it's not an easy journey but I think it's an important one for you sorry John before you go we've actually got someone who'd like to pose a question Sly's got his raised his hand to ask your questions it's like do you want to go here yeah we should be putting our hand up to ask questions do you have any more information on the actual six of

the things like toilet paper is quite silly because if you went to the shop early in the morning every morning they restock it early in the morn they're always stuff there but why do you know of any deaths that occurred from being able to purchase medicine or from taking counterfeit drugs and muscle what you mean by counterfeit you mean like drugs it actually made out of baking soda or something yeah so there's an Australian manufacturer up in Sydney or pharmaceuticals they are making pretty much best both specific funds for export they have found counterfeit medicines so medicines that don't have the proper

ingredients in them packaged up put in their package and being sold in Asia so that's one example the other problem then comes as quality control so back in I think 2008 in MonaVie not knowing there was a drug called heparin that was being produced out of China it's an anticoagulant a blood thinner and it's essential for operations what had happened it's made from pig intestines and there was contamination in the in the pig farming in China it eventually made its way into the drug testing wasn't done properly I think was about a thousand deaths or something like that happened in the US and a lot of people were seriously ill from it and so there are plenty of examples of contamination

in the chain that doesn't get detected people start dying in Australia I went to one of the big medicine lobby groups and said I'm big concern from what I'm reading at Google now with our Institute we have doctors and fellows there we're running a Health Study as a part of our national resilience project with about 20 health professionals Lisa from the pharmaceutical industry from hospital pharmacists doctors surgeons academics and there is a concern about how you validate it but when I spoke to one of the industry representatives they said to me well if there was a problem in Australia we'd be seeing deaths so the fact that we haven't got deaths identified to a drug therefore there's no problem with testing and I thought at first they must have come from the Buddy

tobacco industry by telling me that because there is a problem according to our doctors with inadequate testing so we take a lot on faith we can test within Australia and we do sample testing but nowhere near enough so yes there are examples of overseas of deaths there are known shortages that are critical we ran out of epi pens and EpiPen Junius about a year and a bit ago try telling a parent that there's no EpiPen junuh for their child who's got you know a potential life-threatening allergy problem so right now when I last checked we had 580 medicines in short supply on the TGA list and 70 or 80 of those were critical ones critical for

our health so is there down to about this that resulted from it no there are a number of cases in depth after Australia there are a number of cases overseas for it and you can see something so when you look at the report online I referred to our Institute if you go to that website we have a report there which is about Australia's medicine supply chain using a lot of analysis over the US so you can get some examples there is no shortage globally of reports about contamination and counterfeiting of drug supplies and being in mind that we're not even import dependent that's a problem for us in addition we don't mandate minimum stock holdings

so whatever the industry decides to do we do if you are in Finland they mandate between three and ten months of medicine stocks for 57 medicines now the very time depends on their shelf life and they pay industry to hold those stocks so if you have a supply chain interruption you know you've got somewhere between three and ten months for supply before it gets critical the other issue for us is not just quality of medicines or counterfeiting or anything else like that it's understanding the supply chain what is happening in the supply chain is there a disruption how might this impact us we do not have a model of our medicine supply chain so we don't understand it if we can get that and

then verify it and also have visibility of the supply chain I think your technology's pain doorkeeper there if you haven't got the information about a supply chain then an interruption will come as a surprise but for a country that doesn't mandate stock holdings it's going to come as a dangerous surprise and right now the shortages of the drugs that we need to run a ventilator than intubation ventilator is significant we may have gone from 2,200 ventilators to four and a half thousand and we're heading up beyond that but a TGA study said that if we could get 25 percent more of those three critical drugs than we did last year before the pandemic we could treat 200 covert patients a month

on top of normal surgeries what's the point of having four and a thousand ventilators if you haven't got visibility of the key drugs you need to use them that's the situation we're in so there's a whole bunch of dimensions and data to justify this and the examples there for you to be on the telling story are plentiful all right so thank you John for answering those questions so if you've got further questions for John I encourage you to go to the slack Channel and discuss there so Alicia you're on the call I believe I'm here okay hello hello and welcome so I'll give you a

very quick introduction so elysia false wrong and I hope haven't destroyed your name there Alicia is the managing director of fixed income and head of sustainable investment at Pine Bridge investments she's done many things she's been to Harvard not Harvard Stanford and MIT yeah and she's been a author of co-author of more than one book which is very impressive very impressive so I will hand it over to you I'll share your slides for you so that they will be shared and I'll give you control as well

wonderful well thank you Peter David Sandra Corson and became a consensus on one second I think Ray got interrupted here you go you should have control now I need a kid I may need to ask you a trip some somehow my system if you don't mind do you mind Peter no I'll do it I'm so sorry not a problem at all okay awesome thank you

well first of all again as I was saying Peter David Sandra and all the team at consensus thank you for having me join the discussion today and greetings to you all from New York as Peter mentioned so good evening for me I'm gonna read about my background on top of what you know Peter just share or that I will describe what sustainable responsible investment means and how it is relevant not only in supply chain and supply chain data but to build towards a sustainable future in the recovery planning host : and what he means during our conversation nevertheless what I wanted to tell the

community today the supply chain on blockchain conferences that I'm a firm believer that technology would play a significant role in the coming years to build tools that really leverage the right set of data and as John was just mentioning what is the kind of data and where is the narrative behind it in this case the question I'm addressing with you today is it comes from the lens of financial institutions and how will financial institutions integrate the environmental and social impact of products the day investing starting from existing supply chain dynamics that as we heard from John clearly are context dependent country venom but they you

know Kobe has shown us how they're all so intertwined so the second part of the discussion I will make sure to highlight why blockchain solution developers should actually pay attention to to all of this so we have 20 minutes together the first half of the time I will devote to discuss big picture sort of view and the urgent need really to design sort of smarter and stronger and more diverse supply chain as being clearly one of the main lessons of the pandemic but we will do both procurement and trade and now they have shifted gears dramatically but also the

important focuses on Netherlands and again the investor lands like myself which are increasingly during Corbett looking at transparent traceable comparable environmental and social factors within supply chains and how that is likely to create severe headwinds - supply chain design unless technology solutions are actually built with an eye on investors insights and the evidence I will bring comes from the natural rubber supply chain and our debt as evolved there has been effective to link of it which I think you will find very interesting then the second half of this session we will be discussing how blockchain developers can help bring both clarity but also

commercial solutions today issue how responsible investors will continue to need to manage supply chain risk top-down as opposed to how it's currently done which is bottom-up so led by provenance but let's get to that you know in in a mode they believe thank you okay next so we just you know if we think for a moment of the procurement lens and how could we discharge all the supply chain of basic commodities and other goods upside down for me the way to describe procurement lens from the investor perspective is that I continue to see a bumpy road supply and demand

shot clearly if we had to go back and this is just a short snapshot of the situation between January and April of this year but when you're thinking about all multinational corporations clearly they face an initial supply shock then we have had a demand shock as more and more countries obviously over people to stay home and then you've had governments and businesses and individual consumers basically struggling to procure basic products and materials by the way creating bottlenecks due to the attempts to procure outside of the traditional in established networks and that has been an underlying problem about sort of

a gray market for procurement right they did I'd like to refer to is from trade shift freely available on the web is a global platform for supply chain management and it really looks at the magnitude of impact on both trade and demand which has led the bottlenecks that I'm sure in this chart again I'm showing the US UK and they you and and how that followed a an initial drop of twenty six percent at the very beginning of April but that is on the back of China and now China domestic and internal trade transactions suffered a significant drop week over week almost fifty percent drop beginning mid February now when we look at the US UK

in Europe by the time that bottlenecks in procurement hit China it took almost seven to eight weeks to get to the US today you get under the U so we have to keep that in mind when we think about the broader commodity cycle next slide please now we said there's two sides right of the contraction and one we address this is procurement we don't use bumpy road of supply and demand and the other hinder is just trade on itself right number one two side effects of the contraction in trade in global trade has been number one it takes longer to

settle an invoice and that's purely in economic terms right we heat faster payments across the procurement cycle right before the crisis on a year-over-year basis so global supply chains when they got to the end of 2019 we're actually settling average business is thirty six point seven days to settle an invoice which was huge if we just look year-over-year or three-year time now in the first quarter of 2020 then average payment turned earth basically reason up adding 23 days to that for any is just to settle now add to that that the lack of orders that were coming

through the supply chains that always is exacerbated that trend and new orders were slowing down any voice is also dropping off so when we take a look at that clearly we have an essential takeaway just by looking at China alone and when the lockdown in Wuhan was lifted factories may be reopening but consumers are in buying and so that that's essential because the third point here is also the concept of reputation right China's reputation as the factory of the world why is it causing problems because many of the conscious trading partners have remained in lockdown in China's economy is predominantly fifth

fifth of their GDP experts so orders are flatlining still in the u.s. other key trade partners like the UK and many of the European bloc countries are also in the same trend so if it's really that far at the moment whether China can orchestrate our recovery of the supply chain and trade purely on its own terms and that's essential regardless of the country where you're sitting so clearly what happened then you know it becomes a choice between self preservation and supplier solvency right for many of the multinational companies and the reality of this crisis then has presented the stark choice right between meeting your quarter meeting your even your own

financials and instead making sure that your suppliers at least in the tier one mode are actually so on in the u.s. we've had the case for example of Unilever where their US subsidiary pledged to pay their suppliers early very early on this year now not all consumer products companies have done that and you know we don't really know what the future will look like next slide please now but let's think about possible pandemic for a second right let's let's go on on a little bit of positive what has gone up and this chart is is impressive to me it has been a turning point for people

that are operating in my field responsible investors responsible investors that are driving the next generation of investment flows and they rely on the impact of environmental and social practices to address the value of trade what does that mean it means that sustainability focused investors have attracted a record amount of capital at the same time that you have had all these issues in supply own decisions in demand all these issues in the value of trade globally and in the first quarter of this year they have raised almost 56 billion of new money put to work in funds that are looking to invest in environmental and social leaders across

the globe or to stay away from environmental and social losers in a way and again there are a variety of ways in which investors implemented strategies globally but when you think about the global capital markets we have seen an outflow of almost 400 billion at the same time well sustainable funds have flown in 46 billion in their parts where are they coming from right well 80% of that has gone to index funds these are funds that utilize data to build their strategies and here I go back to supply chains data is a key driver of growth and access to information for these investors and these investors as John

has referenced before they they're not going to be able to parent on themselves from economic recovery and clearly economic recovery there are based on procurement and are based on trade are for the most part driven by supply chain health and sustainability next light please now but again let's let's go back to to discuss how is sustainable investing linked to supply chains right okay so we have two sides right I tried here two to share in a way a supply chain you know on the Left you'll find all the activities that are found in developed markets and and

the right side in emerging markets so they think about think about the two parts of the world on the left you have developed markets so where 70% of companies and you have from four to five hundred to smaller companies and private companies seventy percent of these companies struggle with Prada lifecycle management decisions in their products or in their services so these are decisions that are surrounding what product to place in which shelf for how long and when to restart to substitute on the shelf products or services now in the other end emerging markets rely for ninety percent merchants market countries are dependent from procurement and from the procurement cycle of

developed economies so again we discussed China's example we're thinking about manufacturers or even a engineer Pro Goods and other markets for commodities right so both developed economies and emerging economies are suffering as a result of the headwinds in procurement and trade during Kovan yet they're both seeing a surge in responsible investment funds and practices okay that's great is it in addition to the environmental focus that we see in the headlines many of these funds having the emphasis on corporate responsibilities toward all stakeholders which include employees and suppliers is likely to grow and i and i want to really stress that the suppliers whole here this is not a trend

this is sustainable business practices are here to stay and I'm here to say in what terms in terms of traceability and accountability of goods and services in terms of how that is connected to environmental and social footprint of the goods that are transported or a transfer in the procurement cycle and also in the merging certifications that are linked to obviously auditing standards and and there are more and more becoming known next time please now I'll give you a quick example that I did a had during during the month of April in the natural rapper ecosystem and in the natural rubber market and I'll show

you how it's an example of destructive forces actually now during the pandemic natural rapper smallholders and plantations that are mainly in Southeast Asia in Africa and in Latin America suffered from heating demand in a commodity market that went home it hit was mainly driven by the use of rapper in tire manufacturing so highly correlated to our mobile production cycle now keep in mind Coby strikes and the natural rubber price precoded had already reached an all-time low and was a that was the very first decline in demand for over a 10-year

cycle approximately for a kilo natural rapper was hit by one point 35 US dollars per kilo that before Cohen so think for a moment that you need two kilos of natural rubber to manufacture one car tire and almost three times that amount for a truck okay and globally that the market is a billion higher demand random now that's interesting when you look at the use of block chain solutions that are not being widespread in an industry like that predominantly as bondholders and small landowners have been switching the commodity in their plantation cycle they've been choosing

very quickly to follow the highest yielding one and choosing creating basically a lagging data that car manufacturer we have in their supply chains of natural rapper for they're using in in the tire that that we're ordering so that obviously had hindered comparability of information received now the carbon disruption particularly on the natural rapper a market included you know the travel restrictions we know the global auto manufacturing slowdown and then you had this lack of economic incentives to keep plantation workers maintaining natural rubber as opposed to switching for example to coffee beans or something else now on the other hand though you had

responsible sourcing practices there and not being put on hold during joven if anything they needed intensified so we didn't defy the merging use cases including medical supplies we had seen not just headlines but real data supplying rubber gloves and importance of you know the demand of rubber globes so quickly the natural rubber that was not going into filling the demand for four tires and four automobile manufacturers went into medical supply the medical supply chain so incrementally those regional stakeholder initiatives when starting to support during kovat with local government intervention for example measures I have seen utilizing the market come from Thailand where Thailand themselves at

pledge to support demand for natural rubber by utilizing it in road construction and looking at an innovation like rubberized alpha as an India that has pledged to deploy natural rubber for the construction of Riverside rubber embankments that they use so on the other hand you had other governments that for example Vietnam that I proceeded to convert all the operational natural rubber to industrial land use technically not favoring that as far as a sustainable part of their economy right so most use cases though that we see like the one in natural lapper connect the dots with the Tier one

suppliers which are pre identified and they don't go past Tier one so when you actually shut down natural rubber operations because you're not you're not data to support comparable information or shipping or place of provenance you're actually only you actually only know that here one suppliers you can tell the repercussion on past Tier one that you are creating and so clearly when you take this into consideration you also have to realize that if you're a chief procurement officer probably according to Deloitte you only have six percent of all chief procurement officers that feel that they have a good understanding of what their supply chain last year one and that's important and

one of the one of the use cases obviously as as Janice pointed out we've seen in the u.s. is not only combating kind fit drugs but also medical devices right and the origin of the medical devices now next next slide please so we are briefly what are the Paris and the Paris - this is investors clearly are recognising the need that there is a broader set of technology solutions such as application on blockchain obviously but it may still be in early stages of development so it's not a silver bullet yeah and you may see critics that grow very broadly making statement as you know this is a hammer for meals and

others instead say that is an internet based technology and therefore you have a high energy use that may you know maybe country in country in to depend and not supplying the right amount of comfort to sustainable investors nevertheless nevertheless the outstanding question from investors are is blockchain still an experiment that is relegated to the process of tracking without much to offer to companies to pin instead to evaluate environmental service or risk within the supply chain or is it ready to offer a comprehensive responsible sourcing solution right I would say next slide please that the biggest opportunity is actually beyond

traceability and beyond place of origin and that's the biggest opportunity leading to adoption because they appeal to investors of an encrypted immutable ledger of transactions that they can access in chronological order it's something appealing to investors nevertheless what are the questions that investors are looking to answer when we need to promote additional investment in this area provenance needs to incorporate or start incorporating environmental and social footprint sample metrics recording in the same fashion as a smart contract and if the foot dream doesn't pass the preset standard then somehow it gets rejected or something similar in that

fashion the use of blocks to link to pricing of a commodity waited waiting for environmental and social behaviors it's clearly relevant and you know the idea that I place out there for developer is one if a ledger it provides a value that is then used to set the responsible price for the commodity itself which can fluctuate to stabilize the commodity market to a fair price for own stakeholders next slide please now so out and blockchain develops yourself and sorry if I held you tight for 10 10 slides before getting here

so I'll make my prediction here the next five years will be key for the adoption of block chaining to diligence practices of investors again the capital is there and it's a growing amount has to deal with again environmental and social footprint up products they have to go beyond the Tier one suppliers where you have responsible sourcing that clearly will drive adoption so capturing sourcing attributes behind what we currently have or traceability and provenance now the open question is what are these due diligence questions that investors will likely pose they fall into three categories first of all implementing environmental assessments so anything that has to do with facility

records permitting waste storage leak detection things like that human rights assessment second category of information that would be extremely it's crucial to commodities market that operate through or that can be trackable to blockchain technology like hiring workplace environment think about debt service conditions of proof of age accessibility right and training in the capability building what is the company doing right in terms of ensuring that you know environmental in women our assessments are actually taking place now I leave it with the idea that currently blockchain works from the bottom up of the supply chain right from traceability up to the finished product so they refine the

source of each component but what is missing is the ability to manage the top down so assessing the environmental and social business practices of suppliers where you start with your direct suppliers and then cascade down your supply chain so that allows that to map out all the supply chain while minimizing disparities the elements of trust obviously that are inherent of in blockchain technology will help friends tell their story so when we're thinking about the narrative and how the narrative is is important and that story will obviously it has to resonate on environment and social terms with customers and in many cases the kind of questions investors are asking clearly

I'm not designed for storing on blockchain Ledger's but I believe a hybrid probably blockchain and traditional approach will likely be optimal in the future thank you and I would open up for questions thank you and yes let's all use their clap emojis so thank you very much are there any questions and the last line is my email if you want to put in there as well or all right I've got a reshare sorry there we go yeah so are there any

questions okay I've so I've got a question though I've got a question so all of the I mean in in the first slide there there were all these first few slides there were these rollercoaster of supply and demand shocks happening do you think that as you know so in the USA which is where you live so at the moment I think Florida has got the highest daily total you know and I mean at some point Schumi you can keep the testing up maybe the US will have half a million a day you know

new cases or something crazy like that will will that slow demand down more or will people just get you get oblivious to the number of cases and just keep on as life as if nothing's happening and we'll we'll the supply and demand just level out what do you think is gonna happen it's interesting I think not only is unpredictable I I would say that people are already starting in this process of being oblivious to what is happening this is the unfortunate reality we live in clearly there has to be there has been a dramatic push by different administration on keeping

domestic supply chain open without probably putting too much effort in securing the international supply chain obviously that would be a terrible roadblock going forward the u.s. nor any other country can afford to be a government of its own and and not having any trade relationship with anyone you know when you go back on the pharmacy shelves what I found masks are made in China okay now you find that in every single pharmacy right from and they're very fancy and sophisticated five layers five please and there are

king-size and all of it right so we are dependent on that those masks and every new product that is on the shelf at a regular pharmacy in New York City is not made in the u.s. necessarily right it's not me necessarily in Canada or out of country so I think the current state of the world obviously is not something that people think it's gonna be I believe people think it's temporary now I think the consumer is not necessarily realizing how much their inability to keep the invoicing up right an ordering right to make sure that obviously who they were there from keeps an invoice up is as important to keep their access continues to that particular cut right there's been a lot of grassroots

obviously movements right locally to make sure that local businesses would make it very apparent right to their customers if you don't order you know we won't be in business right I don't think necessarily that the u.s. consumer or to that respect any consumer in developed economies as clearly identified you know that that dependence on on supply chains and that's essential if we think about you know John's example of Finland that's pretty interesting I can tell you manic doodle evidence in February so China was what at the two-month or not even seven week of shut down in February tried to reveal a regular drug that you

can find a groceries for groceries or pharmacy Freddie they didn't have it and they claimed that it was due to you know Chinese supply chains being shut down so that's pretty telling it was immediately a just-in-time medication is not what you want are there any other questions yes we've got one in the chest from Tyler Tyler do you want to just and ask Alesia yeah sure great great chat thank you so much so my question is have you seen

anyone successfully tackle the top-down castigating approach so so so immediately needs no and that's where is the market opportunity and where that's where I'm a speaking to you all today I think it's essential to drive that it is what we drive those 40 billion a quarter being allocated in the right places to the right companies and to the right commodity markets so that's important and essential multinational corporations are realizing that they need that if you start looking at the disclosure even consumer you know products companies and the difference in that disclosure on their supply chain in the last five years you see it has gone from half a

page to ten pages long because clearly not only there are you know investors asking for more information but there are consumers and consumer related laws that obviously need to address environmental and social footprint of the product so especially if they try to operate in countries that are very progressive like you know the European bloc perfect answer and and I was I was half hoping you'd set me up because I'm gonna be speaking a lot about exactly this and how trium is tackling those problems in five minutes so awesome perfect all right well thank you very much for joining in your evening Alicia that was really really yeah exciting

interesting and I've learnt a lot so I know you're you're going to mean II need to be dropping I don't know sometime in the next half an hour hour or so so hopefully you can stay to the next break which is we're going to have a discussion breakout room session so um yeah but failing that please everyone do a LinkedIn thing with Felicia and then you'll be able to fire questions to your heart's content so now I'm going to be handing the floor over to Tyler Mulvihill but before I do I'll introduce him

so Tyler is the is a co-founder of trium do which is a blockchain based platform which helps businesses do essentially supply chain so build confidence in the traceability and track ability of goods he is a chair of the supply chain working group in the enterprise aetherium alliance and he advises fortune 500 companies and he's a CPA which is something I didn't know Tyler there you go you learn a new thing every day even about people you've worked with for years alright with that I'll hand it over to you so Tyler shall I just go Nick you go next slide and I'll move you

along is that good perfect yeah thank you Peter and thank you all for having me so I guess good morning for those of you in Brisbane and Australia in that part of the world and good evening for some of us in the US and other parts and good afternoon to the other remote people so this is a an eclectic group I love it calling in from just outside of New York so not as bad as Florida but I'm pretty hunkered down here but hope everyone's safe and healthy in whatever part you're calling in from so yeah Peter did a great introduction I try to learn all the languages Peter so the language of business with accounting in the language of computers with computer science and I don't know what I'll be on to next esperance and maybe language about everything but we'll say so you did a

good job setting me up so I co-founded tree and bad i/o will get into really what that is but my backgrounds in consulting so did a lot of custom supply chain application builds and that kind of got the group of folks that were building that to say hmm we're recognizing a pattern here low supply chains are a bunch of asset that's moving down a business workflow that has certain people being able to do certain things and if you can abstract that and create a business tool for business users that can just they they already know where the supply chains are broken they already know how they need to be more agile and they can build them themselves and there could be real business they're leveraging blockchain so that's what we embarked upon about three years ago and that has turned into a labor of love and something that's led

us on an incredible journey to kind of bring these organizations and companies into the web 3 world so it's been incredibly exciting and I'm here to talk to you today about the future of sustainable fly chains collectibles and luxury goods tokenization so kind of an amalgamation of supply chains which which we typically think of as a workflow along with how that kind of moves into building a product which then you can buy and trade and that kind of turns into a tokenization play so I hope you know we can learn something today and also see the world a little bit differently if you have any questions comments you want to get on gonna get on a call and a chat and ask questions and talk about the future all my informations down below and I can leave you my personal email in the chat as

well so feel free to peppering me with questions but I guess next slide all right so trium is essentially a business that helps businesses build trust with their consumers so we do this by bringing traceability transparency and trade ability to supply chains using blockchain technology so that's kind of our tagline but really why do businesses need to build trust with their consumers and their customers in my take I think it's because we're now living in a trust economy it's something that we haven't really seen before something that we haven't had to participate in but where we're at the beginnings of what I what I am labeling the trust economy because I can't think of any other way of thinking

about or talking about what we're experiencing now other than the trust economy digital is now boring we used to think that going from physical to digital and having a SKU number and being able to track things globally and having you know something show up on our doorstep in two days was was the future I don't think that is the future I think the future is not digital assets but programmable digital assets which really is is something a lot different most folks when they think about the difference I think in the future one person is going to be playing with something that is like a bundle of sticks and the other person is going to have a rocket ship at their command and and that kind of a window into the next new world and I think if they give the companies that get ahead of this and

start understanding how they can bring that programmability to the assets that are the products that that folks are buying are gonna be miles ahead so really unknowingly customers are demanding this digital fluency and this digital program programmability and and you can you can see this in a couple different forms so customers aren't asking folks to program things using blotching technology what they're asking for when I buy something I want to instantaneously put it for sale with its entire provenance history and I want to be able to sell it on Poshmark real real eBay I want to sell it in a second by snapping a picture digitally authenticating it with machine recognition image technology and if you don't provide that I will go to somebody

who does that is going to be the future that's gonna be the future of the circular economy that's gonna be the future of how we buy and sell things and it's just gonna be the general expectation like going to grocery store and being able to pay with your credit card so that's I think that's I think the future that we're living in and so we want to be kind of the the portal into web 3 for these businesses to help build trust with their customers so I think basically neck next decade is going to be about programmability and sustainable supply chains just like Alessi said just said in the in the previous um in the previous slide so if we go to the next slide Peter all right so if we look at a supply chain here this is kind of our version you're gonna

see probably ten of these throughout the day so apologies but in each of the stages of supply chain whether it's from raw materials to manufacturing and processing and and distribution to the actual product sale and then the aftermarket through each of these phases of a supply chain customers are asking questions and they're demanding answers instantaneously and verifiable the instantaneous and they have to be verifiable they're asking things like my other are the raw materials organic and show me the proof points behind those claims are they non-gmo during manufacturing was this manufactured and if you know you know in a sustainable or good Mandy's good manufactured practice certified

good manufacturer practice manufacturing facility sorry its bunch of jumbled words late at night when the product is being sold they won't know that the entire provenance in the history of that asset along the chain of custody and the secondary sales for jerseys or art or high-value luxury goods they want to know exactly when this was taken care of last when it was maintained when's the last time the watch was cleaned when the last time the handbag was certified and all of that has to be instantaneously verifiable so we defined really supply chains three different ways it's transparency traceability and trade ability so transparency really gives businesses the ability to tell their product narrative and what Alesi was

just saying is that many companies can't really even tell this simple story of backing up the claims that they're making so show me the organic claim the actual physical claim that's given out to every single person not only Tier one but all the way to tier at how do you actually do that today well it's you know through thousands of emails and thousands of the Excel spreadsheets and you try to integrate with the ERP systems and it just doesn't work so one of the things that really built is a transparency module that allows a business that wants to back up certain claims approved points to email their their first tier 1 level supplier and then have them email all their tier X suppliers have them email their tier X suppliers with certain requests they can upload them to the blockchain then that

can be presented eventually to the customer so it's aggregating all that information from a transparency standpoint so it's the easiest way to do testing inspection and claims management on the planet and we have customers using that right now which I'll get to in the in the latter latter sides of letter end of the slides from a traceability standpoint we talked about this in the forms of allowing businesses to tell your source narratives so this is about item and batch level tracking and showing the real like history who the farmer was where it was telling the story of the product and finally trade ability which is our ownership narratives so obviously a business process doesn't have to be often for sale buy sell offer for sale buy sell offer for sale buy sell that's a pretty

boring business workflow and really it's it's not really a workflow of what it is is buying and selling an asset so we also built a module our trade ability module which allows you to mint tokens offer them for sale authenticate them verify authentication trade them the typical stuff that you that you would expect for just traditional products but also non fungible tokens or entities from a blockchain perspective so really we allow businesses depending on where they want to start their journey to either start it from the raw materials standpoint and move downstream or start it from the aftermarket verifiability a trade ability standpoint and move back upstream you can really start whatever story you want to tell we have a module to was to support you so I hope these definitions are kind of

they're helpful it's really easy to get them convoluted when we're talking about traceability and really all you want is a proof point behind a claim that's a lot easier than in full traceability and that's something that companies also like to jump on to so how do I get started well it's easy just give somebody the bare minimum which is show me the proof that your stuff is organic and then which is a claim which is a proof point behind a claim or you can then go into the full digital transformation of tracking all of your ingredients so there's different ways to start different levels of effort and I hope that's helpful for your law so if we go to the next slide the reason we built these modules it's because we see a paradigm shift in consumer behavior from a value driven consumer which is

worried about price and convenience to a purpose driven consumer aligned with sustainability they want to see cut you can see these very easily with the statistics that are showing here 79 percent of consumers today state that it's important for brands to provide guaranteed authenticity like certifications when they're purchasing goods and this is a this is a survey done by a legitimate organization the National Retail Federation along with IBM with like 19 thousand participants so this is not a small survey so if we're talking about 79% of consumers also demanding authenticity but also almost nearly the same percentage willing to pay more an average premium of 30 37 % premium for those products

you can think about that in two different ways the first way is Wow there is if you take all of consumer goods for example of you know trillions and trillions of dollars and you times that by 0.37% that's what consumer products are leaving on the table right now because they can't prove these claims that they want to make even though half their supply chain is organic they don't know whether the other half is and that means they can't put the label on the box and they can't come in to premium so there's a whole bunch of money just it's it's roughly nine hundred ninety six billion euros which is a little bit more than the trillion USD s and that's from an extension report so another legitimate publication so you can either think about it from a leaving it on the table standpoint or you can think of it as of

oh my goodness there's a lot of products that are making these claims they can't back it up easily maybe it's true but they can't back it up which means summers are not gonna be willing to pay that premium very soon which means there's a fear factor of oh my goodness I might be missing out of this premium and my margin could shrink overnight because there's other brands that can make those claims and consumers are gonna vote with their wallet so these are pretty scary statistics especially for the current IT structure and systems that companies are typically using today and they're not elastic enough they're not agile enough to handle what's coming which is the demand for the consumer from a value driven consumer to a purpose driven consumer so if we go to the next slide so let's I want to tell a little story to make this sink in but

first I want to ask you a question and that is what global 100 most sustainable corporation in the world was ranked number two and I think it's gonna blow your mind obviously there's a million of these surveys out there so no take this for a grain of salt but this is a legitimate publication so if we go to the next slide the answer is it's Gucci baby I didn't think you thought that was coming although unless you saw the logo on logo and the the the prior slides bag they're winning the market it's serious growth obviously luxury goods have taken a hit because of kovat but a covetous side their growth year over year has been absolutely tremendous because they're focusing on the consumers wants

needs so for those of you who don't know gucci is part of the caring group it's a powerhouse and luxury industry they're one of the top three houses in the planet in 2017 the president and CEO marco outlined Gucci's ten-year culture a purpose sustainability plan in 19 in 2018 they joined the fur free alliance 2019 to give a million euros as a founding partner of UNICEF's girl empowerment initiative in 2019 they announced the missions offset plan to offer their missions by half by 2025 from supply chains to become carbon neutral so we're talking about a group we typically think of as somebody walking down a runway with a very

expensive bag half of us on this call would never even consider purchasing as now becoming and recognized as one of the most sustainable companies around I think you probably thought this I was gonna say Patagonia because Patagonia is now called Patty Gooch kepada Gucci because it's expensive luxury so we're not only seeing legacy companies responding to consumers and really benefiting from this we're also seeing new new ish luxury goods companies which I would consider Patagonia responding to the consumer in a similar but different way all telling the same story a little bit differently and both benefiting tremendously from a shift in the market so as part of the caring group gucci is encouraged and challenged by the group to deal with sustainability issues and

since Carrick caring has been tracking and analyzing all of their brands environment in environmental impact for years this was a little bit easier for them but I think this was this was a shock when I came across this and it's been one of the use cases that I've been focusing on because it really tells a story of not only these new brands that are coming up to disrupt these old dinosaurs but these old dinosaurs are these old dogs learning a new trick so if we go to the next slide what they're really showing here is just transition sustainability equals revenue Gucci is absolutely killing it and according to the CEO of caring group Gucci's parent company Millennials and Gen Z account for nearly 50% of coochies total sales so that's probably a shock to we think

normally you know our grandparents were walking around with Gucci food if they were lucky enough to or you saw other people's grandparents walking around with this stuff this is not something that traditionally you know Millennials will gen Z would even go after but they're nailing the market the response I think to these consumers demand these purpose-driven consumers that want to see sustainability messages that want to see people join the fur free alliance that want us they want to prove the fact that they've done all of this and now they're demanding more and more certificates of authenticity verifiable proof of ownership verifiable genuinity all of this stuff is coming down the pipeline extremely extremely fast and they've been rewarded for this so the sales were up 16% last year that's probably taken a tithe because of Coban and a double sales since in the period of 2016 to 2019 that's like unheard of

for a brand that size billion dollar-plus brand okay if we go to the next slide I changed this last minute because this I think this is a bit wrong I say luxury doesn't equal exclusivity because these gens II and Millennials aren't necessarily buying luxury because it's exclusive but they're really buying it because they have a passion and these brands have a purpose and they're buying into that feeling good about the fact that they are and it's a good quality product which means a lot of these folks are going to sell this on the secondary market eventually there's a booming industry of secondary markets that have appeared and I'll talk about that in the next slide but luxury goods secondary market actually it's a slide I'm reading

my notes on the side luxury goods secondary market is a twenty four billion dollar industry right now it's growing four times faster than traditional market meaning that where the growth is isn't selling this stuff the first time it's selling it the second time and the third time and the fourth time and brands right now barely have the infrastructure to sell this the first time and prove any of the stuff that I was talking about before let alone managing a circular economy supply chain which is something that we can talk about in another chat but it starts getting crazy when you when you think about how how brands can sell something that one time but ten times with almost zero marginal cost and the last point is the circular economy is here the the statistics of the fact that it's growing the secondary market is growing Forex

the traditional market is something you can't ignore that's an astronomical number in retail the issue is if you go to the next slide how our company's going to be responding to this unfortunately right now they can't I should have capitalized this and bolded this a study front by the sustainability consortium found that 81% of the seventeen hundred companies surveyed lacked full visibility into the CSR practices of their supply chain and 54% had no visibility at all that is an absolutely terrifying statistic when your consumers are knocking down the door begging you and actually demanding you for this information to buy and you have no idea how to respond because you have zero visibility into your supply

chain over 50 percent of zero visibility that that that's mind-blowing so using Gucci as an example and a surprise how can other companies learn from them and start tracking his stuff today so that by the time it's an absolute table stake it can respond and I think that's what we're talking about or the problem that we're trying to tackle from a training perspective so if we go to the last slide this is some of the companies that have been responding to their customers that trium has been working with if you look on the left side it's it's a company called holy cow skincare company that is bringing ingredient transparency to the consumer so if you have your iPhones or androids out or anything with a QR code reader you can actually scan all these and go

through the experience and see what ingredient transparency looks like you can also see with hemp traceability which we did which we built an entire agricultural track and trace platform with a company called verified organic we're tracking thousands of activities hundreds of farms ten thousand acre plus of Agriculture and we're moving very fast into the wheat space into the ancient grain space into the marijuana space it's a do a whole bunch of other organics and sustainable supply chains in agriculture with this platform and the last is memorabilia trade ability so we talked I talked a little bit of it in the beginning about collectability Sacramento Kings is an NBA basketball team in the US they're going to be part of the bubble if that's even still

happening in Florida so you know who knows how long that's gonna be around but we were tracking game-worn jerseys so if you're thinking about your favorite sports team watching them and your favorite player is having a good game you can actually bid live on their Jersey and along with that Jersey comes a certificate a digital certificate of authenticity it comes a digital token of ownership and the next step is for the secondary market of this to absolutely explode so you're gonna buy this Jersey you're gonna want to sell it you'll be able to instantaneously sell it not try to hock it on eBay along with the other 50 fakes or 500 fakes there there's a number here that I've come across many times but I feel still exciting because I can't believe it

could be true but it is it is sighted often that 90% of sports memorabilia is fake that means basically if you buy something you have a 10% 10% chance that that certificate of authenticity is real the person that you're buying from actually owned it first and that it's genuine and that is an opportunity that I've maybe never seen in my adult life so I think we've got 10 minutes left exactly if you go to the last slide it has it has all the information from myself if you want to email me I will put my email and chat right now and I see some questions coming in if Peter you want to start rattling them off I can certainly get them oh all them I'll

manage the the question time for speeches say to go perfect make a dream thank you so much Tyler that's been a really fascinating talk so I think before we start questions we'll all just give you a quick clap and then yes we've got a few questions as as you mentioned so Peter was saying that can accompany make money out of the secondary market and so the resale market for their products and a ratio commented on that saying that you know traditional argument for buying Apple has been eats and the resale value a perfect question I think absolutely so I think this is gonna be a two-phase approach the first approach is that if you eliminate fakes

in the marketplace you decrease supply whether it's legitimate supply or illegitimate supply the people that want to buy an Apple computer that are now buying god-knows-what with an apple case on it or somebody who wants to buy a Gucci bag and is settling for a secondary market that's fake and that you know they're taking the risk because it's 50 or $100 cheaper that's going to dry up because consumers are going to demand that certificate of ownership and authenticity before they make a make a purchase and I think all of the platforms that are emerging like the real rails and the posh marks and the eBay luxury department what they're gonna do is now they're there they are not going to accept these these Goods unless they have both of those things authenticity and ownership so if you eliminate supply what you're gonna end

up doing is you're the use market prices are gonna go up and then there's going to be a decision by a customer that's gonna say what do I really want to buy used want to buy the new thing because it's you know marginally more expensive I know that Apple they do refurbishments but the discounts even not not that heavy so I think apples in a pretty good job at creating that that secondary market from themselves from refurbished but not really done a good job protecting fakes in the marketplace and computers a bit different because you can you can see if they work when they turn on but you know a luxury handbag or something that doesn't have any electrical components is a bit difficult we're difficult to to kind of figure out so that's phase one phase two is that if you can program assets you can program

whatever you want so you can have a white list of of retailers and resellers that are able to sell your product to eliminate totally eliminate gray markets if you do that yeah you your price that you can you can command like incredible prices but what you can also do is you can say that any time a asset is traded this is going to all happen within smart contracts atomically so I give you my ownership token and you give us digital currency whether it's dye or ether or some sort of some sort of national currency digital network national currency and when the token and the money is in the same contract it swaps you know and and I get the token and you get the money and when that happens you can program something that says and ten

percent of that goes back to the original company so they can benefit without absolutely doing doing absolutely nothing but I guess there's a third phase to the third phase is is absolutely nuts which means I can start emailing tokens not people but the actual token certain incentives and as a user I'll be able to look up those those emails to tokens it's the best way I can explain it and it says we will give you 30% off your new iPhone which Apple already does but all these other brands don't do this and if you have a secondary sale they totally lose touch with who that person that they're trying to trying to email now but now they they have that that they have the channel they have that one-on-one relationship

with a token not the actual user so they can email that and say hey listen for a 30% discount by the newest one and give us the old one and then we'll refurbish it and sell it so you can feel good that yours is going to be resold and you can upgrade to something new and beautiful and you can actually track that refurbished one so that you can hold us accountable to make sure that that goes back in the market and now we can start seeing people get really really invested and companies to the point where they'll have ownership in the in the form whether it's stock or tokens or whatever you'll start seeing more co-op like companies because you want to be a part of these these wonderful beautiful moving organisms and supply chains will go out the window and will be supply mesh so long answer to your question but

I don't know it's a little late here so I thought I could go in a little ramp thank you very much for elaborating on that because that thing also talks to the comment that Alesia made regarding of instruction equipment where manufactures have profited from second V and reset markets for a long time because typically not going to go out and buy by track to everyday so it's a bit different to your Apple which is a Morse of consumer you know consumer what I think then it's those speaker ones but the thing that I was interested in is your comment about the consumer being sort of more moving from value driven to

purpose driven but then that has also got to surely link across to the ability to be able to make those sort of purchases so you know like so what I'm thinking is it it needs to almost be like in the context of what the economy is at the moment so if we look at what has happened with covert with people not showing where they employed in that sue thing you may have the desire to go down the this sort of Purpose Driven doing the right thing but the desire to do something the ability to do something may be two completely different things so I'd be interested to know how those

figures as well the stats might look if if a survey was done now or how that those sort of issues can be tricky handled uh suppose I think it's a fantastic question I would be interested in seeing the survey results as well but I think I think the point of the the value driven consumer is that prices it so they're willing to buy an Apple that was doused in s decides because it's cheaper and I think we as a consumer group have wised up to the fact that we're you're going to buy one organic apple rather than two pesticides apples and I think that instead of buying a shirt for you know three dollars will

buy a shirt for five dollars it said that it is organ or that is or instead of buying a shirt that's new for five dollars will buy a used organic shirt for two dollars so I'm not sure if if the goods will be priced lower in a secondary market or in a circular economy market but I would imagine that participating there has immense benefits so it's a good I think that's a great economic question to be honest way way above my pay grade something I need to learn more about I guess but I don't have a good answer for you though that's good what do you want to do what you're able to do depending on your you know situation this just putting food on the table and that sort of thing why you it's not as binary is that right but um but certain yeah

certainly more more price conscious folks right now but I don't know that's a good that's a good question let's take this offline let's let's uh let's like about this later that's a good question I have a good idea and also I Rafi Osteen to also looking to you know the concept of you know you've got something maybe that's being verified through the supply chain but then at one part might be changed how do you work that well yeah the simple answer is you have complete Providence and traceability so if I if I have a handbag and the handle gets changed out from from leather to hemp and I get that done at Gucci and Gucci

does that there was going to be a tech that does that or a person that works for Gucci that does that who certifies that they've done it they've taken pictures on a certain date they've uploaded that pictures they've uploaded that it's certified organic hemp the the proof point behind that claim and now that is you know time-stamped immutably on the supply chain with a cryptographic signature from a address that you can trace back through a Merkel tree back to Google cheese you know main hash hash reference so that's how it's going to be done in the future and we're actually doing that today with with the jerseys and a couple other items so just like the CARFAX I'm not sure if you guys have Carfax in in Australia but there's going to be plenty of I don't know maintenance history items or provenance history

items or chain of custody of almost everything we have it's gonna be a daily thing because you're gonna get more for your money later so yeah you're a price is not a price anymore a price is what you want to but would you pay now but not as what you're gonna get later so it's really hard to sell stuff right now some people are really great at it I'm terrible at it I got a whole closet full of stuff that would love to sell I can't do it because I'm too lazy or whatever it's not easy I don't think that people are gonna trust me that it's authentic it's I gotta meet somebody it's it's it's it's a mess but now companies are emerging to make this very easy and if you have that mean ancestry people are gonna buy your stuff they're gonna buy you ten out of ten

times over somebody else and that that practice is just gonna catch on and start mandating it's gonna be mandated by certain platforms and then it's gonna be part of our daily lives which I think it's gonna be wonderful so yeah I think right at the moment right it's the last minute we are we are so thank you very much or Sandra facilitating and Tyler for your very insightful talk so thank you thank you guys yeah you see so [Music]