Richard Werner on how CBDC could be the end of banking and on the Sovietization of Europe
De Week van Bitcoin · 7 Jun 2022 · 1:11:05
Professor Richard Werner, author of Princes of the Yen and originator of the Quantity Theory of Credit, returns to talk with Paul Buitink about the European Central Bank. He argues that regulation and monetary policy have squeezed small community banks, with about 5,000 banks disappearing since the ECB began, while fuelling asset bubbles and inflation. They discuss retail versus wholesale CBDC, China's approach, gold, and his Valhalla Network of community banks, with the Worgl local currency experiment of the 1930s as an example.
Speakers
Topics
From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.
Transcript
hello everyone my name is paul bioting i'm very pleased to have professor richard werner on again we talked two years ago when we talked about uh how the ecb is trying to become the only bank in town and i really want to understand more about how that would work and to what extent uh the ecb is achieving that goal richard he's the author of princess of the yen a best-selling book he also came up with the quantity theory of credits he coined the the term qe and he just he's working on a lot of things also a new decentralized community bank network so we're going to talk about all of that uh thanks so much richard for being on again welcome thanks thank you for having me again it's a pleasure
yeah first of all let me apologize uh to you and the viewers because last conversation two years ago i interrupted you a lot i got a lot of negative feedback about this so sorry about that no worries no worries maybe there was also like a delay in con in the connection or something but um so yeah last time we talked about um the ecb and and especially also about the concept of revealed intents and you said you have to judge a person or an institution by its actions and not so much by its words and if we look at the actions of the ecb we've seen over the past few years thousands of banks have been wiped off the map especially in countries like
holland and so i want to know we talked last night two years ago have things changed are they still on their way to become the only bank is that still their intent their their goal i think there's no change in the fundamental goal and essentially the ecb has adopted a um a long-term policy of attrition where they've been forcing banks in the euro zone um onto their knees by fundamentally two things one is regulation the regulatory burdens have increased significant european banks are small banks very
small banks um and the ecb has made essentially through most of that time period no exception for small banks so they've had to meet the same reporting requirements as the the super largest banks and for for those uh for who essentially these regulations were made and particularly after the 2008 crisis and the argument was well these big banks they messed up so we need tight regulations tough regulations for all banks well the majority of banks are small banks and it was particularly the community banks local banks small banks cooperative banks savings banks
that were absolutely fine particularly in countries like germany um switzerland you know they they had absolutely no problem they were not involved in the the mess that that caused the 2008 crisis and of course this second point is monetary policy and that itself was even responsible for the 2008 crisis but anyway so but they they forced all these small banks to meet these super high uh standards of reporting which are extremely costly that's the biggest problem for the small banks you know if you've got 20 staff you're a small bank a small balance sheet it's all very much under control but suddenly you need to hire one or maybe two more people
just to do this new regulatory reporting that's required it just adds huge costs to them and you know staffing costs are the biggest costs um and and so for for many of those banks and so they had they were forced to merge and we hear this again and again and this pressure has continued so since the ecb started business 5 000 banks disappeared and it's not the big ones in the us there's a different regulatory regime namely the small banks get different rules and the argument is well you guys are small you're not systemically relevant you don't pose a systemic threat to the system because you're very small and local
so hey let's have simpler regulation as we've had in the past you know regulations become more burdensome more complex over time more and more and more and more and more um and the very big banks are able to manage this but for small banks you know that's it's just impossible and also totally unnecessary in the us is best evidence of that that you can have a separate regulatory regime in fact an entirely different regulator don't even report to the same regulator and that is very much necessary in europe but the ecb so far has refused that in recent years they've said okay we'll do tiny tiny adjustments for small banks
and small loans and they they slightly change the capital adequacy risk weights for um business loans to small firms and things like that but these are minor changes in tinkering overall that's been one of the big policies to just make life very expensive very difficult due to regulation and reporting and bureaucracy incredible bureaucracy for banks the second pillar is monetary policy they adopted a policy of squeezing banks profits banks make profits by essentially taking deposits and you get
lower interest rates or for current deposits you know current counts zero interest on those and then they lend out uh money at least that's what it looks like if you look at one bank at one moment in time we'll talk about the um what's going on behind the scene there but in terms of the profits it is actually this margin between the interest rate of taking deposits and lending out money at high interest rates and essentially they squeeze both um and particularly on the lending side long-term interest rates have been pushed down um even
even just yesterday today we we well today we hear that um ecb is um wants to continue to intervene in the bond markets to push down long-term interest rates or keep them down now it's quite extraordinary because we've had two years of massive monetary expansion we'll talk more about that and then what has happened in the last two years and and as i warned um already two years ago you know we were going to get inflation because the way they did it is very different from 2008 they massively expanded credit for consumption for purchases and while not increasing the amount of
goods and services available but just increasing demand and money buying things because you are pushing up prices that's the inflation we're getting now it's a monetary phenomenon don't believe them when they talk about oh it's the war it's russia well this was actually caused uh from february march 2020 onwards with this concerted monetary policy of massively injecting creating injecting new money used for consumption so of course inflation goes up that means interest rates you know inflation is nominal phenomena interest rates nominal will be pushed up but the ecb now wants to step in and prevent that and already two years ago they said crazy stuff like oh
we see that uh bonds you know bond prices are going down yields are going up interest rates are going up we need to step in and do something what are we going to do let's buy more bonds now but with the central bank buys bonds that means it's printing money why are we having this bond you know yields going up interest rates going up because of inflation why is there inflation because of money printing and what's been their solution oh let's let's buy more of these bonds then we can push you know um down um you know support the bond markets you know um but actually they're creating more money which is really just gonna um
cause more inflation which means um actually ultimately the bond market will reflect that and um bond prices will fall even though the ecb is trying to push up bond prices by just being the main buyer of bonds um but the side effect of this crazy policy of the ecb manipulating the bond markets massively by you know buying one's pushing up on prices and therefore keeping down the yields that worried about italy in particular which has a lot of debt and refinancing costs uh an issue there so
um the corollary of that policy um on the one hand has been to fuel inflation particularly asset price inflation already before um the recent 2020 policies you know since 2008 they've been really fueling asset prices by um forcing banks to mainly move into asset lending but it's also undermined traditional banks that lend to businesses because you are squeezing their their margins because then the loan um interest rate has also been pushed down together with bond market interest rates and it's essentially that the ecb has made it not very profitable to be a traditional bank that helps small firms and lends for productive purposes which
is the sound thing to do because when when the banks mainly lend for productive purposes um lending to small firms for business investment that's very sound you essentially you won't get a banking crisis you won't get a problem and you also won't get inflation if you mainly have money creation banks lending for these productive business investment purposes you get economic growth job creation but the ecb policy mix has essentially made that unattractive and forced the banks to lend for asset purchases grading as asset inflation which of course is unsustainable will lead to a banking crisis is unavoidable and
of course there are ways to stop that if they want to but you know we can talk about that but it looks like you know blowout is um is is more likely what they want to they're certainly in this phase where they've been creating this acid bubble um and inflation as since 2020 which was the new measure um they were also creating money for consumer spending therefore we now have general consumer price inflation but meanwhile the banks and their traditional business and the small banks are mainly traditional members were squeezed out and so they're more and more we're forced to to merge so it's it's quite a disastrous policy mix but i've seen it time and again you know
when i was uh looking at japan as the book princess of the yen details the it's quite astonishing how over a long time period um decades 20 years 30 years the the string of policy mistakes of bad policy is so consistent that if you want to write a script how to completely blow up an economy and then that is the one of many many policy options the one string of policies you take and that seems to be what they're taking time and again at the um the bank of japan is pioneers in the ecb has been a great admirer of bank of japan policies
and by the way the book is somewhat hard to find um people always ask how to get it there's some very expensive copies on amazon but the best is directly from the publisher at quantum publishers.com quantumpublishers.com anyway i'll put a link in the in the show notes oh yes please yeah so with some summarize you that there are two main reasons uh for the destruction of the small banks it's on the one hand overly burdens some regulatory policies and on the other end there's monetary monetary policy squeezing the margins then you have to be big bank in order to survive um do you think this uh this this strategy is uh something
um that is is is purposefully um it's not on purpose right it is it's not some sort of they are making the same mistakes as in japan they haven't done their homework they have done their homework and this is actually what they want right yes well you know we have counter examples and we have plenty of historical uh precedence that we can look at so concerning how you should treat banks and small banks it's clear we have the u.s example you know you should treat the small banks differently and give them much like regulation and less burdensome reporting requirements and that works i mean there's no nobody's suggesting oh that you know america has done it for
for several decades and it doesn't work now there's still such evidence so um so that's one and then concerning the other policies yeah we've got the counter example of japan that has previously taken this combination of surprisingly disastrous policies first creating an acid bubble and then a big banking blow up and so of course these are policies we should want to avoid um and it's disappointing that the ecb doesn't seem to um to want to to do that the ecb did pick up some of my recommendations um
quite a few years ago almost 10 years ago when i also gave some presentations at the ecb and pointed out the importance of disaggregating bank credit and looking at where the money's going as we've been discussing now um and it should mainly go into the real economy not for asset purchases and so since around 2012 they have in their monthly reports that the ecb started to write about oh we need to increase bank credit for the real economy and of course there's no economic theory except mine which says that and so they have adopted my my advice to the extent that there's some economists out there that write these reports that are pointing this out sadly it seems the
decision made because behind the policies that um that the ecb is taking they haven't taken this on board yet or it may be that they just don't want this and and you know the longer this continues the more the likely it is that they actually just simply pursuing different policy goals perhaps coming back to the other point um you raised the you know the central bank digital currencies there is actually a bit of good news out just a few days ago namely um there's a new message that's been sent out um of course it's not officially from central banks because that would be
um far too embarrassing and they've launched it through the pr organ of the central banks which is the financial times um which is now even owned by the nikkei the nikkei in japan that nihon kesai um where the nikkei index comes from like the ftse index and financial times in the stock index um this nikkei was always very very um dominated by the bank of japan has always been pro central bank and it's very very obvious and so this financial times is always very very similar um rarely criticizing the central banks and
giving them a nice platform for whatever they want to say and they've now come out and they've used one of their spokes people there in the financial times to proclaim that oh central bank digital currency maybe we should be careful maybe we should not rush it and maybe we should introduce only wholesale cbdc not retail cbtc and this is something we should talk about because that's an important distinction i've been talking about this before but it's it seems now right for um for more sort of general consumption that you need to make this
um distinction and it's very good news because um i've been arguing if you if you introduce cbdc and i'm really against cbdc but there's clearly a lot of momentum and pressure for doing it then there are two types and one is what they've been discussing at the ecb and other central banks in europe in particular which is retail cbdc whereby essentially i mean it's a misnomer it's really a current account at central bank it's only if you realize that then you realize you know why call it cpdc because if it's a current account at the central bank well it's similar to an account at
the bank and we should use our current money we should call it um [Music] cbd sorry not not cbdc but um bank digital currency bdc sorry that's the one bdc we should call it bdc right but if you did that you realize that actually cbdc and bdc bank digital currency are very very similar and the difference is to see the centralization aspect of it which is really the point so with this retail central bank digital currency everyone gets a current account at the central bank and that of course is quite clear is more or less the end
of banking initially you can say no it's not and the banks will be able to compete and so on but hang on this is the bank regulator saying i'm gonna step into the arena and i'm gonna compete with my regulator do they have a chance it's like in football if the the umpire says well i'm a bit bored running around here just watching i'm gonna join now and i'm gonna actually score some goals now now let's see and oh you get out of my way you know whistle red card for you yellow card for you get out of the way i'm gonna score how easy is it going to be for the umpire to do that does anyone else have a chance no they're meant to be umpires they're not meant to join the game but
this is what retail cbdc's are it's the umpire getting into the game suddenly competing and actually using all the powers available so you just need a bit of a shock a crisis all the money would move from the bank deposits to the central bank and the banking system shuts down you get model banking you get one central bank sovietization now that seems to be what some of these central banker central planners really want but it seems they've realized okay we're not quite getting it maybe the interview we did and and the um you know the work that's recently been done in making people aware of the dangers of
central banking japanese has has caused them to pause a little bit because now they've said okay hang on maybe we shouldn't go for retail cbdc and it looks to me like they've decided okay we'll do this step by step and first we'll have wholesale cbdc what exactly is wholesale cbc could you explain it with and also with an example how would it work and how would we know this yes now this is what i've been recommending for this situation where it seems like we're gonna get cbdc then we should do it the wholesale way which is the chinese way this is how the chinese central bank has done it now you have to understand the chinese situation china until recently had a soviet-style
system with very few banks you know almost the soviet mono banking system in the soviet union there was an era where there was just literally one bank gauss bank and they had many branches and that's it no other bank and china had more or less that system before dengue xiaoping came to power alexia ping when he came to power um he he studied japan and he looked at germany and the us and he concluded okay well we want a successful system and the japanese system of course was was most attractive to him because japan has been essentially a one-party state as far as the political structure is
concerned and that's of course you know what we have in china and that seems to work but economically the system delivered and he thought well that's the best way to get everyone on board and stay in power we deliver the goods so how are we going to do that well let's look more how japan is doing it realized well they have a lot of banks they have many banks small banks local banks and so when he came back from his japan trip that's what he did he changed the banking system and also how the central bank operates and interacts with the banks and he created thousands of banks
community banks savings banks regional banks provincial banks corporative banks um credit unions of course also some big champions national champions and so on and so now china has the second largest number of banks on planet earth just behind the us almost 5 000 banks and that's very recent i mean this only started from the 1980s onwards and it delivered four decades of double-digit economic growth you know you just need four or five years of double-digit economic growth and you've doubled your national income so they've multiplied national income many many times over
this time period raised more people out of poverty than any time in any place in history before phenomenal success and in china people realize it's the banking system that's a key factor in this so now the latest trend among central planners and you know the chinese of course also looking at all the various central planning things that deng xiaoping was very much a decentralizer within uh within the chinese system but they see that oh wow the west is really increasing centralization um in fact perhaps briefly we should mention the european union as a construct um seems to have been modeled on the soviet union i mean there's some
uh some russian experts who've um pointed this out and it's it seems quite obvious uh that it's actually true you know the soviet union had a parliament it had a parliament but you've got a smile you know that parliament did you ask my he's not very powerful right he wasn't very powerful it was a rubber stamp but existed and what what weakened its powers well it couldn't table any laws so that what does that remind us of oh that's actually the european parliament is it's a robberstown parliament they can't table any they can't propose any laws where did the laws come from
well what about the soviet union they came from the public bureau now the polit bureau was this central organ that had commissars there and that they they were not elected of course and they um they decided and formulated the new laws which were then given to the parliament to rubbish what does that sound like to you where do we have commissars commissioners yeah well of course my fellow dutchman timmermans is definitely uh operating that way exactly well so it is the european commission the european commission is the politburo of the soviet system that we have called the eu
um and parliament is just european parliament it's just like a soviet parliament so um so the chinese saw that all right okay so they are they like the soviet system maybe we should have a look at this storytization and oh so now they're talking about central bank digital currency well that surely means you know if you do it this retail way you are going to reduce the number of banks to ultimately one and you're going to get mono banking which some central planners love and they get really excited about but the chinese said well hang on hang on we've done that we've been there just recently and we've just now introduced so many banks we created all these banks
that's given us so much prosperity should we really give this up we're not going to do that i mean if these guys in europe are silly enough to do that let them do it but we're not going to do that and so um but we want to be at the forefront of what's happening with digital revolution and stuff like that and of course you know digital tools are smart and smart means you're getting controlled you're getting watched you get your data and your activities are getting very powerful and very very successful actually no doubt that this chinese success was largely the fact that there's thousands of local banks kicking the tires checking out things before they make the loan it's a
decentralized system it's always much more resilient and better than a central planner trying to centrally do this for the whole country it's you know china is far too big it doesn't make sense so um they introduced what can be called wholesale cbdc namely they said okay the the cbdc is really the idea fundamentally is and that's how it's marketed also in europe it's a modern version of cash a digital version of cash in europe that's so far been more or less pr because they were not actually discussing doing that because if you did that because how does cash come into
circulation i mean do you go to the central bank to get your cash paul not anymore it used to be the case until the late 70s early 80s i think you went to the central bank or your the central bank to the central bank they have franchises in in across holland uh where you could also get your cash but yeah of course you go to a commercial bank if you can find one that still offers that because it's something that's quite rapidly disappearing from the street anyway yes well in england you can you can still go to the central bank because the the bank of england notes say that it's a promise to pay to the bearer and you can go to the bank of england
get your um you know hand in your 20 pound note and say it's promised to pay so please pay me and there's a law which says they will pay you how if it's 20 pounds they'll give you two ten pound notes right so if you come with a five pound nose that's the end of the line [Laughter] they can give you coins no they don't they don't actually because they don't um produce those they ordered from the treasury from the mint so um that's the end of the line so um yes where do we get cash from it's come from the banks because the banks are the intermediaries that deal with the retail sector and the central bank is a wholesale
operator mostly that deals with the banks so this two-tier system is the system that we've had and that's historically been the case in in many countries and that has allowed this decentralization that we have many banks that take the local decisions and has put the banks um in front of the public and that they're really the the face of the monetary system and the financial system and the chinese have introduced already i mean so far it's officially a pilot scheme but they've introduced it this slowly um expanding it and increasing the
geographical coverage um of the central bank digital currency but it's a wholesale system so you will get your central bank difficulty through your bank how did that happen well it happened because they already had digital payment systems that we pay and alipay has been used for many years now in china as the main mode of paying paper money has become quite quite rare particularly in the big cities people just don't pay with paper money anymore everywhere you go tiny amounts um people use their phones and they um you put either the alipay or we pay app on there but how does that work well
the alipaying we pay you know they're not financial institutions they are digital services providers and in order to get your alipay account and then get your qr code and make the payment and you have to have an account with a bank it's always linked to a bank so behind you know people talk about oh alipay we pay dominating the financial system is not true they're just the face the front the shop window of the digital payments de facto so far um behind that has been [Music] the chinese banks and it can be any bank
your bank you know you if it's a local small provincial bank then that's the bank you need to have a bank account and then that's plugged into the system and so likewise with central bank digital currency now that the central bank decided okay alipay and we pay they're getting too too big for their boots and they're actually commercial operators that um was demonstrated a couple years ago when um the the head of alibaba suddenly disappeared and he was going to have a big ipo i think the biggest in in world history um and was it even meant to be in america a new york ipo something or maybe hong kong but anyway
he had not done the formal steps of getting approval from the necessary authorities in china he felt i'm so big this is the biggest idea nobody's going to stop me well they stopped him okay they said you are not in charge of um of monetary policy and financial system regulation so um reconsider and you know he did reconsider it and that was the beginning of essentially the regulators in china um going after alibaba group which is alipay and in general these two payment
providers because they were dominating all payments which is a very powerful position it wasn't that powerful because there were still the banks behind it but still it was quite powerful and that's why the central bank campaign said well actually they're performing a function that they should at least be public offering there as well so we're going to introduce central bank digital currency to compete with alibaba you know alipay and we pay so that's how they structured they use the same system where you need a bank account to plug in in order to get the central bank and digital currency so that's why it's a two-tier system and that's why you need a bank and that's why in this chinese system you're not killing the banks and that's a smart system because that that way you
maintain the decentralization and how would it work in practice then so with with alipay for example i and then top up my alipay account by connecting it with my uh bank my normal bank account exactly and and if i would then uh want to use the chinese cbdc then i need to connect a bank account yeah account to the pboc uh um system and then it tops up my bank account and then i can top up uh my account for example exactly exactly now of course you realize when you think this through that okay it's a small step and it will be easy in the future for a central bank to say okay now we do
this directly and it will be easy to switch to retail and that's of course the dangerous thing and the dangerous temptation with china i'm not actually worried about it because as we as we said they know the value of banks they know the value of a decentralized banking system that's how china became so successful and so powerful they're not going to kill the goose that's been laying these fantastic golden eggs but in the west i'm very concerned i'm not even sure they realize how important and effective it is to have a banking system with many small banks they're very much into all small banks small fry you know that's a it's an issue we want a small number of big banks i mean
that's not a good system but it seems that that's that's what the central planners in the west admire and so i'm very concerned and now so now back to this this news item so there was this the story out in the financial times just a couple of days ago saying that oh the i think they were talking about conversations at davos or whatever um the talk now seems to be let's go the wholesale route they did not interestingly in this article china is not mentioned that essentially this is what china has been doing all along they've been smart they thought about this that's what they went for that's not mentioned as if it's sort of a an insight but i think in reality it is a bit of a
step back for the central planners they are now taking it slower but ultimately i think their strategy is okay that's how we get it that's how we get what we want because if we um went straight for retail cbdc there will be resistance and i've certainly done my best to put up resistance i've written articles i've given lots of interviews warning about the dangers of this retail cbdc and killing the banking system and having a soviet style monobank system um i remember there was an event in switzerland where there was martin wolf also from the financial times and he was going to argue in favor of abolishing banks and just having the central bankers and
then i when i said well this is the soviet system we've had this before this is sovietization he was shocked he hadn't thought about that he didn't realize oh i mean the proposal i've just made is actually to introduce a soviet central bank and he didn't like it i think he couldn't really he sort of you know reverse his position on the spot but i think this is really what's happened that they realize okay there will be resistance and of course the bankers and even the big banks by now will have begun to wake up i've contacted several big banks and argued look you guys you need to understand what's happening they're going to kill you as well and my idea was to get some big banks to support the community banks that i'm
setting up because the trouble with the big banks is they don't have a good reputation and the public will say oh are we gonna kill the big banks okay let's do it yeah exactly of course so they have they have no standing they won't get the backing so they can hide behind the small community banks the big guys should back the establishment of small community banks which are not competition to them they're not a threat to them because they do business that the big banks aren't even interested in but by doing that it's the small banks the community banks the public will stand up for and say no we don't want them killed let's let's maintain them they're very important and it seems that this is happening to some extent the the central
planners have realized okay there will be too much resistance isn't it easier why don't we do this and go first the wholesale way and of course at the back of their mind i'm sure is the idea then once we have that we can there will be we you know we'll engineer crisis there'll be an excuse and as you know but now we need to switch to retail that's of course the big risk yeah of course because then they have the infrastructure available and they can easily just with a switch they can completely take over the system but it's interesting too and also fascinating for me to hear that um everyone is just warning about no we shouldn't go um the the direction china is taking and china's already
went ahead with cbdc and that's that's a nightmare coming to europe but in a way the chinese are already thinking two steps ahead and and keep the decentralization in the back of their minds and and only want to um progress gradually while maintaining um their their their order and and their growth strategy well in europe they um go the wrong way eventually and possibly also of course in china the fact is that there already have been two competing private sector forms of digital currency that if you want to call additional accounts you know payments uh settlement systems
alipay and we pay that have become widespread in fact dominant so it's really a different situation and and one way it's then quite natural you can see the senator saying okay we'll join there and we're going to compete now against alipay and we pay and so far the central bank is fringe and probably will stay fringe for a while although that can be changed you know quite easily if you're the regulator you've got many tools and disposal to gain an advantage but in principle at the moment at least the chinese are saying okay well the central bank um is just one of the players and there's other players offering the same product now that's what we don't hear in
europe so um but it's the first step that there seems to be this indication the message is being given out okay maybe we'll move to the wholesale cbdc first next we what we should hear is that okay and let's have alternatives to that because that wholesale cbdc should also be competing with private sector offerings so let's have the equivalent of alipay and we pay and why not various crypto currencies and alternative currencies as well and let's get them also um established as part of the system you know so that they're actually options and alternatives because that's what we have in china
yeah but at the same time whether you are in china or europe liberty is at stake because in china we have a social credit system which i'm sure you're not fond of in in europe this is also being rolled out with several pilots in bologna in vienna and co2 is being measured um so it's slowly but surely being introduced here as well so whether we have full retail cbdc or just wholesale cbdc uh our overlords are uh in any case going to monitor us that is true that is true exactly so as you say cbdc's digital currencies run by a government or government agency or a
central bank are dangerous because governments can always say oh there's some national uh interest or even national security reasons why we need to do xyz why we can override any privacy concerns you may have why we need to look into all your transactions and why we need to stop some of you people out there from buying something oh you've used too much co2 well then for today for the next two days you've got to stop breathing because you'll be breathing out too much co2 i mean ultimately a regime could argue that right right quite scary yeah think about it but that's that's so that's that's
unavoidable then right that that trend um or everything is avoidable if we stand up and um and come together um what i also wanted to know is um so ecb does seem to take take its time because last year they said oh in five years or so we're going to implement it if we're going to review thoroughly the law and and see if there's uh um enough uh probably buy in from the member states but it will take many more years it seems before the ecb is is going to introduce it why are they taking so much time then and do they have that time because maybe the euro will be disintegrated before that time
yes yes um of course this can be accelerated if circumstances allow a faster track and that may be the scenario that they're talking now about okay this you know in the distant future five years ten years but um events may then allow a drastic acceleration and of course these events would be what what follows from you know the massive money creation that we've had since 2008 and then again accelerated since 2020 the increased inflation and if they maintain their misguided policies the inflation will get worse that will be
essentially debauching of of existing currencies and the call for something new for a reset and then that's where you can accelerate these um these schemes but it does so the good news is that it does give us a bit of time and i think we need to use this time to establish many more small local banks community banks the more we have the better they're trying to shut them down and kill them but it's now a good opportunity because the the the yield curve is getting steeper again that means banking is is getting profitable again um and also we now have talked about wholesale cbdc which means that
you know this is the system that allows for in fact needs the banks um for a while so this is a window of opportunity we must use i think to establish as many banks as we can that are particularly that are local and that are operated or controlled in a democratic accountable way because banks are money creators and the decision of how much money to create and who to give it to for what purpose has such a big impact on society that we need these right types of banks and essentially the the more decentralized and smaller and more local the more
accountable they will be and then you can ensure the stakeholders can ensure that the right types of decisions are made that's how you can make the monetary system accountable and useful for ordinary people and return the power to create money to the people i think the best way and the only way really is to establish many small local banks they've in in the netherlands as well they've concentrated some merchant into one and so the number of banks have gone down let's set up new ones because they're now getting profitable again and it is profitable banking remains one of the most profitable industries by its very nature and so that's what we should do well you have a lot of
very reasonable suggestions and advice when it comes to banking like indeed more banks maybe have a cap on the size of the bank and banks should only land for productive investment and if you want to buy an existing asset you should get your money from a nun bank and maybe we should reduce all these stupid aml requirements we should introduce not retail cbdc so there's a lot of good things coming from your end also jack basement in holland or steve keane quite a few of these of you guys have a lot of great ideas but i wonder if is is the is the euro in and of itself um not have become is it not too weak by now to still salvage it or is it better to
focus on something else altogether or do you still think it can be safe yes and no if we want something else then again it will be helpful to have these community banks because they can actually switch you can introduce local currencies quite easily with community banks right they can be the core of um of a local community a currency and transaction system very easily i mean in switzerland the via wir system was set up in the 1930s um and it's essentially a private mutual credit uh settlement system where small firms give each other credit
and then they pay each other in their own system credit and it became very successful became very big they've got a banking license by now why because it does help you know if you've got a bank at the core of this and so likewise by setting up community banks we can use them to introduce alternative currencies in the 1930s when there was the great depression in germany and austria 25 unemployment is the famous story of of the little town in tyrol called virgo and in this um the city of virgo the mayor was somebody who's read a lot of books on economics and thought about money he
read also gizelle and sylvia gazelle's book anyway he but he he was also somebody heard a lot of common sense and he saw the reality that as mayor he had jobs to do there was a bridge that needed to be repaired he needed some public building there some roads need to be needed to be built and at the same time there are lots of people unemployed well there's a match here you know we need this work done these people are looking for work i'm gonna hire them he said well i don't have the funds but why do i need funds they're doing something for the community so and we value that we are the community we just value that and we give
them a certificate which says you've done something you've worked eight hours today for the community the mayor signed this it's like a receipt for services rendered to the community that he issued and you know it's just the fact they worked on this bridge for eight hours it's fair enough if at the end of the day they get a certification saying you did this for us for the community thank you and then he told his wife who happened to run a large local grocery store with food supplies please you must accept these receipts they've they've worked out you know by the sweat of their their brows they've worked for us to do this and of course you know you must accept this
and she said well okay i'm fine with this but i have to pay my suppliers you know the farmers and so you have to tell them you know they have to accept it and that's how it worked it was literally top down and it was almost initially on on hope that people will see this but it was very simple and transparent and everyone saw this and of course they worked so that's fair you know they're not like some um some banker or hedge fund manager or city of london guy who's not really working very hard but getting huge bonuses right no these people working hard everyone could see the results tangible here's the receipt of course we'll accept this receipt that's worth more than any whatever euro issued by the ecb
to me they said and so it became the currency and so you can see how um very quickly then virgo became prosperous because people started to get jobs unemployment went down tax revenues actually went up tax revenues for local taxes were then also in the local currency in this in these receipts for services rendered to the local community whatever you call them and it was boom town then the neighboring villages and towns started to do this and that's when international attention um appeared and you know even from from uh irving fisher in the u.s he sent his
his assistance over and that started the international articles and of course that's when the the central bank stepped in and probably choked them well the central bank um argued this is totally unacceptable we've worked very hard for over a decade to create this acid bible and then to create the crisis and a big great depression and this lowly mayor is just ending the great depression that is criminal so he must be put into prison that was their argument now unfortunately the prosecutor listened to the central bank more than to the mayor and sadly the mayor was forced to stop this
so he stopped the program and as was predictable virgo fell back into the great depression the people were unemployed again the time was in destitution and this experiment while it worked it was amazing and they still can go to the city and you see the signs they put them on the bills this was built with the verbal money but the town fell back into the great depression and the central bank was happy but it's very similar to what's going on right now because as a as a member of the eurozone you are not allowed to issue your own money so whenever farofaq is or in italy they they propose something like uh like in virgo they uh they cannot because because the
european uh well actually legislation doesn't allow for it it does allow for it it doesn't love it because it doesn't have to be called a currency and technically in virgo it wasn't the currency because it was receipts for labor done now what you can what is bank money 95 97 of our money supply is bank money what is that when you look at the legal status of bank money which is our money supply it is not legally privileged it is not it's simply private company credit there is no legal privilege and that's why in switzerland the veer system could operate and there's no legal obstacles of it because it's private company credit and therefore you'll change alternative
systems until they got too big of course and then because you have to admit also richard if something like that becomes too big in europe again then they will either change the law or change the definition exactly of course that's that is the risk but it doesn't mean we should not even try you know we should try and in fact you know if you get resistance then you know you're doing the right thing yeah yeah well i like i like your your strategy first like planning all these seats having all these community banks and then shoot the eu a shoot shoot euro a break up then at least you have a safety net lifeboats um exactly exactly in fact coming back to your question on the euro of course i was one of the early voices strongly opposing the introduction of the euro that's documented in my writings in the
1990s also some letters to the editor the financial times which managed to get through the census and because of course it never made sense it never made sense for any country um also not for germany it made sense for none there was no good economic argument it was always political it was always about control but politically it also didn't make sense so that was the trouble with the euro it it it was always a control tool by centralizers and only made sense for them for centralization and power concentration purposes but for no other reason and that's why it would be good to get out of it greece should have left it's sad that
greece didn't make a stronger effort to leave because you could have avoided this massive squeeze and and suppression and that's that's been going on in greece um but of course on the other hand there's also a lot we can do while we are in the eurozone uh even countries like switz like like spain and greece in greece we still have credit um destruction negative credit growth the economy is still shrinking with very high unemployment um we can still introduce the policy of enhanced debt mana bonds to stop the issuance of government bonds and instead do what well in those days remember
the bond yields were very high so it was very very costly to raise money through government bonds and they were acting as if there's an alternative that's wrong now just we heard from the ecb today they want to you know keep up with bond purchases why they want to keep yields down to help italy well italy has choices it doesn't have to issue government bonds to fund its public sector borrowing requirement the alternative has always been bank credit get it directly from the creators of the money supply yeah and you see even at the peak of this european uh sovereign debt crisis 2011 around that time when the bond yields for
spain ireland you know we're just pushing i mean island was double-digit you know 20 or something portugal 30 percent greece 60 percent pontiac i mean crazy stuff even at that time when there were such high bond interest rates you know if you go if you issue new government bonds that's the interest rate you have to pay well the bank credit interest rate was never higher than four percent so why didn't why didn't greece borrow from its own banks that's what it should have done and it would have helped everyone it would have helped the banks because they get business you need to to help banks they need to expand and of course they're happy to lend to the
lowest risk borrower which is the government but by doing that we've got we get bank credit creation for real economy transactions which boosts your nominal gdp which means you get more tax revenues the whole economy expands you have job creation and you get out of the recession but that was that was discouraged but there was no legal obstacle so it was just politically political pressure armed twisting to not do this but i've made this proposal also to spain i presented it in fact in brussels at a gathering which was quite fortuitous in 2011 of all the finance ministry officials every finest ministry send officials to this gathering in brussels
of the entire eu and i presented it so it's out there they can still do it and that way you have money creation in your domestic banking system particularly in countries where we still have very weak economy and that includes portugal spain ireland and obviously greece right and some others and indeed i also read today that the ecb is planning on probably expanding again their um their bond uh exactly which which creates these wrong incentives you know because that is just fueling an acid bubble and you're pushing down bond yields um you know artificially when we have inflation which which is crazy
so that's that's an alternative but of course it takes away from the ecb's power so to speak because it's a decentralized measure that finance ministries take and that's why the ecb doesn't really want to contemplate it right but is it possible then that the ecb keeps on buying bonds while increasing the interest rates because they say we first want to stop the bond programs and then we're going to raise interest rates but now they're saying oh we're probably going to go ahead with with the continuation of these programs but they at the same time they probably need to start raising rates in order to tame inflation um will what is the what's the outlook for the ecb in the next 12 months the there's two scenarios one is the um
the smarter scenario if the ecb wants to adopt some smarter policies and one is the disaster policy scenario the disaster policy now is where the ecb says um that well you know as you mentioned we need to um make sure the bond yields don't go up so much with lots of government bonds to to push down the yields you know um raise the bond prices which means the yields are pushed down italian government bonds under that we do that a lot but when they do they create money this is money creation that fuels the inflation um and therefore there's more pressure on bond yields to go up then they buy more government bonds and therefore you
get the scenario which essentially have accelerating ever accelerating inflation it will be an exponential curve that ultimately you know will go to galloping weimar style hyper inflation while at the same time they will they're suppressing that they're raising so they're suppressing the long rates but they're raising the short rates because they're saying oh we have inflation now we should raise short rates so then you have an inverted yield curve which is bad for banks and that would be another way of causing a disaster combination so you'll be very stupid to do this but sadly there is a good chance that that's exactly the policy combination
which doesn't make any sense but they will adopt now if they were smarter they would they would just do something completely different um which is to stop money creation for asset purchases just stop that let the market set the bond yields um and encourage banks to increase bank credit for the real economy therefore have a positive yield curve and actually you would raise short-term rates because you'd say no we we're getting more growth we want to have more growth more growth means higher rates that's why we're raising rates on the short end and let them let them go up on the long end to have a proper steep steepening yield curve
and at the same time ensure that credit created both by the central bank and the banking system is mainly for productive purposes business investment not for asset purchases and that could be done with some very simple rules and regulations and everything else you can forget about just drop all other policies you'd get sooner or later the end of inflation and you get you know growing real growth so inflation would fall away real growth would accelerate um and you'd grow your way out of the previous accumulated debt yeah one of the lead economists of the rebel bank also said to me the other day let's also just write down all the ecb
uh s all the the bonds that ecb currently um has so then the debt the gdp ratios go down a lot for all the european countries sort of a a reset or a clean slate because it doesn't really matter that money has been spent anyway so it's not inflationary that's true that's true that's true that is true but actually you probably wouldn't even have to do that you could do it in fact that's always been one of my proposals when you have a um or even the banking system long-forming asset problem get the central bank to purchase them at face value and forget about it because the damage has been done that's history you now need to be forward-looking so in that sense i agree but actually you will find that you don't even have
to do it if you adopt the policies i've recommended because you get so much economic growth but thanks to the growth and and you won't incur new deficits so that your deficit gp ratios will improve as deficits go down as you get a recovery and gdp goes up and the debt to gdp ratios also go down as the debt goes down and gdp goes up so ultimately that way after a few years you will grow your way out of it but of course on top you could do it as well it's just slightly more uh dramatic when you're announced are good i guess because a lot of journalists they keep on harping about the ecb balance sheet every i mean in twitter they always talk about easily balance sheet even lagarda got the question the other day from the dutch journal is about the balance sheet so
maybe just to avoid a lot of stupid questions about the balance sheet we possibly should just clean it up um well thanks so much richard i also want to spend some time i know you uh we we just discussed and and and uh agreed that we should keep it to 45 minutes but it's it's taking a bit longer i'm sorry for that but also what i really want to know about the for holla network because two years ago that wasn't there yet you you did all already play for a a for more community banks but now you're actually working on something uh really awesome that could help um the development of more community banks across europe the valhalla network could you explain to us what it's all about yes well the valhalla network
is going to issue digital tokens that are essentially um voting rights in a decentralized autonomous organization and this dao is involved in improving the the monarchy system and that includes setting up community banks which of course are profitable and will pay some some yields and dividends to the owners there's a foundation uh involved and essentially it's it's a network so that there is an alternative currency but it's grounded in the idea of setting
up community banks and it's directly connected to these community banks so there's some real value there um because we thought and i'm working there with um one of my um associates i've been working already longer on other projects um only stud we thought it's crazy we've got all these digital currencies out there these alternative currencies and and often there's nothing behind it there's nothing to back it um there are some some you know use uses being talked about and some have some uh you know distributed ledger technologies that can be used for certain things and smart things but um ultimately a lot of them there's not very much
behind it so we thought well since we're talking about and we have been involved in setting up community banks now you know we're making some progress um in england some some other countries too now um why don't we have an alternative token um digital currency that is directly backing this and is directly at the core of this because then that's really what we need and we can then also be in the space where we set up these community banks we would have you know already local currency or a network currency combinations of that it just opens up so many options and just at this time and and moment where
the existing currencies are increasingly being debauched by the central banks and people are looking for alternatives maybe we should actively be out there offering such an alternative but i can imagine that the central bank or the regulators do not allow a decentralized autonomous organization to own or to partially own banks right because you have the fetf requirements the aml requirements do you think they're going to let a dow and participate in well there are structures there are structures where of course it's you know it's at arm's length and you have a essentially a charitable foundation that um is an owner and uh you know there's this because so the tokens are essentially
voting rights but they're not shareholdings as such you know there's ways you can get around these things um but it's clear you know it is a community it's a network and if you participate in network then that's what you're packing and that's what we can we can get and we can get the usage um advantages out from fascinating and when will it be launched um well we we're actually moving to the um we had an original seed round we're moving to the um series a round of raising some money shortly and so hopefully um we've really raised a significant amount of money but hopefully in a couple of months we
can move to the next phase right well i'll put a link to the website in the show notes but yeah good luck with that sounds very interesting i will definitely read the white paper yes please the white paper's there yeah any other things rich from your end that you want to add to the conversation um well there's i think i think we we discussed on what's what's currently um important and new and on this on this front of currency systems and digital currency this this recognition that okay we're they're not going to move directly to retail cbdc which which i think is great news and so
um i think um for my team and my people this is a real boost because it means yes we have as i as i was suspecting would but it's now getting more apparent we have exactly that window that we need to now establish these banks and get going um but perhaps yeah i mean you know people want to support us that would be very helpful there's several ways you can do that one is the valhalla network another one is to be directly involved with some of the community banks and become shareholders on these community banks um we're we're looking at various areas in england so get in touch if you want to support that
um and otherwise um you know try to try to find out more i mean for for the viewers about what's what's really going on in terms of the money creation process and what the the central planners are doing we need to spread the word more and more people are becoming aware of what's happening gold is perhaps another topic one could briefly mention i still like it it's an area where because the gold prices my view has been totally suppressed it's still cheap i mean think about it we've had this massive inflation um and yet gold is unchanged or still you know is sort of going down even
um well the good news is hey this is one place where you can put your money that is in my view safe if you have physical control and access to it and that is still cheap after two years of inflation right quite extraordinary really um but otherwise yes help us setting up community banks yeah maybe on top of a topic of gold do you think it is going to be part of some uh global reset because there's a lot of talk about maybe a new synthetic hegemonic currency like mike mark carney said and that the bis and imf are also talking about how maybe to use the sdr and
are we going to some sort of um world coin and is gold maybe going to back that a little bit just like we had in bretton woods era it's possible but it's speculation um ultimately any gold standard that included banking systems wasn't really a strict gold standard in theory you know any new money credit should be backed by gold but that was never the case but it was still it was you know a disciplining feature because you could get people demanding the gold as we saw in you know 69 70 71 when the french went to the us and said you know please give
us the gold because we have the right according to the imf treaties um us dollar can be changed to gold we're doing that and that called the bluff and so then we've had the temporary suspension of gold convertibility of the us dollar ever since of course um so if they introduce a link to gold it will be in a way a sort of pr device to get credibility it won't in reality back every you know all the money creation uh it will be a similar device the question is would they really want to put that discipline upon them i doubt it but that's essentially the speculation it doesn't really matter because gold i think will
maintain its value either way um and is is a tool that's under your control and therefore is an alternative asset particularly when you need something mobile right right well thanks a lot uh richard uh sure i hope to to do it again um in the future um good luck with all the traveling um i'll put all the show notes uh underneath the video and uh yeah take care and keep on educating us thanks very much all the best take care bye
