Private debt and the modern debt jubilee proposal

De Week van Bitcoin · 9 May 2020 · 42:07

Economist Steve Keen, speaking from Thailand, talks with Paul Buitink about the case for a modern debt jubilee during the pandemic crisis. Keen argues that unprecedented private debt is the problem and proposes using government created money to offset it, with money not needed for debt used to buy corporate shares that cancel corporate debt, which he says would leave bank equity intact. He contrasts this with ancient jubilees, says he favours central bank digital currencies while wanting to keep cash, and discusses whether Italy might leave the euro.

Speakers

Topics

From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.

Transcript

welcome everybody my name is Paul bytes ink and today you have a honor again to discuss with Steve King what's going on in the world and especially all this enormous amounts of depth that's being created because of Gov at 19 how are we going to deal with this hi Steve could see again good to be here I'll be there anyway yeah and you're a based in Thailand at the moment right yeah I was nothing in town called Trang which is in southern Thailand and the motivation for moving he was coronavirus I had four choices as to where I could stay the UK where I'm a resident destroyer I'm a citizen Netherlands where I have a flat as you know and timon were most my girlfriend is a citizen and calm combination of things but looking at the numbers on

coping and as I thought that Thailand's the only option so he moved here and we would arrive to here one day before they started closing their borders of tourists and I intend being here for the duration now well I think it sounds like the perfect place said to stay for now and and he's intent the stator until when well until this process ends because I mean just to give you an idea of what it's like I think what do you got over 40,000 cases and the Netherlands now yeah something like that and I even don't follow it on a daily basis anymore to be honest yeah well there's there's 3,000 cases in Thailand yeah just cracked 3,000 you're getting about between a hundred and two hundred

new cases a day Thailand has between one and ten there's much more successful social distancing over here you can find things like alcohol very easily masks are everywhere it's they've they were prepared for a crisis like this in a way that the West wasn't and they've gone for actual extermination of the virus not this crazy idea of herd immunity so I wanted to minimize my chances of getting the disease and I've ended up in a province where there has not been a new case now for three weeks and there would be total of seven cases in the province of 700,000 people so one in 100,000 incidents versus about one in 500 in most of Europe so yeah I'll stay here until there's violence all those

effect saying well sounds like a safe place and I'm also curious to understand what Thailand is doing with regards to the economy but I think it's better for now at least to focus on a few of the other markets and you start with with the US because the situation in the u.s. is quite tough to be honest if you look at a number of job claims jobless claims unemployment now above 20 percent I believe private debt stands at more than 14 trillion a lot of people are not able to pay their bills at the moment you know you've been saying it for a long time that's at some point Jubilee or debt forgiveness is is needed just like in biblical times do more people now

follow your line of thinking do you see it do you see it's becoming more of a of a solution proposed by mainstream economists as well to some extent yeah I mean give people a bit of a background here I first proposed the idea of a modern debt really about a decade ago because I said what actually caused the financial crisis was too much private debt and what got us into that situation partially was government's trying to actually run a surplus which literally directly causes the private sector to have a identical deficit this is one of the accounting points of modern monetary theory and given the fact that you putting the private sector into effective deficit what do they do they go and borrow money from banks and speculate on rising house prices which

is what gave us those enormous bubbles back into up to 2007 and we now have a level of private debt that is actually unprecedented in the history of America of capitalism across the history of humanity and that's what is restricting people from spending and yet you get people saying oh we shouldn't you know we should have let debtors off their debt that's really you know moral hazard the long-ago and do it again and my argument which is very consistent with Michael Hudson and a few other people who specialized in the role of debt is we can use the government's money creation capability to not not to cancelled it alone but to offset the

debt with money created by the government sector so what you do is you create large amount of fiat money to replace an identical amount of credit money and with that you can get rid of the debt burden and enable the economy to start working again until we do it it simply won't happen I thought there was zero chance of the idea of it being implemented so I really haven't worked on it a great deal since 2012 but along comes coronavirus and now it's becoming obvious even to mainstream economists that what is likely to happen is a financial crisis because suddenly people haven't got the cash flow to repay they're in an ordinary obligation like mortgages and in rent and in that situation there could be an enormous financial process unless we do something

so they're not talking about in various forms of the debt Jubilee that I've been arguing for for a decade yeah so the main difference then between a modern debt Jubilee and one from biblical times is that back in a day the debts were just cancelled because of course there were just a few rulers will own who owned all the depth so it was easier to just cancel them but modern in modern times it's a very intricate web of debt there's and creditors and balance sheets sell by if you cancel if you start getting consumer depth then the banks can get in trouble when and it was a chain of bankruptcies and defaults which possibly could completely meltdown the system so I guess that's the main difference between back in a day and

modern day is that you don't cancel the debt but you're just going to offset them with with another type of money namely money issued by state yeah look at them Michael Hudson those farm up with the stuff than I do but if you look at what happened with the would catch Chevrolet's in ancient times they were restricted to household debt so commercial debt used was not it was not abolished and the idea was anybody who borrowing money for a commercial venture normally borrows with an idea other than I have what they expect to earn out of it so commercial debts weren't canceled but a lot of household that was apparently run I've been made hauls and alcohol faces and you know they actually in debt to the to the public and fundamentally and then you'd become a

debt slave to pay off the debt and when you became a debt slave you could no longer be recruited for the army so the actual survival of the Empire was threatened by the you're in debt so it was given the choice between losing the empire and killing a few creditors you can guess which one the Emperor's anomaly chose and then it became instituted as a regular thing that every 49 years I think it was or every change of emperor this isn't the Sumerian Empire first of all there'd be a debt Jubilee which would free all the debt slaves and that became built into what people expected about the nature of the society now of course as you say we have people who are savers and people who were borrowers neither of whom Elend us and this is the

point which is important about modern monetary theory in thinking in terms of credit banks create the debt banks then give the money to debtors when they create that debt the debtors then spend it it'll end up being distributed throughout the money is distributed through different people's accounts the data still held by the debtors if you then simply abolish the dead you'd crash the whole financial assistance Act leaves me yeah so this is a say let's use the government's money creation capability to give everybody an identical injection and enable that interview see if you get the money in you're in debt then you must pay your debt down or you have a debt debt offset if you're not in debt you get a cash injection and that could be used if you

don't want to actually increase the amount of money in circulation of the real economy you could require that that money was used to buy corporate shares where those corporate shares would have to be used to cancel corporate debt and that would then mean you could reduce both household debt and corporate debt without changing the amount of money in the economy and enable a huge reduction in the debt burden which would actually probably give a stimulus to the economy of a people being more willing to spend because at the moment people are forwarding to try to pay their debts back so that first the basic concept it doesn't actually you didn't maintain the effective solvency of the banks they wouldn't have as much liquidity they wouldn't have as much income earning assets but the banks would still have the same positive equity coming out of

it so it's feasible to do it without destroying the financial system whereas if he just abolished the debt you destroy the financial system yeah so if if I would be a consumer without Deb I received in government money but do I would received a tenement government wallet or is that channel through the bank that's one thing which depends upon the monetary structure so I originally proposed when I was in Australia and if you're in Australia or everybody gets a tax return everybody has an account link to their taxes at the at their private bank that promote the government the Treasury knows your bank account and your tax refund or your tax bill is paid

through that account so back in 2008 it was quite simple for the Rudd Labor government them to say we're going to give everybody a thousand dollar rebate as they called it so every bank account got a thousand dollars now in the UK most people don't pay tax they pay tax as they go they don't have a tax return so it's not feasible so I've been in favor of creating central bank digital currencies not because they want to abolish cash by any means I just don't trust central bank's with the abolition of cash but if you did that everybody would have an account of the central bank and then the government could easily put an injection of money into your account at the central bank and control how that money was spent so if you were in debt the money would be submitted against you all your debts if

you weren't in debt then you could be required to use that money to buy corporate shares so I that's why I prefer I prefer to see central bank digital currencies created but if you don't have that then if you do have a link between people's bank accounts and how they pay tax then the government can make an injection directly into private bank accounts yeah and you maybe you can never separate it account with your bank and that is not nuts Bardolph the ordinary central ordinary balance sheet of a bank or at least it's it's it's segregated if it's gonna be used in other ways something like that and so you can easily see what's standing bank money and government money through the bank yeah that'd be we can

do it electronically there's no way that was never possible say eighty years ago during the Great Depression however one thing which was done with bank holidays back in America at that time was actually to consolidate debt and write dead off and move deposits from one from a failing bank to a successful bank and that was a major part of why we got through the Great Depression so we have done something similar in the recent past but of course the financial sector is the main group that would resist that the reason that the coronavirus gives much opportunity is that I think the banks themselves realize but if people can't pay their mortgages and they can't pay their rent then there could be a chain reaction to

bankruptcies that also since the banks bankrupt and now they're worried enough to be thinking well maybe we should agree to something like this whereas in the past we would have resisted it yeah because on their balance sheet they would just swap a all these mortgages and car loans for government assets basically over for for something that they have with the central bank central bank reserve I guess yeah if you have a fear made me say you over to did it let's say you either did a hundred thousand euro to your bank and that would be the amount of money let's say the amount that person was a hundred thousand euros you're putting more than I'm thinking I'll just give an easy example then the bank would have its to have an asset of a hundred thousand dollars of the debt you owe to the bank

which was a commitment for future payment but they knew the possibility you would actually fail and that and therefore they might lose 30 percent or 40 percent of that with this rescue they'd get a hundred thousand in government created money and that would mean that their equity would be maintained whereas if your situation if you went from being able to having a hundred thousand euro debt which you would be unable to service so you'd have to sell whatever property had bought with it and then by selling it there'd be a loss and all those sorts of things the bank might find itself getting fifty thousand euro so loses fifty thousand it takes a healer owners equity could go bankrupt so so it's a ways it'll be odd for the banks and the banks are just as

much bailed out faggus mechanism as our ordinary a consumers that's wrong yeah yeah and by sort of forcing people to also buy corporate shares you are trying to keep inflation in check them I guess yeah I mean if you had an enormous creation of money like you know looking at the levels of debt around the world I mean the Netherlands has an enormous level of corporate debt about 1.6 times a day your household it's about 100 percent of GDP if you actually injected that much money into the economy in one go of course you'd cause an inflationary search so the idea is that if if you could cancel like we injected 100 percent of GDP one year in this game which is more than I

would consider doing first time around but if you did do that then if they half of that money went to people in debt and half went to those who didn't have did you'd have a 50 percent of GDP increase in cash in the hands that people who want to spend which of course would cause a huge surge in spending but if you simple instead and 80 percent of that must be used to buy corporate shares and therefore you reduce corporate debt by 40 percent of GNP and put a 10 percent simulus in that's much smaller you could even Sabol in the Netherlands case a hundred percent of the money must be used to buy corporate shares and what you would do then is partially increase the level of the democratic content of share ownership because of the across the entire country and you'd also reduce the extent to

which quantitative easing and which central banks have practiced but the last decade has actually boosted share prices which has made the rich richer and lifts the poor in the lodge this would be a way of resetting that that Democratic deficit that the central banks pushed us into about the key way they actually practiced yeah so in debt the way consumers are helped banks are saved corporates also see a benefit because they have too much depth and some of it will be converted in shares but then we have still a big problem with SME most small businesses are struggling at the moment especially in especially restaurants and bars and shops and tourism how are they going to benefit or is it also possible in your

in your view that they should get some of the helicopter money as well if they could also get some of the helicopter money too I mean it's quite possible so to give a cash injection based on the size of the of the corporation so individuals would be getting as households the unity health what account would get the same amount of money if you you could leave large corporates out of it was a SMS would get say the same amount of money you could have a you know you'd actually set it up in such a way then there's a maze between with about with with you know with the account backing or say overdraft limit of say between a hundred and thousand and the million could get

half a billion the these are the various ways you could actually do it because we do have data and we do have an electronic financial system so it is feasible to extend it to SMAS as well not large corporates obviously but you get extended to SMAS and that would enable the small businesses to keep on functioning bertha Mamet is me now anybody entertainment and tourism is basically destroyed by the coronavirus yeah and then the mortgages they would go from the commercial bank balance sheets to the central bank balance sheet not necessarily would be paid off completely I mean look if you look at what's actually going on with central bank's create money it's every time I've been creates money it's an accounting

operation so if you have a private bank which creates a loan creates a new debt for a borrower like see they create a bill a million dollars in euro for somebody to buy an expensive property in Amsterdam then they created a million dollars on their asset side and they're creating million dollars on the liabilities on euro million euro on the liability side which goes into the buyers account and then the buyer transfers that million euro to the seller and you have a million euro increase in the in that in the seller's account when a central bank does it it simply says normally to a financial institution we're going to buy two billion dollars worth of bonds of you

see you transfer the ownership with a billion dollars worth of bonds which goes on the central bank's asset side and we'll put a billion dollars into your bank account at the central bank which increases the liability side now they could equally do what has been done by the central bank of England the bank of the Bank of England they they allow Scottish banks to create what they call the Scottish pound which is one for one equivalent British Pound but issued by banks like Clydesdale Bank and Royal Bank of Scotland and so on and for a hundred every hundred million dollars a day pounds worth of of those notes and circulation the Bank of England creates a one hundred million pound note they

call it tighten which stays inside there at Needle Street if you tried to go shopping with if you broke into the bank and stole it and tried to go shopping and you know by the local lamborghini district distributorship you'd be arrested nobody would accept it it's just a piece of paper it's very dusty it's it's fairy dust yeah the negativity this is just it's yeah counting they can just and that's right because central banks can operate with negative equity as a paper by another guy called Paul ball ash is at the Bank of England he and a few research colleagues wrote a paper up saying central banks can operate with negative equity that's one thing a private bank cannot do private

being with negative equity is by definition bankrupt but a central bank because it's backed by the entire country effectively I equally doesn't really matter so they've done this trick with the Scottish notes and they could do exactly the same thing with the debt Jubilee but it's done you know in order to sort of create the illusion of solvency solvency in order for the market to keep on having faith in the pound or why not just be honest to say look this is all this is all fairy dust and we might as well just write it off this tight and show that we have no identity well I think in fact then what they doing is doing the fairy dust I'm just saying we want to pretend we've been they want to show you've got to keep your assets and liabilities and in

balance the whole the fundamental you can't run a bank and violate what's called the fundamental law of accounting assets minus liabilities - equity equals zero what central bank's of course take they can have negative equity there and still balance the entire thing but it's just nice and tidy to say we're going to create this fictional equity of a hundred million over here and this is sectional fictional asset with greater coding concerning it equity and therefore we we don't fall into negative equity but it is an accounting trick and money fundamentally use accounting and that's why people like me unless I get so frustrated when I usually say how we gonna pay for it you write two numbers in a balance sheet that's how you pay

for it if you are the sovereign issue of money of course that's in the eurozone it's a bit more difficult as we've seen there but if you guys have a problem yeah that's one of the many reasons of is in favor of abolishing EU and going back to national currencies let's discuss that too I think you also brought a chart right oh yeah I could screen sharing now so I think you should be able to that's because I wanted to show people I mean I know that this is gonna sound people an outrageous set of ideas and so on and so forth but they need to get an idea of what's going on in the economy and why we have to do something about it this is the velocity of m2 Manning the rate of which money in in check accounts and savings concerns over on an annual basis and you

can see that this is it's a measure statistic and it's got problems with it I'm looking to say otherwise but I want to see in a very interesting trend that's happened to it for a long time it ran between about one point seven and one point nine times GAAP then we had the period of the the what was called the Great Moderation and that actually rose quite dramatically that's actually really representing the asset bubble that happened back in the 1992 to 2000 period then you had the decline and now look what's happened to it is down about 1.4 now since the coronaviruses hit it's plunging so what's going on here here clearly is is people spending much much

less money than they were doing beforehand which is sort of a holding effect but at the same time what's happening to loans and this is really showing this is dramatic I only saw this a couple of days ago commercial industrial loans were rising it you sort of not an under unexpected rate in America and then you get to here and that's what's happened they've been pushed into having to borrow to remain solvent there and also big workers that debts out of prudency just used all the facilities they had with their banks in order to have enough to survive the crisis right so that's that's that's

half a trillion dollars keep on going so that's going to send up on these on their debt books at some point and that's an increase in the level of private debt compared to Judy Pino we know GP is plunging right now and this is the really scary thing this is long term look at the level of debt and credit in the United States going go right back to 1830 so this is looking at the level of private debt that's the red line as a percentage of GDP this is 50 a hundred percent 150 over here you can see first of all that the level of private debt at the global financial crisis was greater as a percentage of GDP than the Great Depression even with the deleveraging that occurred after the crisis you've still got a level of debt

that's greater than the Great Depression and each time has been a serious crisis in America it's been negative credit this is the blue line is the rate of change of private debt that I call credit and that was it's minus 10 percent of GDP during the worst downturns that America has had now what we're likely to see after the initial stage of people borrowing money should be accessing credit lines to increase their leverage to tteok cash flow they can pay the commitments for a short while that might cause this to be positive for a while but it's going to go massively negative while the ratio might rise because notice here the ratio is rising or the amount of debt is

falling and what's going on there and as GDP fell by 20 percent 20 or 30 percent as people paid their debt down by 10 percent now we saw it's just happening in America right now the level of GDP might fall by 40 percent during this crisis so a 40 percent fall in GDP no change in the level of nominal debt you're going to get a dramatic increase in the debt ratio and you're already on the verge of bankruptcy and that that to me is where we simply have to do something to stop that happening after the crisis otherwise we'll have a financial crisis following on from the health crisis yeah man you yell at you've yeah that's some time ago he wrote if

this book can we avoid another financial crisis and you just answer the question and we are in it and it's there's no way to avoid it the only thing we can do is yeah to try to soften it and maybe the Jubilee would be a right way forwards but do you think that would be such a dramatic dramatic change that it would also lead to a completely new financial system afterwards because it's almost seems like it's such a big it's such a big step that it seems impossible that we continue like and we've been doing over the past decades with all this debt buildup that we need to also progress towards a better system afterwards more sustained yet

I think don't underestimate the capacity of the financial sector to try to push us back into the old pattern so I mean we financial the financial sector and that's again that the data I showed you look at thee just remember that the increase in private debt from the end of the Second World War forward back in the 1950s private debt in America was about 30% of GAAP and at that level the finance sector was timed you had bankers went to jail during the Great Depression you had bank holidays and forced bank holidays done by Roosevelt and so on the power the bankers was broken by the Great Depression in the Second World War and in the aftermath they were the servants of the industrial secretary had

an enormous amount of credit being created for industrial innovation and consumption and so on it was the Golden Age of capitalism now fast forward to where we are now the level of debt is five times what it was compared to jvp back then the finance sector is dominant it rules everything and politicians if they talk to anybody outside a political circle that talk to people in finance they're going to be following the opera's we've got to reestablish everything and you know get the finance sector back in control again that'll be the worst thing we can do now it's so possible we'll get the worse thing but I think this is as you say a time for a new financial architecture where we drastically reduced the power of the financial sector provide the money for people you can get get money to people's for spending and

to entrepreneurs for innovation and Finance trying to get a green revolution in this planet before we destroy it entirely it's that's what I'd like us to go for but I'm sure the finance sector will campaign for a return to business as usual after the crisis is over in the States we we've seen already quite a few lenders that have offered a few months of relief that you don't have to pay and this is already of course a sign of desperation if they allow millions of people not to pay for many months but of course that will only delay the problem and the problem will only be bigger after a few months because I'm sure interest rates or interest charges they

will continue and depth will not be any smaller well like you say GDP is contracting so what if we don't go for a Jubilee what would be the alternative then what kind of what kind of situation will we end up in then no I think we'll see people going bankrupt on a massive scale because as you say the so-called debt repayment holidays they're giving adjust period so you don't have to pay the debt we're going to continue recording that you row that debt and you haven't paid it so your debts going to compound doubly first of all because money you haven't paid while you can't pay during the coronavirus will be added to the amount that you use is currently owned they'll probably charge interests

on top of that as well so it'll compound at a super exponential rate you might find people coming out of the crisis with the dead level 10% of GDP higher than they went into it when GDP itself has collapsed on top of that so that's going to amplified once more yeah you could have people saying you know you just you asked me to pay my mortgage you asked me to pay my rent I've got no money left in my bank account I haven't got a job here are my keys jingle mail effect again and you could have a collapse in the American financial system once more so it would be either Jubilee or Melda of this I think that's pretty much yeah with the depression like figures high unemployment and then like a lost decade

basically yeah and and and political term I love it because this crisis has been so much faster than the last one this time people can't blame themselves so you know borrowing too much money to buy the house there was a certain amount of guilt that was pulled on households for you know mum and mum and dad made a terrible mistake of agreeing to a loan contract put forward by a bank which has 200 economics PhDs and 300 lawyers drafting at the moment that Lane themselves for signing the deal rather than saying isn't there something suspect about a bank offering this much money to us it's the banks that were really at fault not the individuals but the individual blame themselves I think

that put a lid on how much revolting there was how much revolt actually happened after the crisis this time around people are going to say we were screwed we didn't want to stay home we had to stay home no we're not going to put up with it there may be much more political turmoil after this and there was after the 2008 crisis but at the same time Steve when I see these queues for for people getting food packages because they have no savings but they still drive big pickups that day at least as well so there's of course their responsibilities people also need to take themselves that instead of trying to get the biggest car and try to save some money instead yeah I mean I think we've got it we're going to consumer driven society and we're now realizing

in lock down how much of that was garbage and that you know we also in eopsi coronaviruses just the very first major global phenomenon of climate change people reduced climate change to just global warming it's far more than that we're putting an enormous amount of pressure on the biosphere and that's one reason why these diseases evolve in the human species there's no point in them involving in any other predator because the numbers of all of the Predators have fallen the only predator whose numbers increasing in humans and the only predator hop on planes and fly somewhere else is humans so in that base that's we're just saying to pathogens hey one

that evolved when the human species much better much better prospects and evolving in lines or targets and other forms of pressure putting on the environment as well plastic pollution you know chemical pollution waste if we run processable wastes taking over the Wild Kingdom destroying forests etc etc all this stuff is putting enormous pressure on the biosphere and we're going to see many more more this not just not qualitatively like the coronavirus but having an impact upon the sustainability of our society like the coronavirus we're gonna have to go backwards dramatically so I'm not in favor of

monetary austerity but I think we're gonna have to practice a large amount of physical austerity in the next decade if we're gonna have any chance to survive as a civilization yeah in that sense it's the best wake-up call that we could have had what what is what is your view then that it might also need to - too much power with the government because I for one am very suspicious always when it comes to power in general general when it's when it's big corporates of course you want to be careful but also big government can be a scary prospect and by giving the government that much power to create and allocates money don't you them bring in all sorts of

other risk sectors and make and creating other problems I think we're gonna have a whole lot that frankly because we look like we've let the private sector rip for too long and saying the government's role is to slit the gut private sector ribbing and that would have worked if we are still living in what William Baumol decades ago called cowboy capitalism we have wide open spaces humans are a very small part of the ecological footprint and you can expand as much as you like and don't need to worry about waste when they're living in what he called spaceship economy spaceship capitalism and they were incredibly crowded we're putting enormous demands on the spaceship and we're dumping all our waste in the spaceship as well in that

situation we're going to have to go backwards and capitalism doesn't go back with voluntarily so I can see a real increase and state power inevitably out of this and info to some degree necessarily out of it where they will do it in children are very much touted I can see a lot of fascist elements coming into it as well but I think yeah we're going to see increase in the state whether we want it or not and it's because we let the private sector rip too much for the last 50 to 100 years yeah in cahoots with the government of course and it's it's a lie engines always be Hannibal little place and now we're going to have the going the other way but you know again the same sort of cahoots behaviors like that

continue as well of course I wouldn't mind to see if a few experiments across the world so maybe one country could could try your solution another country kids completely let people decide whatever currency they want to use yet another country can try to proceed the same way as now just to see how these different experiments would lead to different outcomes that would be very interesting for me to see saying the coronavirus enough I mean whether Europe has done it intentionally or not you're all Europe is closely following the Swedish model even though we just say not being Swedish is talking pretty Swedish and whereas Asia as follows of the what's called the yen

coronavirus model put forward by na yaar BAM I highly recommend looking at that page for the end coronavirus at all and he liked the pure Averett rush the curve he's talking favor extermination and it looks like a lot of Asia Australia and New Zealand and some a small handful of the country is again to exterminate the virus so in that world you're going to have a two part world one part without the virus and the other part with how that itself is a pretty crazy social experiment I don't think anybody's going to abolish money okay I think in fact this strengthens feared money because if you actually for example say well let's go across the bitcoin now you'd be

rewarding the people who gambled on Bitcoin for something that absolutely no anticipation off which was this virus it foresight them another fund another fire of course but but more in general but people bought Bitcoin because they didn't like exist the monetary order yeah but I mean how many transaction Bitcoin handle a second right now is it we above it will you back down to it want to be down to three now it's all about the lightning and trying to get a second good timing good timing I think a lot of things being hit by Thunderbolt you know this whole idea that we can have a lot genitive monetary system to me this crisis strengthens fiat money systems you might you might use you know

Bitcoin type currencies as a form of speculation and storage but it's not used for transactions and what we're likely to see I think is it's the same extended movement towards a universal basic income which i think is a good idea out of this crisis as well and in that world it might be digitally distributed but it won't it won't be a speculative currency and the way this would corn has been no well let's see I sure hope to see a thousand flowers bloom and and see what works best but I'm very sympathetic to to the whole idea of a Jubilee because I also see how unsustainable the current private debt load is so something has to be done

about it otherwise again it's all crashing down final topic briefly because I know he's been of course living in Amsterdam as well on the euro is something you have been of course diagnosing for a long time what's what's wrong with the euro and I think you're quite a proponent for just going back to national currencies right just yeah yeah and then I think it did it depth again I mean particularly the way italy was treated during the Cross responds Remini you know so much for European solidarity and it showed that the euro is there to stop things happening not to let things happen and you need to let things happen right now so it's symptom II did see it was part of the paralysis of Europe as meant

Europe has had such a bad performance on the on the coronavirus if they think is the worst countries in the world are America UK and Europe whereas the best countries in the world and the sim the whole thing are the Asian countries now they haven't got any if they've all got their own national currencies they've all got strong national governments they've all decided to provide money to let people continue operating it's it's intriguing this into its Europe and America have failed in this crisis there's much strengthened is much more ideology in America or in Europe than there is in Asia there's just acceptance of a strong role

for a state here and no nonsense like trying to join China and Japan into a common currency area and they're doing much much better so I think the real interesting experiment is countries that have always had some degree the belief in a strong state versus the libertarian hang-ups of Europe and America so but if if if a breakup of the euro is inevitable would a country then need to start preparing already by for example trying to get rid of all euro denominated assets like for example pension funds in Holland they own huge chunks of of Euro assets like like bonds of our countries for example would they

be wise then to start maybe secretly divesting these assets and and increase their euro debt because that will be a future should be worthless how how should you plan for a break up our country I think that one of the dangers is these things may never happen I mean I thought the Euro should break up during the financial process and they kept on going so I wouldn't be revising anybody to take that particular gamble on but yeah if if he Italy decides to you know it's had enough of the euro Italy suffered more than any other country I think and so the damaging impact of the euro on it if they don't decide right we're writing off all our debts tomorrow every bank account in Italy is now a new lira and there's no we we have no euro debts

to the rest of the world you know actually we are going to ever make sense not to have any any Italian bonds for yeah so you but then the ECB will probably back those bonds I mean it's all it again it's back to accounting you know the when when before a crisis hits all these things were impossible when a crisis hits all these things happen so you know I skeptical about the extent that they've lived you know European bondholders failed they probably go in and rescue them again and buy risky and they'd validate the approach to money that people like myself have had for the last 50 years and that is wrong they'd validate it in one stroke yeah so a Jubilee would also

be almost impossible in in Europe together although yeah to get everyone on the same page yeah possible yeah I think so I mean that's another vision against the around that's sobering I should get the hell out of doing you inside and Steve it will be too late oh yeah I got here one day before they started to close the border datura so I'm sorry that you can't join me love until after the virus is over anyway okay well it's very inspiring again to talk to you Steve thanks so much for making time vailable is there anything else you you'd like to add oh I'm just a major thing I've been doing in researchers you know in the last decade

is my last year rather is focusing on climate change and the absolutely appalling garbage that has been pumped out by Richard toll William Nordhaus and all these moronic neoclassical mainstream economists I'd like people to check out my patreon page which normally you know is normally most of the articles they are free then if it be a patron to read them as I try to pull apart this stuff and say why they've got us into a serious crisis in which this is just the first taste and we have to get rid of the bastards kicked them out of positions of authority so we have any chance to have a survivable planet for the next decade that's that's my main message and for the meantime I'll be coming it out on my patreon page at patreon.com slash prof. Steve King right

it's the one yep yeah I'll put it also in the show notes great words I advise everyone to take a look and and follow and support for Steve online and also financially thanks again Steve and good luck there enjoy your time thank you hopeful news live in Holland so once the once the crisis over weekend maybe it may be in 2020 sure okay okay