The New Great Depression: growth, lockdowns, Bitcoin and SDRs
De Week van Bitcoin · 18 Feb 2021 · 31:04
Author Jim Rickards talks with Paul Buitink about his book The New Great Depression. Rickards argues that the United States has been in a depression of below-trend growth since 2008 and puts real unemployment at 12 to 15 percent once people outside the labor force are counted. He argues that lockdowns damage economies and are hollowing out New York, says Bitcoin's fixed supply makes it unsuitable as a reserve currency because it would be deflationary, and expects a new issue of IMF Special Drawing Rights this year.
Speakers
Topics
From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.
Transcript
hello everybody my name is paul beijing and today i'm going to talk to the man who hardly needs an introduction best-selling author jim rickards i just finished reading his latest book the new great depression and i'm honored to have him on the show today to talk about this book his view on the pandemic economy and how to preserve your wealth hi jim welcome hi paul how are you good yeah good to see you again um so let's let's start with with the new great depression um you talk about the new great depression how would you define a great depression well it's a good question and it it's kind of points to the distinction between a depression and a recession and there are two different things um
recession people are familiar with economists use the term all the time and it has that numeric definition it's two or more consecutive quarters of declining gdp there are a couple other factors that go in but that's the basic rule of thumb so two consecutive quarters two or more of declining gdp that's the recession uh of course we had a recession at least in the united states actually probably most of the world and the first half of uh 2020 uh first quarter and second quarter were both down uh and uh and and there's the recession so the third quarter uh growth was was quite strong it didn't come all the way back uh compared to what was lost in the first half but it was strong and um so that you could argue that the
recession was over by july of uh 2020. uh that we have a group in the united states called the national bureau of economic research it's a private group of economists but they're the official scorekeepers if you will about recessions they did declare recessions started in the first quarter they haven't said it's over but it's very likely that they'll they'll reach that conclusion um depression is different uh economists first of all don't like the word depression because it's more subjective it's not as quantitative it involves a lot of um almost psychological behavioral behavioral variables if you will but depressions are real they happen and we're in one now
uh but economists just don't like to talk about it they they've kind of banned the d word as i put it from the vocabulary so um a lot of people assume that if a recession is two quarters or more of declining gdp and depression sounds worse that must be ten quarters of declining gdp some really horrible economic outcome and that's not the definition you can actually have growth in a depression but the point is it's depressed growth its growth below trend uh below potential um and for that matter i think you could make a good case that we've been in in a depression since uh 2008. uh you look at the recovery okay we had a recovery from 2009 to 2019
it was the longest expansion in u.s history but it was also the weakest expansion in u.s history the average annual growth during that entire 10-year period was about 2.2 percent whereas uh in all all recoveries uh post 1980 uh the average recovery was 3.2 so there's an example where you had growth but it was a full percentage point below uh trend below what we had done previously if you go back even further to um to the end of world war ii forward uh average recoveries were closer to 4.5 so if that's the potential in a developed economy and you're growing at 2.2 that's depressed growth we can leave the uh the definite
definition what happened for those 10 years for another day but uh now the point is we've had a technical recession we may be approaching another technical recession of the first back-to-back recession since 1980 but that aside we're in a period of depressed growth we won't recover uh 2009 levels of output um until late this year at the earliest maybe probably early 2022 um and uh this will persist for not just years but for perhaps a decade or more this will be intergenerational in its impact so that's what i mean by depression i did an interview the other day
um and i said this you know could be or was a appeared to be worse than the great depression and the uh person i was interviewing with said well hold on you know the the great depression they recited some statistics since it hasn't been that bad yet i said well you're missing the point uh those uh figures from the great depression took four years to play out uh we've only been or in some ways ten years if you go all the way up to 1940 we've only been in this for about a year so let's you know call me next year of the year after see where things stand but in my view we're in a new great depression it will persist uh we'll have intergenerational effects and will be very very difficult to get out of even periods of growth will be a very weak
growth yeah because i can imagine a lot of people think about high unemployment rate for example if they think about the great depression um and if you look at the unemployment rate when we last spoke in april what was sky high around 15 percent and then it's it's uh it went down all the way to around 6.3 of course you can have a whole discussion about the definition of unemployment um in your book you also describe the labor force participation rate which has been declining over over time but just purely looking at the unemployment rate it seems like we are in a much better state now purely based on that number than we were when we were dropping uh steadily since um really since the late 1990s but more steeply since 2008
fell off a cliff in in 2020 but it's dropped uh over 10 years or so from the high 60s to the low 60s now that doesn't sound like a lot you're talking about almost 10 percent of a workforce of 120 million people so this is uh 12 million people or so who don't have jobs uh but we're not talking just about you know early retirees or baby boomers or uh you know teenagers or others these are uh basically able-bodied of people between the ages of 25 and 54 uh prime working age there are uh over 10 million of them who are who don't have jobs but they're not counted as unemployed because
they're not looking for jobs but the point i make is well if you're a bartender in a town where every bar is closed uh you know what's the point of looking for a job maybe you can move to phoenix arizona and put solar panels together but that's not very likely the point is um and and that that labor force participation rate never gets to 100 it barely gets never gets over 70 there are good reasons for some people not to have jobs you could be a student it could be a homemaker um you know as i say there are other reasons but when it drops that much you have a large pool and by the way i've been speaking about this for a long time other analysts have as well jay powell uh chairman of the fed mentioned it in a speech last week so it's even beginning to sink in at the
fed a little bit he said well what we're saying right now which is if you take um the uh be able by the americans who are don't have jobs but not looking for them and add them to the unemployed list um that number uh percentage number goes up to about uh 12 or 15 and that is a depression level unemployment rate yeah we met once in new york around 10 years ago when we set up an interview between you and james turk that was in 2011. i visited new york a few times afterwards and i really love spending time there but i haven't been there now in many years how would you describe the situation there now with all is there still um talk of of a lockdown or are bars
opening up again uh could you describe a little bit the setting of new york at the moment yeah it's it's more lockdown than not uh and this is by the way the evidence is is overwhelming for many studies both international and comparing states in the united states and lockdowns do not work to stop the spread of the virus they're very good at destroying economies uh they don't stop the spread of the virus we've seen for example in the united states we have 50 states well we never had a national lockdown it went state by state governor by governor in some cases mayor by mayor so we have a pretty good uh we have a diverse set of experiences so there were places like um california and new york that had extreme
lockdowns you had a place like florida which had more of a moderate lockdown you have a state like south dakota which uh had no lockdown they the governor said you know wash your hands social distance uh you know if you don't want to go out to a restaurant that's fine but we're not going to tell you you can't we'll make it voluntary the same thing was true around the world we saw extreme lockdowns in in italy and uh spain and uh france in uh in the first wave in 2000 into sorry in 2020 we had some countries that did moderate lockdowns i would put sweden in that category and some countries that at least initially had no lockdowns and brazil is an example of that so we now
have the data we have the 50 states we have 30 or more countries around the world and what the data shows clearly is that there is no correlation between lockdown policy and the spread of the disease um or put you know put in more statistical terms the lockdown policy has no material impact on the spread of the virus whatever policy you pursue you get pretty much the same results in terms of caseloads and uh fatalities i had i did another interview um earlier today i was a large international audience a lot of people from asia and one question said you know well uh new zealand had a very severe lockdown and the the spread of the disease
declined and uh could the united states learn from new zealand i said no i said i don't i don't doubt that you have a lot i know you had a lockdown i know the disease declined but it would have declined anyway and that's that's really the point and we see that from a lot of data so lockdowns don't help but they do destroy economies and that's what we've seen in new york um now they say they're easing up but let's define that so restaurants can have indoor seating but only at 25 of capacity uh sports arenas can have um fans and you know in the seats but only at 10 capacity and only if you bring a recent uh test result with you like a little you know qr qr code on your iphone etc
um that's that's tan amount to a lockdown they say the reasoning up but they're not really using up uh the impact on the economy is devastating and it's not just a question of business shutting down and then reopening you know six weeks later eight weeks later a lot of these businesses don't survive uh perhaps half of small businesses uh are going out of business permanently those job losses are not temporary they're permanent the owners of you know let's say a restaurant or bar salon a boutique shop they're closing their doors breaking their leases selling their equipment at bargain basement prices and the workers are never getting their jobs back now you know eventually those people will get jobs and perhaps a restaurant owner will move to a
different state move to florida and open a new restaurant next year uh mustangs the end of the world but i'm saying it's the end of millions of small businesses and that's about half the economy in the u.s so new york streets are pretty much abandoned uh murder rate has doubled uh crime in the subway is you know people are afraid to walk into the subways tax bases eroded uh there's graffiti everywhere uh stores are still boarded up some of them um and and the city's depopulating we um in the united states when you move i suppose it's true in other countries around the world when you move you can go to the post office and put in a notice of your new address and that way the post office will
forward your mail so mail comes to the old address will be sent to the new address through october from january to october 2020 there were 300 000 of those mail a change addresses filed new york it's a public record well that's one per household so if you assume an average household of three people you know it could be more or less in a particular case that's um upwards of a million people leaving new york and that was still october i don't doubt that that number is significantly higher today it's only a city of 8 million so you have a million people moving out cities are the greatest wealth creation wealth generating uh agglomerations in the history of civilization
and they're depopulating uh so you're destroying the wealth generating potential of the cities and it's not just new york it's chicago los angeles san francisco um portland seattle uh baltimore and and elsewhere do you think a city like new york will ever regain its former status or do you think it will from here on words only um decline um i think that the decline will continue uh probably because of the political leadership if you don't change the politicians you should expect more of the same um and a lot of this is irreversible you know when you when a business um or an individual moves you don't move back six months later i
mean you could i guess but they're they're moving you know one of the questions you have to ask is okay they're leaving new york and the other cities invention where are they going well we know they're going to miami austin texas nashville tennessee phoenix scottsdale arizona um and boise idaho among denver among other cities so there's an exodus out of a lot of cities going to either suburbs or ex-serbs or in many cases other cities miami's booming so there's a vicious feedback loop then for new york because people leave and then companies will close more people leave etc etc yeah this is not martial this is this is massive this isn't exodus yeah and in your book you talk a lot
about velocity and monetary velocity um because the first part of the book is about kovit about the measures how effective they were and then the second part of the book is more about the economic consequences of the policies by governments and especially in the us velocity is something that you keep on hammering about right now velocity of m2 has um has decreased a lot of over the over time like it have from a little bit more than two to a little bit more than one even though the monetary base has has doubled the fed balance sheet has doubled we see that the velocity has halved so the effect i guess is neutral and without velocity there's no economy
what would be the best way to increase velocity to make people spend again well the important thing is the velocity is a psychological concept it's not a monetary concept the austrian economist monitors neokinsians all of the bureau if you print a lot of money you'll get inflation that's just not true military was wrong about that um it's not the money printing that causes inflation is the velocity is the turnover of money um and you know the quantity theory money is just an identity people say well doesn't that you know prove that velocity is not constant doesn't prove that you know quantity theory money doesn't work no i mean it doesn't prove that at all the quantity theory money is just the definition it's like saying a equals a what it proves is that
velocity is not constant you have to you as a it's good for thought experiments but as a guide to policy it's challenging because you can't what milton friedman did he held velocity constant and said he could dial up or dial down the money supply and and with a cap on real gdp potential and no desire for inflation if you want p to be one q to be 3.5 percent and your whole velocity constantly you just dial the money supply up or down you get maximum real growth with no inflation that was nirvana the only problem with that is that velocity is not constant there was a wrong assumption and we see that you mentioned them too but you can other slightly different velocity numbers depending on the my supply whether it's m0
m1 or m2 but m1 the fall is even steeper it's going from about almost 11 to three it's been cut by two-thirds so yeah the fed is double the money supply uh practically but uh with velocity dropping like that the uh nominal gdp is up barely well it's not up and we're still below 2019 output levels um so i remind people uh seven trillion dollars times zero is zero if you don't have velocity you don't have an economy so the question is how do you get velocity to change that's psychological it's based on expectations you have to get expectations to change so central banks think that they can do it by
holding interest rates at zero but what message is the central bank sending when interest rates are zero they're saying that they're worried about deflation well if you're worried about deflation why should i spend money i'll just hold on to my money wait till prices drop and go buy things more cheaply in the future um or in fact the real value of cash increases in deflation so i'll increase my allocation to cash i'll increase my savings so the fed doesn't understand any of this they barely you know they just don't understand monetary policy they think they're acting in a stimulus way they're actually impotent uh because um because they can't control velocity and by holding rates at zero they're sending a signal that they're worried about deflation so people will save more and
spend less uh so you're getting exactly the opposite results now how do you change velocity how do you change expectations you need to devalue the dollar uh but not against the euro or the yen or sterling i mean that that's all irrelevant those cross rates um they trade in a ban i mean if you're a currency trader i mean if you're concentrating care about it if you're in the export import business you might care about it but for um understanding the value of currencies the fact that they you know they don't go to zero they don't go to the moon they just trade back and forth in a band but they're all in the same boat you're not you're never going to have a world where people have completely lost confidence in the dollar but they're flocking to the euro that's not going to happen the euro and the
dollar are going to kind of go up and down together with some fluctuation in the cross rate the only way to devalue the currency and change inflation expectations is to increase the dollar price of gold yeah but you can also develop all currencies against all uh commodities right so the central bankers can come together and and and jointly decide to produce more money um possibly via the emittance of more sdr but they can jointly of course devalue against everything not just gold right now by extending their balance sheets well no they can't as i just said they raise increase the balance sheet doesn't do any good at all what you have to do is do something else
that would cause commodity prices to rise now well oils and gold has doubled in the last five years uh oil is going up uh recently um so that that trend may be emerging but it's emerging very slowly you could accelerate that with a with a declaration that you know just gold is five thousand dollars an ounce and you know the fed had an emergency meeting took their votes it goes five thousand dollars an ounce if you think it's cheap um come and get it the doors of fort knox are open if you think it's expensive deliver it to us and we'll pay for it we're using the printing press if you use the golden fort knox and the fed printing press to maintain a market your buyer let's say 49.95 and sell or 5050 then the price of gold is uh 5 000 an
ounce and the purpose of doing that would not be to reward gold holders i mean it might do that but that's not the idea the idea is to change expectations and get the price of everything else to go up because the world of five thousand dollar gold is also the world of you know four hundred dollar oil one hundred dollar silver twenty dollar corn et cetera this has happened before that's happened twice once in uh 1933 and once after 1971. and how much bigger will the fed balance sheet uh be after uh after they've completed that uh revaluation well it might not be bigger at all but this but my point is that the fed balance sheet doesn't matter what matters is uh inflation expectations and that's the
people the people that read the newspaper and see about this then think okay we better start spending and and start exchanging our money so the velocity goes up or because right now we see a lot of news articles about the central banks extending the balance sheets but it doesn't it doesn't lead to inflation expectations amongst consumers but does a gold revaluation then does it lead to inflation expectations amongst the common men yeah absolutely because people understand gold and as i say it has actually happened this is not theoretical after yard franklin donald roosevelt did 1933 on purpose and it worked brilliantly um richard nixon did it by accident but it also worked look at the
borderline hyperinflation by the late 1970s so people will get it but again it's not just about gold it's about expectations and that's that's uh it's the easiest way to do it it's the clearest way to do it because gold isn't good for anything gold is a form of money uh it's perfect for uh devaluing the dollar as i just described it's not good for anything else it's not an industrial input like silver it's not uh i guess they use it to code space elements and a few other things but not much people talk about jewelry but jewelry is just wearable wealth uh yeah it's just gold you wrap around your neck uh but you still treat it as a as a store of wealth so gold is the perfect instrument i mean i suppose the united states could go out and uh build up the price of oil
but but why bother if you don't need the oil gold is a much easier way to do it yeah you go a gold price of uh 2500 early 2021 in the book of course the book is uh is already a few months old but these that that seems difficult to reach because we only have a few months left if you would define the first half of this year's early 2021 um and later on you expect 14 000 in 2025 that seems very bullish well not really because um the math is kind of simple what what people lose sight of you know say well gee well i'll choose 2 000 as a baseline i mean uh that that'll happen by the way when interest rates turn around so right now as we're speaking
um interest rates i'm talking about the yield of maturity on 10-year treasury notes so an intermediate term rate um is going up but that can't persist because it will grind the economy to a whole so that's going to turn around it's happened four times by the way in the last 10 years you look at a charter to be able to mature in 10 year notes and it has gone up but every time it went up it reached a lower peak than the time before so the previous peaks were kind of three percent two percent you know one and a half percent uh it's announced that maybe one and a quarter but it will turn around quickly announced to 15 000 announced that's only a seven percent increase now it's the same thousand dollars if you have an ounce of gold you made a thousand bucks in both situations
but those percentage increases unless you know when you do the chart logarithmically that's different but if you uh this percentage increases becomes smaller and smaller as the denominator gets larger and larger so uh you know you as i say you've got to get the 3000 before you get to 14 000. but once he gathers momentum those subsequent gains you know going from 10 to 11 is a 10 percent increase down from 14 to 15 is a seven percent increase it keeps getting smaller so it goes very quickly at the end even though it starts out slowly but all the more reason to get gold now so you can participate in those uh in those games but many investors have heard these forecasts now for ten plus years right that the gold would go to two thousand three thousand five
thousand uh over the past few months it's been it's been going down even well yeah that's that's really interesting are going up like like uh crypto for example yeah well crypto is nonsense but um yeah the uh uh gold uh has been going down the the past a few weeks went down yesterday because interest rates are going up but gold hit uh two thousand seventy dollars an ounce last august eighth so anyone who predicted two thousand dollar goal was correct yeah but it was since 2011 that he hasn't hadn't reached that level well uh that's not true well it bonded well in 2011 2015 you had a bear market 2015 was the bottom and it's doubled since 2015 and went over two thousand dollars
in august eight twenty twenty so this is the facts yeah i know you know if we want to take a come on take a one-way perspective that's fine but good luck with that no i mean i believe in diversified portfolio and i think gold should be part of that um but i also what i like about your book is that you at the end you also come up with some investment uh advice or how you believe a portfolio could be structured um but one thing is missing and i already briefly touched upon it earlier is bitcoin or crypto in general last time we spoke in april you called it a uh a massively uh manipulated instrument and um and basically fraud do you still hold that opinion sure i mean look i'm not saying i can't go up could go up to
a hundred thousand i i i wouldn't rule that out i did an interview when uh bitcoin was eight thousand but it was good this was in late 2017 it was going up almost like a thousand dollars a day so seven thousand eight thousand nine thousand i said uh it could go to twenty thousand and uh and then it will crash and that's exactly what happened it went to twenty thousand it crashed eighty percent all right now it's back to fifty that's fine first of all i have a one word uh uh piece of advice for any bitcoin holders called tether uh tether is uh uh has never accounted for the dollar proceeds and there's good reason to believe that they take the dollars and invest in bitcoin so that makes the tether bitcoin relationship the biggest ponzi in the history of the world um and uh as far as bitcoin being some
kind of reserve currency that's nonsense because reserve currencies aren't actually currencies they're bonds in other words people say you know the dollar is the leading reserve currency in the world 60 percent of global reserves but it's not as if the people's bank of china has pallets of 100 bills in in the basement of the of the bank they have u.s government securities that are denominated in dollars so you can't have a reserve currency unless you have a liquid bond market with all the surrounding plumbing of a bond market you need primary dealers auctions when issue trading futures options hedging vehicles payments systems and the rule of law all of which would take at least 10 years to build maybe 20.
uh if you could the us has been doing it for 230 years but the point being um people don't invest in currencies they invest in securities denominated in the currency so where's the bitcoin bond market well the answer is it doesn't exist there's nothing to invest in by bitcoin but you know no central there's a lending market of course sorry there's a lending market for bitcoin uh yeah i could sign up and borrow some bitcoin and um you know it's not liquid and there's no rule of law but you know good luck with it but but the point is and it's very small by the way so either musk is full then in your view for uh for purchasing 1.5 billion through tesla uh yeah uh you know he's he's uh he's uh he's he's
the pt barnum of our age uh but uh but here's the um uh but here's the thing about bitcoin there will never be a bitcoin bond market the reason is and it shows that the uh applied mathematicians and developers you know satoshi nakamoto if it you know assuming that's whoever that was if it's not a team from raytheon let's say um they uh they basically said we hate central banks this is public they behave central banks they print too much money blah blah blah so they put a cap on bitcoin that shows that they know nothing about monetary economics uh bitcoin's capital i think around 21 million coins that could be off a little bit but that's approximate number but the amount of electricity and computing power uh and mathematical application you have to go through to generate each
additional coin gets exponentially greater so you'll never get to the less coin but you know you'll get close and we're almost there now we're at about 18 million points outstanding um and then it stops well if you fix the amount of currency but the economy continues to grow i mean the bitcoin groupies uh didn't like central bank printing well central bank printing can be abused and has been abused but if it's done correctly the money supply grows in accordance with the economy that's why gold is so attractive because gold is not static the output is about 1.6 a year of the above ground supply population growth is about the same real growth can be a little bit higher but it it pretty much it syncs up pretty well uh with um economic growth but if you stop bitcoin
here and the economy continues to grow that's naturally deflationary i mean each bitcoin buys a bigger piece of this economy and that's why people like ray dalio and paul jones are running around talking about you know hundred thousand dollar bitcoin or more why not right but but the problem is you'll never have a bond market because why would anybody borrow in the deflationary currency you have to pay back more than you owe the point is uh it stands in the way of a bond market because borrowers want inflationary currencies not deflationary currencies and the result of that is you'll never have a bond market and therefore it won't serve as a reserve currency it's just you know it's um you know if you want to gamble go for it i mean i i
i'm not again i'm not against it i'm not saying don't uh it should be outlawed i think people should be able to you know kind of waste the money any way they like a final question jim because i know you're a time trapped as well um sdr i saw a recent announcement that there might be an new emission of sdrs coming especially now also with leadership change in the us and biden seems more open towards it than trump do you think a new allotment of sdr is coming in this year yeah it's very likely and they've said 500 billion for a number but some people are talking about as much as 2 trillion i talked about this in uh four years ago in chapter two of my book uh the road to
ruin i i detailed like i i don't it is an sdr special drawing writer i call world money because that's what it is but i explained how it was coming uh so yeah i said that uh four years ago and here it is cool any other comments from your side no it's uh um interesting times i guess the the point i would make is that um depressions are intergenerational and their impact and we'll be um feeling the effects of this for not 30 months or 30 weeks or 30 months but for 30 years okay well let's let's hope things are not as as grim as as you describe in the book and um and and let's hope we can get things back to
normal as soon as possible but thanks so much for your time jim and talk to you again in the future thank you paul
