Modern Money Theory: taxation, deficits and inflation
De Week van Bitcoin · 14 Mar 2016 · 1:04:39
Richard van der Linde interviews L. Randall Wray of the University of Missouri Kansas City, author of Modern Money Theory, on how a government that issues its own currency differs from a household. Wray argues that such a government cannot run out of money, that the real limit is inflation and available resources, and that taxes create demand for the currency. He criticises the idea of debt-free money promoted by Positive Money, discusses the job guarantee, and describes what the second edition of his book adds on taxes.
Speakers
Topics
From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.
Transcript
okay welcome everybody uh this is a new episode of reent money my name is Richard vandelinda I'll be your host today and with us is Dr L Randall Ray from the University of Missouri Kansas City um Dr Ray wrote the book understanding modern money as early as 1998 and more recently he authored modern money Theory a primer on macroeconomics for sovn monetary systems he's also starring in the recent documentary called boom bus Boom by our very own uh Theo cooken who is one of the writers of that and uh which is getting a lot of attention in the media uh at the moment Dr Ray welcome thanks good you could be here um
as a start could you explain what the essence is of mmt modern monetary Theory well we we start uh with the recognition that a naal government that issues its own money is nothing like a household or a firm and so whenever we hear a politician say that if I ran my household budget the way the United States government runs its budget I would go bankrupt and then implying that the it's the national government that is operating in the wrong manner um we say this complete nonsense the Uncle Sam is nothing like a household nothing like a
firm Uncle Sam is the issuer of our currency uh Uncle Sam can never run out of money so when know President Obama uh after the global financial crisis said you know well we really wish we could do more to get the economy out of the very deep recession but we run out of money well this is completely false and so it's either he doesn't understand how the monetary system works or he's just flat out Ling to the population um so that's the the the main difference between us and the mainstream then we we need to go into all the details of how it is that governments actually spend why they can't run out of money why they can't be forced to
default on their own obligations why they are not subject to the whims of the Bond vigilantes who might decide not to lend to the government you know and all this other nonsense that has built up over the past 40 years right yeah so basically you say a government and a house household cannot be compared in the sense that the government is the issuer of money uh and needs to spend it first before it can collect the money through taxation for instance whereas a household should first earn the money before it can spend yeah almost okay I I try not to use the word money in the way that you are because then uh we get it all all
uh bundled up in the misunderstandings of the terminology right and of semantics so I would say the government is the issuer of our currency rather than saying the issue of our money uh it is our currency that the government issues um and that uh households and firms can issue IUS they they can issue liabilities that are denominated in money so and my former Professor was hman Minsky who appears in the film that you were just uh mentioning he used to say anybody can
create money the problem is to get it accepted and what he meant was that anybody can sign their name I owe you5 the problem is to get others to accept it okay so uh households need to earn income and when their income is short they might decide to issue IUS which promise to pay plus promise interest and they can become insolvent in those promises it might turn out they actually cannot repay those loans um The Sovereign government is different it promises to pay its own currency it cannot run out of its own
currency currency so this is a big difference between households and the government all right um does that also mean that the government can spend as much as it wants on anything it wants or is there an a natural limit to it before you enter um inflation or even hyperinflation yeah well you would definitely hit inflation and perhaps eventually hyperinflation if the government decided the sky is the limit I'm going to spend uh without any limit whatsoever then uh of course the government could drive the economy to an
high inflation um the limit is real resources so if the government only purchases or hires re resources that are currently unemployed then that will not be inflationary by itself but if the government starts bidding against the private sector saying we'll pay more than you pay uh and if the private sector reacts by upping their bids then the government can start a bidding war and cause inflation so the government needs to be very careful in how much it spends the problem is not insolvency the problem is inflation okay and um how do we know if if the government is is
spending enough or maybe too much or perhaps not even enough yeah well there are two indicators um one is if there are unemployed resources uh in the economy so uh unemployment by itself is evidence that the government is not spending enough to employ people um however you can get inflation before you get full employment it depends on what the government is uh Buy so the if the government said that um we're going to um colonize Mars and our goal is to do that within
the next 10 years then you can imagine that the government is going to start bidding up the prices of the labor resources and the other kinds of inputs to missions to Mars uh this could very easily lead to a bidding war for for the most skilled engineers and so on because the the government would be bidding already employed resources that are being used in private sector the government would be bidding those away the government can win the bidding war and that will probably cause inflation even before full employment so it's very important for the government to focus its spending in areas where there's excess capacity
in that case it's not going to be inflationary all right um mmt um is seen as as one of the more alternative views on economics uh it's not really considered mainstream however uh it seems to be picked up more and more by the mainstream media outlets and and for example yesterday uh Bloomberg covered uh mmt in one of their articles um in which President Obama was quoted uh with saying small businesses and families are tightening their belts their government should too what what do you think of such a statement well that's a complete
misunderstanding of macroeconomics as it's been taught for oh 80 years um during the Great Depression we under we came to understand and I mean by we uh policy makers politicians and almost all economists almost all understood that in a deep downturn the government has to move in the opposite direction of the economy it needs to expand um in early in the Great Depression um you know they didn't understand this and they thought that the best solution
was to liquidate everything sell everything unemploy everybody and somehow that that was going to be the right solution to the Great Depression but what they found out is the government has to spend more and it may need to cut taxes too that is the way that you get an economy out of a deep downturn yeah so is is that that in line with the King view that that in in a downturn the economy with a slump government needs to step in and actually spend more to get more effective demand in an economy actually to to get uh the economy by itself on a higher level where the government can stop back yeah
and you know nowadays we say that's the Keynesian view and and KES gave the theoretical justification for this in his 1936 book but in the United States we were already doing that uh President Roosevelt enacted the new deal and that was substantially already in place by the time the general theory came out so it was recognized already before kings that the government needed to spend more the government needed to hire the unemployed so yes it's good to give KES the credit but he wasn't the only one who recognize this okay um there seems to be a lot of um support for for the the the positive money movements uh that we have
throughout Europe every country seems to have their own movement um what's your take on their view that the government can um seem to be close to what you're saying can spend more can actually some sort of a basic income um or or civilians dividends um and by thatb stimulating the economy and they can actually issue that money uh debt free well you that I I'm I'm glad to see people advocating the government playing a bigger role in the economy and understanding that the government can spend its own currency into existence I think that these are
um uh important understandings that have been lost for a very long time I everyone understood this in the 19th century that governments spend their currency into existence it was obvious and so a lot of the people today are going back and looking at the the green backs for example uh you could also look at the tally sticks used all over Europe the government spent their own currency into existence taxed it back and then burned the tax revenue as soon as they received it back they just burned it they understood the government does not spend tax revenue the government spends so that taxpayers can pay their taxes so it's nice that we're sort of recovering
ideas that have been lost a long time but I think there's an awful lot of confusion in the positive um money U movement and frankly I can't can't quite get a handle on what they think they believe uh this idea that you can issue a debt-free money is just complete nonsense government currency is the government's liability the government is liable to accepted back in tax payment right if the if the government said we're going to issue currency but we're not liable for anything we don't have to take this back uh it's not going to get accepted currency needs to be
redeemed in tax payment or other payments to the government and this is the way that it always worked in the past so I don't know why they refuse to actually look in detail at the way things worked in the 19th century the way that green backs actually work these were debts of the government right and they were debts because they uh the currency that was issued um by the government spent spent as as as as money U had to be accepted for tax payments right yeah in fact in the United States every time there was a paper money act enacted by the government so it would
authorize the government to issue paper money it also uh imposed taxes for Redemption they were called Redemption taxes they were to redeem the currency this was how the government made sure that that currency would be demanded and then they would take it out of the economy when the taxes were paid so everyone understood this in 19th century I don't know why it's so hard to understand now no do you have any idea where the the confusion uh comes from because a few weeks ago we interviewed uh Steven zanger on this channel on the show and he said and I quote um mm's focus on credit debt as money is the IR
there are plenty of other money forms they should reap and I know you're quite aware with NEP so um it started with NEP yeah could you may explain what ne's ideas are and and how you feel about that yeah well I naap um developed what he called the state theory of money it is that the state issues its own currency the state imposes taxes and the state can name what will accept back in tax payment I think what might possibly be confusing zarena is that he also said governments can choose if they want to to accept back Private Bank notes in tax payment and thereby sort of give them
the status of estate money this is true but I I don't understand why he thinks that we don't understand that that's where the whole modern money Theory movement started nap someone who's much better actually is um Mitchell inis who wrote a little bit after nap and it doesn't seem to have been aware of nap's writing which we seem to have a small issue with the connection but he did was to generalize the credit theory of money to include St money we made it very clear
that state money is also a credit money and the uh debt of the issuer which the state must take back in payment in the same way that Banks must take back their own bank notes in the old days they use Bank notes instead of Bank deposits they must take those back and payments to the banks so in other words if you have a debt to the bank you repay that debt in the old days by delivering Bank notes to the bank today you write a check on your banking account so you use your checking deposit the bank must take this back in Redemption if it doesn't it is defaulted on its obligation in the same way that a state that refuses to take back its own
currency in tax payment is defaulting on its obligation to take it back so this is what en said in 19134 I I think if zarlena would read that he might improve his understanding the okay to to get it clear um uh would you call bank credit money would that fit the the definition of money for you well remember I don't like to get into these semanic uh debates uh this the bank deposit is a money denominated liability issued by the bank so I wouldn't call it money itself I would reserve the term money to mean the unit of account in the
United States it's the dollar in Europe it's the Euro and so on so let's call let's use the term money for the money of account and then we can issue Kane's called them money things but we can also call them Money Records um we can all issue Money Records denominated in that money account a bank deposit is a Money Record it's a record of the bank's liability to the deposit holder okay that's awkward terminy ology but it's precise right and so we don't get into an argument about whether the bank deposit is money or the currency is money or Bank Reserves held at the central Banker money or a checkable
savings account is money uh the dividing line between what most people want to call money and what I am calling money denominated liabilities is arbitrary right it changes over time and what most people seem to mean is something you can actually go to the store and use to buy something um which you know is sort of a a Rough and Ready definition that sort of works a lot of the time but then you start getting into debates because there are things that have almost all those characteristics but as sometimes in places they're not accepting in payment
right which is true even of currency fly on the airplane and try to use your cash to buy a glass of wine some Airlines will say no we don't take currency we only take credit cards others will say we don't take credit cards we only take currency so sometimes you can use currency sometimes you can't yeah yeah I want to go into um uh Bitcoin with you but first I got a question from one of our viewers um Yan zela he asked did the Roman Republic use a credit money system um yes it did in the sense that sure they issued coins and the coins were the liability of the state they were accepted back by the state and payments
to the state at the nominal value yes okay now a lot of people get confused because it it was very common from the time of the Greek city states until well the 20th century to issue coins that has some precious metal content so a lot of people think oh gold coins uh are not consistent with what you're arguing because gold coins are a commodity money but actually this is not true if you you look at the Roman coins or the Greek coins they never have uh a value stamped on them but they the nominal value of them is determined
by what nominal value they are accepted at in payments to the state right so it is true that in some circumstances the value of a coin can fall to the value of the precious metal embodied in the coin and that would be either because the state has defaulted on its promise to accept these in payments or because you're well beyond the boundaries of the state that issu them and therefore they become nothing but precious metal but that is the exception in Roman law coins were
valued by the nominal value not by the commodity money value and the nominal value is almost always well above the commodity uh gold or silver value of coins okay so so it was a credit money system but but there was the backing of the commodity value of the the type of money they were using no let's this way coins are the debt of the state that issues them and that date that debt happens to be stamped on precious metal right that's all okay it happens to be stamped on precious metal yeah and exactly why they stamp it on precious
metal rather than on a clay tablet or a piece of paper or Notch it in a tally stick or stamp it on base metal is uh partly uh sort of a a custom and tradition partly technology to reduce counterfeiting and partly a um possible mercantilist story so we need to get into the specific of each individual uh gold coin or silver coin why it was issued that way in order to explain why they used precious metal
rather than just stamping on a piece of paper Okay often the answer is counterfeiting right so it wasn't because of the intrinsic value of the gold it actually got the intrinsic value from the fact that it was used as money probably it it got its nominal value from the fact that it could be used to make payments yes okay all right um well we talked about um What government policy uh should be aimed at or what indicators it could use to see if it should stimulate more um or not and uh that that's where you talked about unemployment mmt seems to go hand in
hand also with the the job guarantee uh a program where uh any unemployed in a country um actually gets the opportunity to work for the government um that seems to be um a program that is not really appealing especially not to for instance the austrians um could you explain what the job guarantee is and and how that would influence the uh the the size of the government yeah well as we were um talking about before uh if there are unemployed resources then you can essentially
costlessly put those to work uh in the private interest and in the public interest it's an economic waste to leave them unemployed and by far the biggest economic waste around the world in every country I've ever visited was unemployed labor it's a hug huge economic waste and it actually um creates tremendous costs so it's not just that you lost the output and so on that you could have had it creates uh private cost to the unemployed and their families and tremendous social costs in the form of um social unrest and crime and so on so this is a big waste um and uh so we
argued that you can put this to work to in the public and private interest a sovereign government cannot run out of its own money so it's not a question of affordability it's always affordable the um uh potential problems would include inflation but if you're hiring people who are unemployed for whom the private sector's demand is not sufficient or otherwise they would Bey already then you're not competing with the private sector so you can employ those workers without causing inflation
uh I also said that the government has to be very careful in its spending I talked about the the race to Mars or something like that um this is a form of targeted spending where you're spending exactly on the uh resources that are unemployed and you can put the them into sectors where there's sufficient slack so what you're going to do is Target your spending where there is already slack that way you're not going to compete with the private sector so this is why you can have an increase of government spending without sparking inflation before you get to Full
Employment so you can uh bring up the employment level and start a approaching full employment without causing the inflation that uh military keynesianism or NASA exploration of Mars might do long before jobs ever trickle down to the unemployed right RAR the unemployed directly right and would this be a policy that can uh be used in every country uh simultaneously and also for a longer period of time of time or would you then perhaps get into um a mode where we by by Innovation and and um increase of production uh start to consume more and
more and then let's say given Jeff's Paradox at some point just run out of the natural resources would that not not be like an end point that you reach then well so what you want to do is um put people to work and environmental sustainable occupations which um I think is relatively easy to do if um you are creating jobs with the purpose that you're going to uh first provide employment second on the job training um and skills development and and third do things that are in the community's
interest to serve the public purpose um rather than simply pursuing a profit motive it's much harder to uh ensure that jobs created pursuing The Profit incentives um are going to be environmentally sustainable these jobs can be environmentally sustainable and in fact can be uh targeted to improve the environment to restore the environment so that's the sort of thing that um we're advocating uh you would like the um jobs to be green jobs you also would like to improve the training and
education of workers so that they become more employable in the private sector so that they can be recruited out of there into private sector jobs um the the idea that robots are going to displace all the workers uh is a a huge topic and really a different topic I'm ex extremely skeptical of this humans are just so phenomenally imaginative when I fly on airplanes and find out what the person next to me does for a living I'm always surprised it's a job I never heard of and never would have imagined we need uh I think that we can come up with plenty of things to
keep bu keep people busy of course reducing the work week is something that we should be doing in the United States we got our 8 hour day we over a hundred years ago and there's been no reduction in fact an increase in the work week since then for those lucky enough to be employed um so I'm all for reducing the work week but I'm not at all worried that robots are going to displace human labor okay so so you would say a job guarantee program so everyone can who wants to work can actually work provided by the government and then also over time gradually reducing uh the hours in the work week perhaps even to the 15 hour work week that G's predicted
yeah one one thing I I want to clarify though um when we talk about a job guarantee these are not necessarily uh government jobs the the national government needs to provide the funding for the jobs because only the national government can do that national government can't run out of money so they can afford uh to um pay the wages of the people in the program but uh each Nation might choose a different path to achieving full employment this way could you give us a few examples maybe well uh they okay so a generic example um they might decide that it makes much more
sense to have um not for-profit NOS um do the job creation and manage the projects that are uh go through some kind of an approval process and then the government pays the wage so for example it could be local community organizations that first know who the unemployed are because they're dealing with them uh through their Outreach programs and also know what the communities need so we have a happy coincidence here double coincidence where they know who's unemployed and they know what the community needs why not match those two together and have
the national government pay the wages to get it done so I think that this can be highly decentralized as decentralized as you want which makes sense in a country like the United States where we have community service organizations everywhere in the United States in every city and their major problem is they can't afford to hire people to do what they know needs to be done in other countries it may make more much more sense for the central government to uh plan the pro projects and actually employ the workers so what I'm saying is you can you know let a flow a thousand flowers bloom you can do it a variety of ways the only I'd say there are two important things one is the national
government pays the wage and second the wage is uniform and you hope it's going to be at a living wage throughout the country so all the jobs will pay the same wage this is important in um and they also said the minimum wage in the country right exactly it sets a minimum wage that actually is an effective minimum wage H Minsky used to always ask students in class you say what's the minimum wage in the United States well at the time let's say it's $325 cents an hour so some bright student will raise their hand and say that say no it's zero he says because if you can't get a job your wage is zero he said you need the job
guarantee to make it an effective minimum wage it does no good to tell people that the legal minimum wage is 775 an hour if you can't get a job yeah so it's about effective minimum wage yes right um I think this all makes sense I mean in the sense that it is very clear uh what your views are um those however are uh examples for uh countries where the government is the currency issuer The Sovereign government um in the Netherlands but also in the other Eurozone countries uh we have the the the uh the monetary Union so that makes a big difference doesn't it in the sense
that that the government can actually run out of would you say currency or money yeah yeah sort of they can sort of run out of it so uh even before the um the Euro was um put into place uh we predicted there would be problems um and I know that there were some other people too it wasn't just uh modern money Theory uh people who predicted the exactly the problems that resulted um and uh in a way uh it hasn't been quite as bad as I thought because the target 2 allows
quite a bit of slop and so it's true that you know ultimately the ECB is the issuer of the currency of the EUR just for our viewers Target to you mean the payment systems yes the money flows from one country to another yeah that that added some slot so technically the ECB is the issue issuer of the Euro but every member Central Bank within the their own um country also can issue Euro in their country uh now there there were supposed to be tight prohibitions on the central banks from financing treasuries um but the uh the ECB I sorry
the central banks can sort of do an end run around this if private Banks buy them first and then the central banks buy bonds from the private Banks which is exactly what the FED does to then you're sort of indirectly providing Finance the the problem for the member nations is that you have to clear with the other members and your Central Bank cannot create the Euros you need to clear with the other central banks so if you could actually close your economy the uh member nations could be more or less okay uh they're stuck with a fixed exchange rate against all the other members which is a bit of a
problem but they're sort of okay the problem is that the Euros leave and then you've got to make payments to the other central banks and you can only make those with ECB Euros not your own Euros so Target 2 was created to provide a bit of a leeway or slop in the system and so you have um the uh Mediterranean countries who have to borrow tremendous amounts of Euro to clear accounts mostly with the center especially with Germany and the ECB has allowed that to go on but this is at the whim of the ECB um and they sort of give signals that they might not allow it to continue
to occur and there's a a real danger that they will stop the lending and then all bets are off could you say that that that that uh X anti the the problems that we see now with with countries like for instance Greece or Italy have been predicted and modeled because if you have a country in a monetary Union that is a net importer permanently at some point runs out of money well that's right so if you compare the Emu area with the United States both of these have currency unions we have the dollar Union they
have the Euro Union right in the United States we have many states I don't know how many that are cry importers from the other states okay um and we have our own version of Target 2 it runs through the FED in the US we have um essentially 12 central banks spread around the country and um the clearing goes through these things our advantage is you don't have States associated with their own central banks it's regions not States stes so we don't even keep track of who are the net
importers and who are the net exporters some states subsidize the other states basically yeah in a sense they do but then Uncle Sam also distributes his spending around the country in a way to offset that so we have chronic net importing States and they are really not subsidized by the other states they're subsidized by Uncle Sam so Uncle Sam will put a lot of his projects in those States so there's a flow of dollars into the states to match the flow that is out and of course what you have in the Emu is that the total budget for the European Parliament is
less than 1% of GDP and so you have some redistribution this way but it's far too small to offset the net import over a country like Greece and would you say the way to go about it is is to actually go a step further and create a fiscal Union or would you actually um try to detach the the currencies again and and go back to the old regime with every country being the The Sovereign issuer of of the money which way would you go if if you were the president of of Europe you have to do one or the other right system you have absolutely will not work it cannot work from the the
design itself was flawed which is exactly what we said the design is flawed it cannot work it will lead to crisis you are now in a crisis you will not get out of Europe will not get out of this crisis no matter how much they might hope that it some miracle is going to happen it is not going to happen they will not get out of it so you have to do one or the other you know if I were a European would be rooting for the fiscal Union that makes the most sense um if you really believe in European unity and a lot of Europeans that I know do then you must go for the fiscal union now if you just want to Europeans then the on you know they must be Southern Europeans
the ones you know then a lot of them are southern Europeans that's true I lived in Italy and many of my friends are there now many of them uh were supporters of the euro in the beginning and now oppose the Euro they still like the idea of European Unity but they understand the euro is the problem so if it's impossible to do the fiscal Union then they must leave yeah the sooner the better because all they're doing now is prolonging the pain uh and eventually they're going to have to leave so they might as well go now yeah so you mean kind of the the like the the Brits basically have the status now of being
in the EU but not being in the Emu that that would be the way to go about it then well if they're allowed to be in the EU once they leave yeah yeah that's I I don't expect it to be but um are there any say lwh hanging fruits for uh for example Dutch politicians now because they are faced with the fact that they are in this emu and not within a fiscal Union so they need to somehow manage a budget um with a surplus or a deficit uh they have to deal with the economic crisis uh but they have all this limitations because they they have the limit of how much budget deficit you can have what would you advise uh be to um touch policy makers in this current
situation well you the the members of the Emu are in a beggar Thy Neighbor situation uh so if you pursue your own individual self-interest then you do what Germany does you you want to out compete everybody so that you can be an exporter that is the only way you can succeed in in the way that it is set up now it's it's fundamentally antisocial yeah and will lead to disillusion and maybe War yeah that's try to export as much as you can that's basically your advice that's the only thing you right okay okay um we have 10 more minutes I uh
would like to talk a little bit about the banking system uh we touched upon it a little bit when we talked about the positive money proposals uh which is is not only about issuing the money but also about the role of the banks in the uh in the monetary system um what do you think of of fractional Reserve banking in general is that one of the problems that we uh have in the system right now or would it be something that can still exist in a world where MNT is is being used as the dominant uh Theory yeah so that's sort of the the other half of the uh the critics of the monetary system so they
they want to go back to green backs government just issuing currency when it spends and and supposedly debt pre money and the other thing is to put very tight constraints on banks if you let them survive at all you might uh want to make them what's called 100% Reserve or narrow banking yeah so that they have to hold nothing but government bonds they can't uh make loans they hold the bonds against uh deposits and they also run into this this idea of not having Reserves at all but having like real money uh that can be lent onwards to others right okay that's Islamic banking would be a
another possibility where uh really you're just a shareholder um you buy shares in a bank and then the bank uh will lend those out and you know that you're taking a risk because you're a shareholder not a depositor yeah um so anyway I I think that uh first everyone is almost everyone except the people who happen to be in the top one tenth of 1% and living on Wall Street everyone else is mad at the Banks so am I completely understand that the banks are completely out of control that's absolutely true we need to restrain that so the question is uh what kinds of constraints make sense I think
that we need to get um our chartered Banks back into the Commercial Banking business what commercial banks used to do is they make short-term loans largely to businesses but they might also make some loans to Consumers and they issue the deposits that are the basis of the payment system that's that system works perfectly fine the banks do underwriting they which means they do credit assessment so that they make loans that have very high probability of repayment and then they issue the demand deposits that we all use and connecting those two things together is traditional
banking it worked very well the the problem is that we freed the chartered Banks to get into all sorts of other stuff um which uh was vastly more risky but more important than that much easier to engage in massive fraud which is the has become the business model of the biggest banks they they just engage in fraud um so 100% money or getting rid of banks alog together is returning to the system that that worked very well that um
uh has a logic to it in that the money in form of deposits is being created as part of the production process so that money is linked to production by commercial firms um that helps to make sure that we sort of have the right amount of money in the economy uh because it's being created to finance the loans that are necessary in order to get production underway uh that money is then used to buy the output of the firms and at that point in a sense we say the money is destroyed because the bank loans are repaid so this sort of a lot logic
that's made famous by the Franco Italian circuit approach to money um uh is appealing yeah and sort of accurate uh to a description of the way the Commercial Banking worked our big problem is outside of this it is all of the speculation the derivatives the uh making bets uh against people's homes and against their lives with credit default swaps all that stuff that accounts for 99% of the financial system now that's where the problems are that's
what attacking get rid of the big Banks because basically what they do is fraudulent their business model uh separate the payment system from from The Lending no no I would not separate the payment system from The Lending but I would separate it from the big big Banks and all of those kinds of activities okay and I think I also read somewhere that that you were in favor of having the government um taking back the the the payment system and perhaps also the the the commercial and and andme lending uh within the economy as well rather than take it back I would have the government compete with that okay so
uh I see nothing wrong with uh having uh Reviving our postal savings system which we had in the United States Italy had a postal savings system Japan still has a postal savings system so that you can use that uh for your payments you can uh have your wages paid into your postal savings account and you can make payments uh utility companies and taxes and so on through that a very efficient way to do it that the reason why I would like the government to do this is to compete with the private Banks right so that they can't get away with discriminating against uh depositors who are low income so that they can't get
away with charging outrageous fees if you happen to bounce a check occasionally you have the postal savings system as a an alternative to keep the other Banks honest to compete with them and can it also be a cryptocurrency for instance that that system would that be no they bit Bitcoins will never become uh a significant part of the payment system uh this is for speculators and drug dealers strictly that's that's what it's all about the the fair value of a Bitcoin is zero right nobody promises you anything these
are debt-free money I mean if this is really what the debt free money people want is Bitcoins and cryptocurrencies um this is never going to be significant because the value is not guaranteed there's nothing driving the currency other than speculation and the need for drug dealers to be hidden from law enforcement right and that's where it deres the current dollar value from yeah and I mean I know that some people are just fascinated by the technology the mining technology and all that and and no doubt some others are going to rise up and then also collapse but the problem is the fair value is zero the fair value of a $1 us bill is
$1 you know that it's going to be accepted at a nominal value of the dollar now some people say I don't know what the real value is because you can get inflation okay sure fine the only promis is in nominal terms with a Bitcoin there is no promise whatsoever no one has issued this a liability no one has to take it back in payment its fair value is zero so according to your definitions also it's it's not money in a sense not right okay um well we're almost at the end of the interview I have a few more questions if if that's okay with you from sure our viewers um one is about the basic income uh we talked about the job guarantee but uh perhaps uh could you explain why you
are in favor of the job guarantee and um I don't know may maybe also for the basic income or or how what's your take on that yeah well I I think if someone is ready and willing to work the right thing to do is to offer them a job why would you refuse to give them a job and say no here we'll just give you some cash go away and leave us alone no they deserve to work it is a basic human right it's recognized by the United Nations as a basic human right for everyone who wants to work to have a job the United States and all other uh developed capitalist countries are
violating this basic human right we need to provide them a job we need to provide them a living wage a job gives you more than money money alone does not give you access to the economy and to social networks in the same way that a job does it doesn't give you the kind of respect that a job gives you and so we need to provide the jobs first to anyone who's ready and willing to work now that will still leave a small part of the population that is uh not ready and willing to work um note I don't include uh people living with um disabilities in
that group because the survey show at least in the United States that 75% of people with disabilities want to work they want jobs they just can't get them so I include those as being ready and willing to work we should design jobs that they can perform so once we've given everyone who wants to work a a job we're going to be left with a residual that uh either can't work or doesn't want to work or shouldn't work shouldn't be with and in that case of course we have to provide them with an newcome okay so I'm not opposed to that at all I I think that the the Arguments for giving
everybody enough income so that nobody has to work where they actually have a choice uh that they can reasonably make to either work or stay home at a pay that is sufficient to give them you know the normal standard of living that other people in society would want um you're you're talking about uh incomes of $50,000 a year in the United States this is not feasible without causing a lot of inflation right if
everyone's going to get this whether they work or not then effectively now my starting uh uh income before I work is $50,000 it makes no sense to me to argue that this is not going to cause prices and wages to go up yeah so I think that this uh you'll be chasing this goal because the 50,000 won't be nearly enough yeah once the prices and wages start to rise so it's going to have to be 60,000 then 70 then 80 and so on it's just going to chase the prices up yeah if you then say but
we're not going to give it to everyone we're only going to give it to the people who don't want to work okay then you're stigmatizing it and you're not achieving what you claim to be achieving which is to free everyone from the need to work right if you want to Target it only to those who don't work yeah you say it's it's a human right at least to have the the option to work if if you want to that that's one of the main uh differences with with the basic income where you don't offer people um the opportunity also to to uh to gain the social value from work but only give them the purchasing power that will only be sufficient for a period of time after which you need to increase the amount of
of income that you generate or provide right right all right um another question is about the trade deficit between the US and Japan and the dollar reserve of Japan is holding um is that also in the end bad then doesn't say if it's bad for the US or Japan but I guess for for the US is there a problem if if foreign Curr countries have your currency have large Holdings um is it can that be problematic for the issuer well I most people are are worried about sort of the financial aspects the money aspects of
this um but let's just first quickly look at the real aspect so the real aspect is that the Americans are consuming a lot of products made by Japanese and now Chinese workers so the Chinese workers are working very hard to produce stuff that they don't get to consume that is sent to America so that Americans can consume it so who's being hurt China and Japan because their workers are working hard to produce stuff they don't get to consume who's benefiting America so in in real terms uh trade deficits are good things you get to consume everything that you produce plus a portion of what the
Chinese and Japanese produce that's a good thing so that is an advantage um but what people are worried about is and I think you know this isn't uh controversial among economists as long as we're sticking to the real terms deficit are a good thing uh but they start to fear that well the Japanese might stop lending dollars to US to finance our trade deficits now that has got it exactly backwards it is the US trade deficit that finances the Japanese accumulation of dollar wealth if we didn't uh import from Japan the Japanese wouldn't have the dollars so all the dollars they got exist mostly in
the Bank of Japan uh or the bank of China because we bought their output so all those dollars came from us it's not a matter of them lending to US dollars so that we can do this we provided the dollars for them uh does that burden the United States well most of the dollars that are being accumulated are in the form of either reserves held at the fed or the majority are treasuries issued by the United States government so again people will say oh no Uncle Sam has to borrow dollars from China to pay for its budget deficits but again this is got it exactly turned on its head the dollars
they got came from uh Americans purchasing their output that leads to an increase of Bank Reserves held by the Bank of China at the fed the reserves earn zero interest so the Bank of China says Hey we'd like to earn some interest on that so the uh fed debits their Bank Reserves and credits their account that is treasuries it's like moving money from a checking account to a savings account at the FED right so that the Chinese can earn some interest what is the burden of that the US uh treasury credits their uh treasury account with interest okay two three 4%
interest rate is credited to the Chinese there's no burden of this no only problem is the government debt the amount is rising but it's only a burden if you pay attention to that or think it's important right or if at some point in the future some future American generation decided to pay off all the debt by taxing itself more okay now fortunately Americans are not that dumb so they have this great fear of debt but they don't impose taxes to retire it we only did once 1837 President Andrew Jackson actually paid off all the government debt every generation since then has been sensible enough to never pay off the debt right
so I think the probability that that will happen is very small but there's one other possible burden what if the Chinese decide to use all of their uh dollar accumulations to buy US exports well then Americans will have to do the hard work to produce the output that the Chinese are going to consume which is exactly what most American politicians want they want us to run a trade surplus and so they're really mad that we run trade deficits and they say we need to turn things around so we run trade surpluses well if we ever get what they claim they want that will be a burden on this right but it it's not going to happen in the near future okay uh eventually China probably will start to
run a trade deficit not just against the United States I think against the world as it becomes a wealthier uh economy with high wages um it will probably start to run trade deficits so that would turn around so for the US it would be good to remain a net uh importer and let the Chinese and the uh the other Asian countries be uh the workers where they actually consume as long as they want to do that yeah now finally of course people will then say but hold a second we're losing jobs to the Chinese um and I or what if it changes that that that they actually want to
spend like where what you were talking about well then we would get the jobs back but I mean in the short run uh our trade deficit are said to lose to job losses in the United States um well the answer of course is we have to create jobs in America and that is why we need the job guarantee with a living wage right away to replace the jobs that are lost to Imports and also the Lo the jobs that are lost to the robots um so we need to to quickly put people to work that's the right way to deal with the trade deficit the wrong way would be to um try to slow your economy down and use
austerity to reduce Imports which is what most Nations do when they're trying to reduce their trade deficits they think that the answer is austerity which of course just creates more unemployment at home right all right Dr Ray thank you very much for being with us tonight um I believe everything that we talked about is also described in your book modern money Theory uh am I right uh probably pretty close to it yeah yeah and I believe this is the second edition can you perhaps briefly explain what the difference is between the first and the the second edition the uh well the big addition is a new chapter on the purpose of
taxes so uh modern money Theory says that taxes Drive the currency and that uh governments don't actually spend tax revenue so they don't really need the taxes for Revenue purposes um but there are other uh so I explain all of this in much more detail there also are other purposes of taxes okay we want to change people's behavior avior so we tax Sin Sin taxes um and I we may want to reduce the income at the top so you have Progressive taxes High tax rates on the rich so they won't be so rich um and then finally a
discussion of um what kinds of taxes make sense what are good taxes what are bad taxes so there's that there is more discussion of inflation hyperinflation and I separated it out from the discussion of the job guarantee and unemployment so there's a now a separate discussion because many people worried about inflation of course and hyperinflation and I go through some of the experiences with Hyper inflation and show that they were not caused by budget deficits which a lot of people believe government just printing money causing the hyperinflation um uh there's something else that I slipping my mind right now there
there's one indexation is one of the big additions to to the new uh edition of your book yeah right okay well it seems like a also a good read for those who are uh uh uh exposed to to bitcoin and investing in in cryptocurrencies to see what actually drives money and and gives money value am I right yes all right well it has been a pleasure thank you very much and um well hopefully we can uh uh speak again in the future okay thanks okay thank you byebye bye
