MobyMask introduced, Aave live on Aztec and more - The Daily Gwei Refuel #488 - Ethereum Updates

Transcript

hello everyone and welcome to another episode of The Daily gray review where he kept the latest news in ethereum ecosystem I'm your host Dan this is the 16th of November 2022. all right everyone let's get into it so an update here from the relay or dot WTF team which is uh Builder 0x69.eath now this is a blog post you can go check out for yourself but the tldr is that going forward you can send bundles to build a 0x69.io even when they don't have sufficient balance to cover gas fees our Builder will cover all necessary gas fees for transactions as long as these fees are returned at the end of the bundle so if you have been using the relayer a relay or WTF service CR while this is relevant to you now well I haven't checked uh the

website in a little while on the refill to show you the growth that's been happening with this relayer they got up to 10 000 validators registered on their relayer with 8237 active at time of recording now the difference here is that you can register with this relayer uh at once and then uh use it and then move off of it and use another relayer and come back typically what you'll see with uh with validators is that they won't just stick to one relayer if one is you know consistently more profitable than the one they're on the people may change and it's not just profitability that they change for there's various other reasons why they would but that's the difference between registered and active so it seems about 1800 uh validators that have registered are not

currently active on relayer relay or dot WTF but still cool to see that 10 000 have been registered with them and speaking of relayers uh it's about time for us to have another look at the Mev watch website I like checking in on this every now and again now I did mention that it seemed like it was coming down into the post-emerge ofac compliant blocks uh it seems to have I guess like stalled at around 70 75 percent I I should say uh and it seems to have plateaued there it doesn't seem to be growing much more anymore doesn't mean it can't grow into the future but it seems to have plateaued around there and you can see here if we include all blocks um it's 84 uh and it was at like 97 I think just the few weeks ago so at 73 percent uh currently of um of Mev boost

blocks are enforcing that ofak compliance obviously still really bad still something we need to fix but uh it's good that it's not growing right it's good that it's plateaued there which I like seeing and then you can see in these charts uh underneath the main chart you're basically showing that the graph of how this looks so this is not including all blocks this is just Mev boost blocks you can see this is plateaued as well here but we'll see how things go uh if I go to the Mev boosted blocks you know blocks route Max profit is still second here that's a non-censoring relay flashbot is still first with you know 77 of the market share nothing really to to report on there but uh but yeah that's the current landscape of things I mean uh yeah if you look at this chart you can as I said

like 97 we're at night we were at 97 of all Mev boosted blocks being offat compliant on October 27th which wasn't that long ago now we're down to uh uh 82 percent uh and we you kind of like went down to 77 came back up a little bit that's probably due to profitability of different relays uh you know obviously as the market heated up because of the FTX collapse uh there was a lot of uh activity on chain a lot of gas fees a lot of mbb Mev opportunities and different relayers uh have different ways of capturing that uh there so just just checking in on that uh and related to Mev is staking and I just wanted to give a quick update on staking well it seems that we're almost at 15 million each Stakes we're at 14 million 988 095

each um with 468 382 active validators this is another big milestone for the ethereum network absolutely awesome to see to see people still staking their even validators still coming online even though withdrawals haven't been enabled yet obviously and that's another thing that I want to wanted to talk about as well there's been some fun going around over the last few days that withdrawals have been taken off the roadmap or have been delayed indefinitely Or won't be here till 2024 or something like that uh and it seems like it was all stem coming from a website that posted an article saying this because apparently the ethereum.org website took away the estimated date of withdrawals coming uh to to uh the ethereum mainnet now from

what I can tell from the core Dev scores there has been no change in uh the uh the fact of uh getting withdrawals into the Shanghai update which is still due for q1 or Q2 next year so don't I guess listen to these fudsters online I don't even know why they're doing this honestly there's a lot of Bitcoin maximalists I mean I know why they're doing it because they're coping over the fact that they said the merge would never happen and the merge happened they have to shift the goal post and I just wonder like when withdrawals are enabled what are they going to start saying you know what they're going to start saying I already know what they're going to start saying they're going to be like oh look at all the eat that's about to be unlocked to be dumped on everyone right

there's always a shift in goal post and as I've said before on the refill if a group of people or if someone keeps Shifting the goal post every time one of their arguments is proven to be wrong they're not someone worth listening to in in my opinion but yeah just felt like that was necessary to bring out but nothing has changed from what I can tell on the withdrawals front every core developer or at least most of them really want withdrawals in Shanghai and as I said it is not as complex as something like erp4844 so there's no kind of a 50 50 chance or anything I as I've said I think 99 chance it goes in obviously always leaving that one percent chance open just in case anything uh goes wrong and I'm not expecting anything to go wrong there so cool to see uh you know cool to see that

uh that the validators are still coming online and that more it is being staked even though as I said we don't know withdrawals yet uh and I don't know I haven't had a look at who they're going with maybe I should have kind of checked that before I got on the the refill here seems that there are a bunch going into Lido but other uh services are still getting uh traction as well if I go to raider.network actually I can bring up this website one of my favorites to to kind of monitor this stuff you can see Lido has gone back above 30 it's up 30.44 so it has moved a little bit there um uh rocker pull went down a little bit unfortunately due to other I guess like entities going up but it's still around the two percent Mark uh I wonder if

there's a history here of network penetration I think there might be or maybe they uh they're they're planning to do it uh I actually don't I actually don't know I haven't haven't seen a history here but still regardless uh eight more if he's being staked uh it's being staked with various entities still obviously can't uh you know Network penetration for a lot of these things can't really go down because withdrawals aren't enabled man I mean I can't wait for the draws to be enabled from you know so many different reasons but I think this is obviously a major one but still as I said cool to see more validators coming online and uh looking forward to hitting that 15 million each Stakes Mark any day now all right so metamask announced today that they have introduced something called mobymask which is a new

initiative from uh one of their one of menomas co-founders Dan Finlay to help proactively protect users from phishing by using a dynamic web of trust for sourcing phishing reporters so in partnership with uh this uh leonic uh like leonic laconic Network we are launching a special movie Mask caching ethereum like client which greatly reduces the cost for an individual organization to host a trustworthy copy of the mobymask anti-fishing registry so that's cool they're actually releasing a light client for this and the goal is simple to eliminate fishes forever the current version of baby mask focuses on Twitter fishing but eventually will expand to any kind of phishing like websites smart contracts and new social media platforms people running the mobymask Watcher client will contribute

to a more fisher-resistant web and gain access to a private API for looking up phishing reports which they can then share as they like either at no cost or for a fee Try It Out by heading to mobimaster.com which of course you can do now this is cool because I've gone over a similar oh I guess like Solutions in the same same vein before like fire where basically it'll tell you what you're interacting with so that it can kind of protect you from uh from getting fished potentially or particularly from interacting with things that you shouldn't be and I've also talked about daylight before which they've got an update as well which I'll cover which is basically a firewall for your addresses but uh maybe mask is another is another solution here where it's basically trying to create a web of trust around

various things that you can interact with using your your wallet on uh through metamaskia and it's using a light client as well to make sure that they can be verified locally without having obviously to run a full node to verify that so that that's just awesome I love that I love this initiative from metamasking it certainly feels like with the push to get people to do more self-custody to do more things on chain we definitely need to build more of these protections and put more of these Protections in place because I think the worst thing that can happen is that we get people coming on chain they self-cast City their assets and then they don't actually understand that on chain isn't you know completely safe there are ways to lose your funds there are ways to get phished and they end up getting fished and then they get burnt

from doing stuff on chain forever that's the worst thing that can happen obviously because once you send your funds somewhere once you get your funds drained from your wallet there's no way of getting them back I mean the same would be true for a centralized exchange for example if for some reason someone was able to withdraw funds from a centralized exchange from your account and withdraw them to their own address there's pretty much no way you could call that back but a centralized exchange has a bunch of Protections in place it has like two-factor authentication email verification trusted address lists and all that sorts of all those sorts of things right so if we can bring all of that to metamask to other Wallets on chain uh which is something like arjun's been trying to do with smart contract wallets if we can do all that we can make the on-chain

ecosystem a much safer place for people and have people more you know encourage people to to use on-chain stuff and then not have them get wrecked so to speak right and I think one of the biggest ways people get wrecked is that they visit one of these fishing sites which purport to be or pretend to be or you know basically a clone of something like uni swap the interface all looks very similar everything looks like it should and then you approve something on on a contract that basically gives the uh the person that set up that fishing website full uh permission to draw to drain your funds uh that's happened a lot of times before and it's going to keep happening into the future so if we can build something directly into the popular wallets that basically say to people hey this is not the real you know unisop

website that you're interacting with uh uh you know please don't uh interact with this one please report uh it's been reported as fishing then we can protect people from getting duped here which I think is really really important right um so yeah we're gonna leave that one at that uh I did mention before that uh I was going to talk about daylight in the context of security but I think I got myself mixed up there it wasn't daylight that was the uh firewall that I spoke about a few weeks ago that that kind of thing it was different to fire uh but it basically allowed you to have a firewall to a whitelist uh things that you interact with it's not called daylight I can't remember the name right now daylight was another thing that I spoke about but it's different this is basically a way to discover different uh

things that your wallet can do different abilities that your wallet can do such as claiming airdrops uh claiming pull-ups renewing ens unlocking events and all that good stuff there uh their announcement today is that they're out of closed beta so you no longer need to get any special invites or nfts or anything like that you can go uh check out their web app connect your your wallet to it it's all free it's uh it's it's it's open to everyone so so yeah but yeah apologies I mixed up my words before when when talking about this uh there's there's too many projects now too many protocols now I get mixed up uh sometimes here but yeah you can go check out uh daylight now if you haven't uh yet as I said it's out of closed beta uh go give it uh a try I'll link it in the

YouTube description below all right so speaking of too many protocols these days uh there's been a couple that got announced today so one of them is called price protocol which is a permission list and a permissionless and reliable solution that leverages uni V3 and keeper automation to provide safe price quotes on any existing token token and this has been created by the team at Wonderland so you can learn why price uh has the potential to take D5 to the next level in this thread here but it's cool to see that we've still got these protocols coming out even though I guess like it's a bear market and we had the FTX collapse and there's so much I guess a noise out there but defy keeps shipping right and price protocol is as they

describe it here the ultimate Oracle solution to provide price quotes on any token in a safe reliable and permissionless way so basically it's a competitive I guess like competitor or maybe complimentary to something like chain link and empiric network some other Oracle projects out there uh but as I said like price is built on top of unisop V3 thus inheriting all its decentralized and sustainable features in addition it solves the following three issues trust issues price makes liquidity trustworthy and predictable for the oracle's users complexity everything is managed by smart contracts we created a hassle-free experience for our users and multi-block attacks price uses automation to detect and correct price manipulations including multi-block attacks now I don't know how

much I trust something like this off the bat because oracles have notoriously been quite hard to get Riot and quite prone to manipulation because if you can successfully manipulate a price of an Oracle and that can feed into something like a lending app for example you can stand to make a lot of money taking the taking the other side of that trade there has been other attempts at this using uni swap for uh as as a price Oracle for I guess long tail assets with Euler but I don't know if they've re-enabled it but they did disable it because of the risk of multi-block kind of attacks and multi-block Mev attacks which I've talked about before about how if you knew that you were going to be the proposer for you know a few blocks in a row you could potentially manipulate the uh the the Oracle price

of something on uni Swap and then potentially manipulate it on the money market and then profit from that as I just explained so I'm cautiously optimistic about something like this I obviously wouldn't be uh trusting it just yet I wanted to see it play out in the wild I want to see how it all goes but the Wonderland team is definitely not new they've been around for quite a while now and I think they definitely seem to know what they're doing but at the end of the day uh uh there's definitely a lot of questions here a lot of um a lot of things to still scrutinize and of course uh chain link guide here who obviously has his name implies he's a big fan of chain link uh was putting the pressure on a really already asking you know surely you wouldn't leave out the trust assumptions

and trade-offs of tup oracles so T WAP is time weighted average price oracles and this is I spoken out before how people are using uni swap uh as as a t-wop Oracle and how There's issues with that not just with multi-block Mev but just generally it's prone to price manipulation depending on the liquidity of the uh the pair care of the of the asset pair right so there are issues here but I think this shouldn't prevent people from creating um you know new oracles new protocols that take advantage of this but there are things to iron out so I'm going to keep an eye on price uh protocol myself but very very cool to see this uh announced today all right another protocol that got announced today was or I guess like a project that got announced today is something called a superform which is a

universal yield Marketplace so uh basically they've got a blog post here uh describing what they are uh they've got uh you know a bunch of different Graphics here as well that you can go check out but the Twitter thread don't give us gives us the tldr so basically super form starts this thread off by saying it's time for Access and distribution of yield to evolve finding accessing and managing yield is clunky and fragmented Distributing yield is time and resource intensive incentives superform combines these experiences into a single seamless non-custodial interface you can browse yield opportunities and make single transaction deposits using any asset into a any ERC 4626 volt which I've spoken about before on the refuel and on any chain uh they uh the super form uses sockets to combine Bridges swaps and

deposits into a single action so you can permission only list any of these vaults for instant omnichann distribution protocols like M state Maple and some Finance are already building their vaults using the 4626 and many more are following so this is basically an evolution of that 4626 yield stand that I've been talking about and basically making it really easy for people to get access to yield but not have to go through all the and I have to jump through all the Hoops to do that because as more protocols come online as more yield opportunities come online it does blow it out and it kind of becomes a thing of well you need a third-party tool to just go and comb through things in order to find the best yield but what if you had a third party tool that

didn't just show you all the best yields but it actually brought them all together and just told you what it was right and across any chain whether it be ethereum mainnet or layer twos or other layer ones and basically automates that entire process I think that is the future of of yield but it will also what it will also do uh fortunately or unfortunately is that it will collapse yields eventually too because the thing is is that a lot of the time when when you're saying being a relatively high yield it's usually due to information asymmetry it's due to not enough people knowing about this yield uh and and then you know not enough people plowing into it to bring the yield down or not knowing about this yield opportunity I should say and not enough people plowing into it to bring the yield down which

they naturally do over time once that information asymmetry collapses there's also things like risk involved too like don't get me wrong there are risk premiums to things but on on net if everyone knows about the the yield opportunity and they plow their money into it the yield will obviously come down now it depends where the yield is coming from as well because there is a natural yield that you can get or a real yield as it's called and there is a kind of I guess like an inflated or an artificial yield an example of an artificial yield or something that is not a real yield would be token incentives where you're providing liquidity to something and you're getting a token incentive and that is included in the yield calculation that is not a real yield right but an example of a real yield is something that is

being paid by users so for example uh there is debates about this but in ethereum staking the block rewards that you get for testing the blocks of proposing blocks and for uh being part of a subcommittee are not considered the real yield the real yield is considered uh to be the yield coming from the execution layer so from phase and Mev but then there are debates around uh around the fact of the matter is that you could say that the the real I mean the terminology gets confusing because people use it interchangeably but you could say that okay well here's the network issuance of ethereum right uh not including the burn just here's the network issuance but then take away that from the yield that validators are

getting without just the consensus layer yield so just the block rewards um attestations and subcommunity uh yield and that becomes like part of the real yield I actually think that's fine to do it that way but the yield that part of the yield is being paid out by the protocol itself not being paid out by users uh through fees and Mev so uh but I guess for for sake of the argument and forsake of Simplicity it's my much easier just to split it out in terms of at least in crypto context in terms of things that users are paying directly for in terms like things like fees and Mev and things that are being paid out by the the protocol itself or or some other kind of like thing like token incentives for example right so definitely anything with token

incentives shouldn't be considered a real yield at all it shouldn't be considered a natural yield because the token incentives don't last forever and they are at the whim of what the token price does as well right and at the whim of like the amount of people that plow into things uh and distributing the yield across uh and things like that but I've gone on a bit of a tangent about yields there but really cool to see something like super form announce themselves today and and come out and basically say hey we're going to take advantage of the new 4626 standard and uh they're already I think they're already live taking advantage of this so maybe they're not live yet I actually didn't uh didn't check this area I only saw this just before uh let me have a look if they're if they're live right

now I don't know if they're live but uh I think you just check out the blog post no no okay here it is close beta launch so they're launching their closed beta on November 28th and we'll continue into the first quarter of next year as they complete audits of the contracts polish the platform and add even more functionality they're going to initially Grant access to Degen score Beacon nft holders and over time to users who sign up to the waitlist so if you're interested definitely go sign up to the wait list go sign up to the wait list I'll leave a link to it in the YouTube description below all right so Ave is now live on Aztec so the leading open source protocol for non-custodial liquidity markets now with full privacy and 12 times lower gas fees than layer 1. Ave is the biggest

liquidity protocol on ethereum with over 4 billion internal value locked and innovator and permissionless lending borrower Ava allows you to supply assets to earn yield without Financial intermediaries so Aztecs integration with Ave allows users to deposit funds using azteconnect as a proxy getting both cost savings and enhanced privacy so what users can do is that they can now deposit their shielded eat and die into are there and earn yield from a fully decentralized liquidity protocol and deposit with 12 times lower gas fees than layer 1 with D5 deposit batching split the fees with other users and save on gas while protecting your privacy this tweet here actually got my brain spinning just then it's funny that even though doing privacy stuff on layer 2 is more expensive than not doing it

privately on other layer twos right on such as optimism and arbitrim you're still better off using Aztec to do your transactions than ethereum mainnet because it's still 12th time in this example 12 times cheaper than ethereum mainnet so if you are an avid other user and you want to protect your privacy then even though as I said it's more expensive than interacting with are there on on optimism or arbitrim from what I've seen it's you're still better off because you get privacy with this which I think is really really cool so really awesome to see Ave live on here I mean uh Aztec seems to be uh I mean they're moving slow-ish right but they seem to be kicking goals with who they're on boarding they're on boarding all the star D5 protocols in order to give people that fully private

experience of using D5 and using Aztec connect to bridge with a liquidity from layer one to Layer Two because obviously that's very very important rather than trying to bootstrap the liquidity on layer 2 all together all together you're tapping into the existing layer one liquidity which is still very large as I said it's four billion dollars worth in other right now obviously that fluctuates depending on the price of various assets uh but yeah cool to see this from Aztec uh go check it out go use it if you're on Aztec all right so polygon announced something today uh Called Quest which is a play to earn gamification feature added to the polygon wallet Suite that rewards you for achieving certain goals if you are new to polygon then Quest is a great way

to start and you can learn more on the blog post here uh which I'm just loading up right now if it wants to load yeah here we go so this has been added to the polygon wallet Suite which if you are someone who uses that as you can see in the screenshots here you can take advantage of this so it's basically gamifying the experience of using uh the polygon POS chain Network ER which is something that we've seen I guess other protocols do obviously arbitrim did it with Odyssey uh and optimism is doing it with their own quests thing I think there's been other platforms out there that have similar initiatives but polygon has joined The Fray now so if you are of avid polygon POS chain user which I suspect a lot of you are this may be something that you're interested in and that you can go check out I'll

link this in the YouTube description for you to do so but I love seeing these gamification stuff coming come coming to crypto in general I think that really when you think about it liquidity mining was a gamification feature right and now we're just incorporating things like nfts into it but really when liquidity mining got popularized so to speak uh when compound did it in the startup defy summer of 2020 it was a super gamer fight thing I remember feeling like I was playing a video game while doing all of the stuff during D5 summer that I was doing and I wasn't the only one feeling like this like people were making memes about it all my friends were saying you know this feels like a a an MMO an Unchained MMO sort of sort of thing but obviously instead of game characters and

assets it was default protocols and then the nft Mania happened and that really started to feel like a video game and now people are incorporating those two things into gamification uh with nfts and then obviously we have crypto games and things like that as well so it really does feel like it's just evolved over time and I I don't think I've seen something that is able to incentivize people more than gamification I think that's very very important but at the same time there is kind of like a bad way to do it where it looks like a Ponzi right we've seen plenty of those things play out but then there is a good way to do it where you're incentivizing at users to do something but without making it look like a ponzier without making it really risky and without promising users all this kind of money for doing it and

that's doing it with nfts we basically say to people hey you could earn these nfts for doing these things uh and these nfts entitled you to certain benefits uh and then the users go and do it and it gets more activity on chain and they discover and by doing this stuff to get the nfts they discover different apps on on these different ecosystems and they discover different ways to interact with things which I think is very cool and very positive all right so Tycho has a new blog post out today called the type 1 ZK evm and there's a summary of the post in the future in the um Twitter thread here I should say but definitely recommend giving these blog posts a read because it goes through such questions of what is a type 1 ZK VM what does a type 2

plus C KVM change what are the impacts of these changes why does proof generation cost matter and why use a type 1 ZK evm so if you're interested in learning all about type 1 ZK VMS and why Taiko has decided to go down this path rather than the other type of types of ZK VMS and this blog post is for you I'll of course link it in the YouTube description below uh but great to see more of these educational posts coming out because obviously the ZK AVM space you know we started off as just as EK VM now we have different types of ZK VMS and then we have different ways to construct them and then we have different ways um that they're going to be deployed different cryptography that they're built on right all those sorts of things so you can go give this blog

post to read to learn more about how Taiko is approaching a type 1 ZK evm alright finally here I have a bit of commentary about a tweet from Brian Armstrong today where he said Twitter has broken just about every piece of this FTX story using blockchain analytics while the New York Times is writing puff pieces on a criminal feels like a turning point for citizen journalism and loss of trust in mainstream media so for those of you who missed this the New York Times put out a Fluff piece about SPF and FTX yesterday and I put out another one today and they haven't really done any deep investigative journalism on this and they haven't really called it for what it is like fraud and a scam and all that sorts of stuff but Brian's tweet got me thinking and the thing I want to focus

on here is this term citizen journalism now Citizen journalism in theory is really great it's basically this notion of people coming together and and doing investigative journalism and then collating all their resources and coming to a source of Truth so to speak right and and Shining a light on things as a collective but the dark side of that is that there's usually a lot of quote-unquote fake news or inaccurate information that tends to spread while the fact checking and while the information is being collated now we've seen the effects of that over the you know the past few years in serious things like elections right we've seen the effects in crypto how far just seems to spread really really fast as I said before there's this new photo of the

past few days about each withdrawals which just came out of nowhere which makes absolutely no sense but that that's the dangers of Citizen journalism now of course mainstream media uh and media just in general comes with the same dangers of putting out the wrong information putting out biased information uh misleading people but I I want to kind of uh I guess like warn people against just going all in on citizen journalism I think it's great but it has to be a measured approach I I figure that that if you see someone tweeting about something and they're not a journalist or anything like that they're just spreading some information definitely don't just take their word for it just like you wouldn't take one media Publications word for something you want to cross-reference that with different Publications you want to for more information to come out if there's

only one publication saying something and they're saying they have a source somewhere you want to just just wait you don't want to form an opinion you don't want to think that something's true until more information comes out so I think the same is true for citizen journalism uh just as it's true for normal journalism right and mainstream media and things like that um so with that out of the way I do want to say that it's been pretty cool to see Twitter becoming the the I guess like the the home base or home ground for breaking the FTX story and I think that it's it's a lot a lot of the reason is because crypto Twitter I mean crypto people live on Twitter generally right and a lot of the information gets put out on Twitter uh generally for anything else to do with crypto and obviously the

key players were tweeting about this Twitter's like the Town Square right where everything happens everyone's gossiping about things every you know people are screaming things out and people will hear them and follow them and they'll be notice boards where there's Public public information on there and public uh things on there and then people can reply to these notice boards and say this is correct not correct and people do all this colliding information as I mentioned which I think is pretty cool but as I said like it's best to just make sure that you're getting the right information and not take things at face value um I'm guilty of sometimes putting out the wrong information unknowingly because there's actually a difference between misinformation and disinformation misinformation is when you're putting something out there uh

you know uh either unknowingly or or knowingly oh I guess like mostly unknowingly uh because you haven't checked your sources you haven't verified the information and you're spreading this misinformation by doing that whereas this information is people knowingly spreading the wrong information like they literally know what they're saying is a Lie Is false is not accurate so there is a key difference there between those two and I think that this information thing obviously is happening a lot and at scale on on Twitter but the misinformation thing happens just as easily or even more so because of the retweet function for example right like if you read tweets and something without checking the source if it's coming from someone that you generally trust and you retweet it well that information tends

to spread very very quickly and the rebuttal now later if you if you want to correct it correct yourself or if someone lays a correction out there that tends to not be seen uh by nearly as many people as the original story got seen by or his original piece of information got seen by so just always worth keeping that stuff in mind uh but still cool to see that Twitter is playing such an absolutely massive part in uh stories like the FTX story I think it will continue to play that but do need to keep in mind that just because someone says something online doesn't make it true I mean people lie online all the time people lie in real life all the time it's best to get your information from multiple different sources make sure they all match up make sure that it's accurate and ideally you

want to get your information directly from the source and that's what what's very powerful about Twitter is that you can get your information directly from the source but also remember that that's that the direct source can lie just like we've seen over the collapses of this year um you know there were lies from the biggest players saying that they that everything was under control everything was fine and then it turns out everything wasn't so it's good to not take anyone's word at gospel collect your different sources together and make sure that the story lines up between all of them but I think on that note that's going to be it for today so thank you everyone for listening and watching be sure to subscribe to the channel if you haven't yet give it a thumbs up subscribe to the newsletter join the Discord Channel and I'll catch you all

tomorrow thanks everyone