How peer-to-peer technology can help end the nation state
De Week van Bitcoin · 7 May 2015 · 37:16
Jeffrey Tucker of Liberty.me and the Foundation for Economic Education joins a weekly Reinvent Money hangout on anarchism and peer-to-peer technology. Tucker argues that the nation state is an artificial historical construct that digital, borderless technology will make obsolete, pointing to services such as Airbnb and online marketplaces that outrun regulation, and to experiments like Liberland. They also discuss banks investing in Bitcoin and blockchain companies, and Tucker says he sees Bitcoin as a new safe haven if interest rates rise.
Speakers
Topics
From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.
Transcript
hi everybody welcome to our weekly hangouts about Bitcoin FinTech freedom and much more I'm your house Paul bad ink in my costa days learn to huy of Holland's most popular bit coincide bitcoin spot an l i'm honored to announce today's guest the average charming mr. jeffrey darker chief liberty officer of Liberty dubbed me and author of many books amongst them is latest bit by bit happy to be his freeing world's our viewers should can ask questions using QA to I Jeffrey a great everyone that's nice to be here thanks so much for inviting me I'm excited to be I'm speaking to from the offices of the foundation for economic education and Atlanta okay that's great Atlantis is quite quite a town it's Yuri bit going friendly I think there are 400 members of the Bitcoin meet up here in
town and many people i have a group i run on wednesday night so it meets every wednesday called anarchy and atlanta and a mini bitcoiners show up when we talk about about peer-to-peer technology and be kind of particular this is also the home of bitpay i don't know if you knew that but bitpay is here so lots of bitcoin startups them that's sort of thing that's interesting bit bay as of course and head office in atlanta but also has a European office in and amsterdam and we're of course dutch so there's a connection between Atlanta and Holland just they're all that's interesting i didn't know that I didn't know bitpay had offseason and holiday that's really its connection that's really wonderful yeah it's a great
company I've visited their offices i co-sponsored a conference with bitpay this is a very interesting company and they've been enormously successful and still holding onto the principles which is very unusual these days exactly so before we dive into the world of bitcoin is first talk a bit about philosophy and anarchy and because you identify yourself as nana guess right i do and and there are many reasons for this I first of all convinced that the state no makes no contribution whatsoever to making the world a better place it doesn't help us in our individual lives and our families and our communities as nations it does nothing but cause
trouble lives parasitically out the rest of the population so and I think that society without a state has has all the mechanisms that are necessary to give us what we want prosperity security allow for an opportunity for realizing our dreams all that comes from the social order and not not from the state so I don't I think the state was is has always been a mistake essentially it's one we keep recreating again and again but I personally don't believe it has much future and I think we're entering into an a world of Anakin's and I think we need to prepare for by understanding what it means what Annika's philosophy really is so what do you think of new
states like New Berlin this new tiny stated it was announced a few weeks ago do you think that's a good thing or nothing I it has to be a good thing I you know I think it's a part of a larger puzzle I do think it's fascinating this idea of finding that territory in the world that is not ruled by any state establishing was a free place that's I think very good but I still don't think that that's necessary to achieve anarchism I think what's necessary is that we have to make the state obsolete through the growth of Technology peer-to-peer technology that connects people across borders and without the intermediary menace of intermediating menace of the state itself so i think we
can realize anarchy without having to move to liberland as nice as lower than might be although i understand it's not that much bigger than the Vatican's and it's mostly filled with trees and stuff like that you know so it sounds like there's a lot of work to do yeah I'm actually organizing endorphins in Holland in September it is actually first time I talk about it publicly but the president of the Libra dentists already agreed on and speaking at a conference because he's going to accept Bitcoin in his new nation so it's interesting to to hear more than I think it's really really fascinating I hope that that they'll be left alone by the European community and by the United Nations or the biggest problem of all in
the world the United States you but we shall see maybe if liberland is bother anybody else then nobody will bother liberal and that's that's what I'd like to see happen and I think it's really exciting you know there's also other nations but what country is that that's now offering passports it's not to czech republic in estonian with the ira's yeah II residency and Estonia so that's kind of exciting is it limited actually they don't offer passport so it's dressed residency but I think it's really exciting this idea that we're going to break down nation-state
attachments you know i mean the nation-state is this weird artifact it was born and something like the early 16th century and it gradually got worse and worse and worse and then became worse of all in the 20th century but but it's not a natural state of living I mean Europe and you know in the in the 15th century an early 16th century but you know there were different names for different countries but borders were porous you know you would go across them and and and even that's through the late 19th century people tended to think of themselves as Europeans a citizen of Europe you know they would travel from here to there their names are slightly a
change based on the language they speak and that sort of thing but this weird thing that we have nowadays that you somehow like a slave of this geographic territory in which you live I think this is this is artificial and it's incompatible with a digital age so I fully expect the system of of passports and national borders and nationalism that is such a feature the 20th century is going to eventually evaporate in the course in the 21st century and how do you how do you expect this transition to take place and videos right now governments of a lot of power and a lot of assets do you you you want
governments to start selling those assets and start dismantling the power you think it's the organic process or you think it will be more of a shark in a way yeah I think it would be both you know people start misbehaving enough and eventually states can't keep up with them anymore and then they adapt their laws to accommodate them we're seeing this every day in the United States you know because we have arcane laws governing every aspect of life but those laws are being eaten away through peer-to-peer technology in housing riddles and hotels and car rentals transportation services offices professions I mean there's all these
things that are happening every day through the app economy that are breaking down these old systems with regulation that are that are that want to codify and control everything I mean like you can't control in the world anymore and that's what's that's what's beautiful about it and I what I see happening is that people at first they get involved in Pierre depicted technology because it works for them and makes her a better life I discovered that it runs headlong into some government restriction they're appalled and amazed by this this grows and grows and grows and eventually states adapt to either just not enforce or to actually actively change their laws so I see this as a feedback loop that's going to
continue to unravel so you think peer-to-peer technology will nibble away the state's power M slowly but surely that's already happening all around us all around us may I see this in the US all the time you know 20 years ago every city had a taxi monopoly you know so that you could only ride with somebody who was licensed to drive you you know then and now that whole system has been blown apart really in the course of like 18 months it's been awesome to see it and it's the same thing with like zoning regulations like I'm in Atlanta right now anybody in Atlanta if you have an extra room in your house now can list
that room I'm services like air B&B and you can turn your house into a hotel well this is pretty amazing because it it goes against zoning laws and tax regulations and and all these systems that have been constructed to prevent just the thing but when governments are faced with something as as amazing as peer-to-peer technology they eventually decide that the cost of enforcing these laws are too high even for governments so we're seeing this happen and taking up 16 child labor laws are under pressure because somebody like in the u.s. you can't really work at a job in to your 18 years old which maybe that's amazing to you I don't know but I
think it's disgusting like people should be allowed to work whatever age they want to you know why do we have these crazy lost but thanks to peer-to-peer technology now you see very intelligent young people at the age of 12 and 13 starting online businesses you know even at a very young age and and if you're starting the business online there's nothing anybody can do to enforce child labor legislation and I think this is this is very good so it's like happening across every sector and every way you know it's touching every area of life like the ability to sell goods and services you know like eBay has turned the whole world into this global marketplace you know and all these
portals that allow you to work as a contractor you know now I can work for you you can work for me we can communicate directly and we were having this video conference you know I mean it's it's it's it's awesome the way the advance of globalization and the end technology is really shattering a model for organizing the world that emerged pretty much in the early part of the 20th century but I don't think it can last under the current conditions for very specific reasons too and it has to do with the fact that states really only have two features to them one is that they control only the physical world and they can only do so geographically so if
you can come up with the new technology that evades the limitations of the physical world and exists outside the limitations of national geography then you bust apart the system and that's precisely what we're talking about with a digital digital world and peer-to-peer technology it's digital so it's weightless and spaceless and it's n is truly global nowadays in the economy world you download apps from anywhere on you don't you don't care what they're made there's no protectionism on app on mobile applications for example right like you pay probably extra premiums to for sugar and for corn or for pork or for ham right we're shoes but you're not paying any protectionists premiums on on
applications like you know around me calm or or you know Facebook instant messaging or anything so the more the more goods are distributed in this format the more things are available to be traded freely instead of protected would it be funny if there were import controls on something like Facebook instant messaging so like you should only only download 10,000 copies and in Amsterdam the crazy and every crazy if you would say that's insane huh i miss your talkin yeah and but do you think that like like a hammer you can use technology for good and for bad i can use my hammer as a mass mass murder of mass destruction or i can use to pound
in some nails but likewise the government could adopt something like a cryptocurrency and make it mandatory so watch what your take on that because stuff that sometimes bothers me because they can also use this new technology in more sinister way so have you have you given any thought about that yeah sure well i mean the one thing about governments is that they're much not nearly as smart as market so markets are just naturally smarter and are better at doing things the government's and consumers will always be in a position of choosing one or the other I mean people forget this but back when email first came along the United States Post
Office thought that they would have their own system of email and so they implemented this new system and and expected everybody to go to a government office to get their email system and they were certain that this would work because they thought that people would prefer the government system because it's more verifiable and an official you know but it work right they put out these machines they tried to get everybody to get email addresses there was talk that they would mandate this but it just blew apart because about the post office is not funding political campaigns the banks are so this report when a post office goes overboard well the government will be like okay but if if the banks go
overboard I guess then we'll take steps in in some way or the other so well they're taking steps now I mean bitcoin is is a lot more regulated today than it was even a year and a half ago you know I mean like two years ago you could start a Bitcoin exchange in the US with no restrictions and then the Financial Crimes enforcement Network at the Department of Treasury implemented a one-page list of things you had to do if you wanted to become a Bitcoin exchange and immediately hundreds of exchanges just went out of business I said we can't do this anymore so if they could cause a lot of damage but I just don't believe that over the long run they're going to win the struggle but i think it's it's a good thing then that banks
and vested interest invest in Bitcoin companies right now even today we saw it bits a US exchange to become flu regulated we saw Gordon sacks investing and earlier in circle and we also saw similar investments with with coinbase do you think it's a good development or does it worry you I I think well I think it is a good development in many ways because anything that's a wonderful technology banks are going to want I mean they've been a little bit hot behind of surprises taking them so long and blockchain technology and the money transmission services of Bitcoin are so much better than our existing system I mean I'm like I don't know what it's like an Amsterdam but in the United States if I want to get money to a
friend of mine like today it is extremely difficult in fact it's almost impossible you know to do it directly and even now like if I want to send a check for a thousand dollars to a friend the old the only real viable way is for me to go to my bank interface on the web and ask them to write at you know to write a check and mail it through the post office to them and it arrives in their mailbox I mean that's like I just did this yesterday I mean like compared to Bitcoin this is like a joke you know it's like a hundred years old it's ridiculous now things are much better in Holland we are anyway lucky that we have
a very easy to use banking system and people can they instantly to eat to each other but do you think do you think in the states that banks are temporarily interested in the technology behind decentralized Ledger's and so they can basically smooth and their interbank clearing or do you think they're interested in the currency unit itself you know they're not interested in the currency unit they're interested in the interbank clearing there's no question about that but still I think it's good because we need a better infrastructure to get the big banks behind it will lead to ever more development and the fact is that the way Satoshi build our Bitcoin it's not possible for the blockchain to be separated from Bitcoin as a currency these are really one in the same so it's
going to be good for Bitcoin III believe the other thing is that since bitcoin is essentially an open source decentralized system all the investments that the big mix make in black chain style technology can be taken by the private markets and be used in those open source world to its it they don't have to be exclusive of each other and we all know the truth about the blockchain we once you live in that ecosystem you're you're basically free to do what you want especially if you use anonymizing plugins you know like dark coin and that kind of stuff you know i mean there's there's there's not going to be any stopping this but it's going to be a long process right i mean it's gonna take you know five to
twenty years but but the important thing is that it's like an awesome innovation because you know before Bitcoin came along nobody really knew an alternative to national currency we didn't we didn't even know it was possible to create a currency out of digits like if you'd asked somebody 10 years ago can this happen there I mean if you'd asked me 10 years ago can this happen I would say oh no way it'll never happen now we know it's possible and that knowledge alone is is awesome because it gives a chance for us to to escape that they the prison of the nation-state one of the coolest things about Bitcoin to me is it's it's a global currency so you can really use it on a global basis without these constant
conversions in and out of national currencies and that's that makes that automatically more marketable to the whole world yeah it's just interesting also to me I mean open my eyes as to like typically a lot of people think well currency that's the state's business or maybe the banks or a combination but through the use of bit going you you understand it's a very important aspect of life that should not be dominated by the state and it it's very nice and cool if people can do it on a peer-to-peer basis so if it works with money it works for all sorts of other things as well as we already see of course with housing and rides and all of that so we entered me of you it could usher in a new era of the peer-to-peer society or people just work together without third parties I agree I
completely agree you're right about that it's the experience of using it that's that's so awesome like you can read about it you know all the time in the papers or on Wikipedia whatever but like you don't really know how incredible it is until you actually own it and then transmit it and then you get this like glimmer of the future you know you just you feel yourself embedded in a world that's newly dawning and it's it's it's amazing didn't you go back to national currency you're like oh you know this is this is terrible this is a terrible sister can't possibly work and I gave her I gave a presentation last week for the Libertarian Party and amsterdam so and about five or six people showed up
so that's a big turn out differently guys it's good to stay with both feet on the ground i guess but my question really wash like you're an anarchist and how other anarchists are they picking it up or it should be an anarchist wet dream i guess they're going in the US it it really is in fact in a way people have exaggerated expectations for McLain like they think it's going to be this magic thing that's going to get immediately from where we are to where we want to be and yeah and and that's not true it's it's like the best tool I think human Liberty has ever had but
that doesn't make it magical right it's still going to be a long time and a lot of struggles between here and there so I'm worried about the transition like people have exaggerated expectations in the anarchist world for forgetting something like people think for example it's anonymous right it's not anonymous then people need to understand that but you know a new world of freedom is not born and built like overnight it's just that I think right now we have the best the best tool we've ever had I mean the peer-to-peer revolution has been going on for a long time i would say maybe 10 or 15 years but it wasn't until bitcoin
that we had a currency to use I mean you can't imagine a global economic revolution taking place without having a currency otherwise we're always forever bartering services and that's what goes on a lot of the time in the peer-to-peer world but now with this unit of account we have the thing that takes us from bardur you know into civilization and and now we have the infrastructure that can can build and build and build and scale across the globe so we have all the pieces in place and now that's all thing and the thing you just said about exaggeration do you also blame yourself maybe I'm dead regarded oh I thought I felt a bit I've also been to positive in the past fortunately as some people
listened in time and were able to acquire bid going at a very low price but I sometimes saying yeah I should have been maybe a little bit more realistic especially let's say twenty twelve or twenty thirteen absolutely I mean I totally agree with you I mean it's I look back at some of these things like you know I would give these talks you know just like I was just so excited about it right then in the nation's take you know and this is gonna be no limit to everything and I've and it was very exciting and I was probably in a sense like overly exuberant it away because I gave the message you know that it was somehow gonna be like a no-brainer you know like struggle is over and and that's just I never
intended to say that but that's probably in many ways how I came across just because I do think it's awesome and I haven't changed my mind of that but yeah I I agree I bear some responsibility for that oh so we have quite a few question from the audience and it's and let's go through a few of them first of all from hendrick young he'll bullying and arm the state's replaced by multinationals like a Google Facebook and Twitter ha yeah well I mean once we get once we get rid of the state we still have the problem of corporate cartels right but they but these these ages to Google and Twitter and Facebook have far less power in a world without intellectual property
and and in a world where they're not being bolstered in their bigness and in their size and their scale by the state's themselves so I think one of the reasons these organs ease corporations are so powerful is precisely because states are powerful but yeah this is another problem we have to deal with and we are not yet towards a peer-to-peer world we're just we're just building it a little bit at a time but I also worry that yeah I mean things like like Google they also have central points of failure and what we really need to work towards and is a truly decentralized world without enforcement of IP without the regulations like that but that hobble
competition you know without the state I think that they're going to have much less power at least there'll be an opportunity for constant competition related question is from dimple store it's about IDs because right now with passwords from the state right it's a completely arbitrary thing because my wife she's Ecuadorian and it's very difficult for her to travel two lovely ladies very smart but she cannot travel easily because of being born in the wrong country it's just a lottery of course very unfair but then we can go maybe to word where we were where we have IDs from facebook and google which is still not ideal so the next step would be decentralized ID system so Tim's question is what do you think of decentralized bitcoin-related ID systems and how are these going to help to do it get rid of those made-up
geographical borders that's a really good question I'm extremely excited about the use of block train in general for creating non for jable and immutable identity systems and for processing transactions their exchange related even apart from money so and I know a lot of people are thinking and working hard on this topic and we're working our way towards that I mean I'm really excited about things like block dream marriages right I mean I think that's really great if somebody was to get married why should you have to go crawling to the government you should just be able to get married on the blockchain I mean and I've done I guess now to block chain weddings so see you are d block chain priest I cry every time and I always try
to catch the roses beautiful as another question from Jillian get here it's Jeffrey let me ask you a question off topic somewhat ron paul's felt many times in the power structure that actually runs the government's like the permanent stake what gives you hope that they will not shut down the internet by guidance well the empty internet shuts down then the ruling class shuts down too so it's not in their interest to shut down I mean everything collapses you know a hundred percent of all financial transactions and the world goes back to you know pre-modern times so I I don't think that that's a real danger I thought the question was we're going to ask about my theory of the
state you know by reference to Ron Paul and I I think this is a gigantically important question because I spent years thinking about it I used to think of the state as being just politicians and I realize that's not true and then I thought it was like this thing that's completely exogenous like a violent force that's always holding people down and I realize that's not really true either and my latest understanding of the state I feel like I've kind of become more sophisticated my understand it really is kind of like what the Marxist say is that it's the violent tool used by the ruling class to create cartels and and eliminate competition for its power I think that
the essence of what the status libertarians need to do a lot more work to understand this do you know what do we shed about state sir john dewey yeah he said it's a shadow cast on society my big business yeah it's not entirely crazy analysis the more I look into it the more I'm shocked at the direct relationship between the violent means and the largest wealth holders and power holders and among the ruling class I mean there really is a deep almost stable cooperative relationship that happens between the two this is important because because people on the Left think of the state as being an
extension of the people right so so like if we want to have more equal distribution of wealth we should give the state more power so they can equalize wealth and power and privilege I mean the problem is that that never ever happens I mean once you give the state more power the only people who benefit is the existing ruling class structure that's that's what it works and then on the right people tend to think of of the state as being simply like the realization of mob rule you know like this is the state really is the rabble the have-nots organizing to take from the haves I mean that's not true either it actually is the existing
power holders and wealth holders in the social order organizing and conspiring to maintain their monopoly of control and power that's that's what the essence of the state is and neither the left or the right fully answered understands this but in each potentially democratic well its democratic in name that's what's funny I mean like it's very advantageous for the ruling class to give the impression that everybody is participating in this great project of ruling ourselves and that's the purpose of elections but do elections actually achieve what we hope they will like like a revolution of who of what the kind of
regimes we live in really I mean least in the US elections are mostly kind of silly and sometimes you can make a little bit of progress that way but but mostly it's just it's like a like a like a charade you know it's like a like a a game we all play together but you hear your friend of rental Orange you just me yes I've known him since he was about 22 years old and we used to hang out at backyard barbecues at ron's house so it sliced him not to Rondon and the if you think it's a theater and you know he's not able to change anything well you know it's funny Rand would disagree with me on this point and he thinks he believes that he can achieve something for the
cause of human Liberty by running for president I like to hope he is right and all I can say is that I'm glad it's that he's doing it and not me so I I mean I have extreme doubts that this is true but he's very very clever and very serious so he thinks he's going to outsmart the system that's what he believes you know all the all true believers will to get flushed out on the primary I guess yeah well we'll see I mean he's very clever and very popular actually I think and Republican circles and I mean people say do you support him well I I don't really it's not my thing
right to like support this politician or that politician not really I kind of wish him the best in a way but the most i think he could probably do is decline to do really evil things like go to war or something like that or maybe his presence will help break down and accelerate the decline of the nation-state I hope that's true but at some level part of me dreads it also because I he's a friend of mine and I I do worry that he's going to get eaten alive by by ruling class structure and it's very smart very well-funded and anybody who sets out to defeat it is it's going to be facing a very difficult
time of it what Lisa's procrit currency so that's a good thing as a war and we it will hopefully help the movement to grow further yeah you know it's very interesting because he's never it's fascinating to me because like you were saying earlier you used to be really interested in the gold standard you know and I was to write like I wrote my undergraduate thesis on on the gold standard and I've always loved gold as an idea but but like you and I and the handful of old people care about the gold standard but it has absolutely no future you know in a technological world especially in the presence of Bitcoin so what do you think of all these new bit and new cryptocurrency is backed by buy gold but it's also a question from Gideon again Jeff we should bit gonna be
back by commodities like real estate gold silver in other words by hard assets to be a real alternative to other fiat money and I read it forward to to getting your answer in that one yeah I don't think that's impossible but i do think if people need to understand that bitcoin as it currently exists is backed by something extremely important and valuable and the same sense of Mises talked about use value it's backed by the extraordinary service of the blockchain and people say what the hell is that well the blockchain allows you to title and commodified bundle information bits and and transfer them almost instantly on a geographically non-contiguous basis in a way that's non for jable non reproducible in mutual and
immortal okay that's never been possible in the whole history of the planet and the whole history of humanity nothing like this has been possible so yeah that's an unbelievable value proposition and the currency that enables that it makes that possible then absorbs the value that emerges out of that block chain services so it's different from gold but it's probably more valuable than gold in ski feeling extra Tucker to wear to rafting shop and you seem quite a embedded in the Bitcoin stuff would ya you also do other things I guess I I do I I'd work for laissez-faire books I work for the foundation for economic education I read one book I have a book
I'm becoming book called called a bit by bit how Peter p is free in the world and it's all about all about Bitcoin but I spend my days trying to do many things like I work for the foundation for economic education we're in the throes of revolution it's revolutionising it's real real estate and big massive ways I also run Liberty dot me which is a social publishing platform for liberty and I do a lot of writing for Leslie fair books too so I try to keep like my feet in all these different worlds you know intellectual space technology you know practical applied applications of
Liberty so yeah I'm trying to do a lot of different things but they all center around this one theme yeah okay just just one a quick last question and my favorite Armani philosopher you should Andrew gosh maybe you heard of him he's a gold guy and he states just it's the doll of stern and a barrel soon so the fair fat will probably start raising interest rates there were a lot of disappointing quarterly reports coming out inflation is coming what do you think this will do for Bitcoin I think bitcoin is the new safe-haven it's not gold it's Bitcoin and if the Fed really starts raising interest rates then we could actually directed yeah we'll have to go we'll go to another recession I don't actually worried about inflation
that much but in the case of a genuine monetary crisis like we had in 2008 you have the Bitcoin exchange rate to the dollar in any cases is I I'm willing to believe that it's going to change directions and just take off if and it will not affect gold as much I think bitcoin is the new gold and that's pretty obvious to me now okay great okay well and Jeffrey am I never really has been talking more than half an hour but i'm amazed about you're so busy with so many things and you still sleep i guess and do you have a partner or dr Ewing in a relationship work well that yeah that's well that's a those are big big
questions I I do not sleep as much as I should yeah for sure last night in fact I was lying in bed for three hours thinking about technology I get obsessed with things so sometimes I have to knock myself out with a good glass of gin we were to Roger very well he was reading up on mid going he was actually dehydrated after a few days because he stopped and sleeping and eating and his his girlfriend had to bring in to the hospital I completed I can believe this i mean really outline it because I'm you know I'm building out a new cloud structure for feed org which is an immensely complicated problem we're building a news content management
system out of an existing live site and tracking tracking the progress of this dude this great new dot that planet we're building so all night long I just had code rolling around in my head now through architecture issues and potential complications and yeah it's it's obsessive I yeah it's it's obsessive and thrilling because look I mean look all of us this generation of workers in the space we're building the new world you know it's it's an awesome responsibility and and incredibly exciting so yeah it's hard to sleep yeah I admire your positivity and and of course also you always make sure to dress up perfectly like a gentleman so keep it up with Jeffrey Thank You Syd
March and everyone should check of Liberty dot me and of course Jeffrey talk on Twitter and and maybe we can do to get in future thanks so much thank you so much for inviting me it's really great to be here all the best guys might write
