The Gold Repatriation Movement

De Week van Bitcoin · 18 Dec 2014 · 40:06

Paul Buitink talks with gold analyst Koos Jansen and economist Tuur Demeester about the gold repatriation movement. Jansen explains why countries are bringing gold home as doubts about the dollar grew after 2008, including the Netherlands moving 122 tons from New York and Germany's slower, continuing programme. They discuss Chinese and Russian gold buying, euro crisis contingency planning by the Dutch and German governments, and what role gold may play in a future monetary system. The conversation closes in favour of monetary diversity and free-market money.

Speakers

Topics

From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.

Transcript

hello everybody my name is Bob I think and welcome to our weekly show about Bitcoin Gold's the future of money and much more I'm very pleased to have both the cosians and to the master on our show today the code is a widely respected gold expert will rise for boom starcom and tyr is a renowned economist both need no further introduction today it's all about the gold repatriation movement Russia Bitcoin and the new financial order fewer scan ask questions using the Q&A tool and don't forget to subscribe to this channel on YouTube and follow us on Google+ so you never miss a single episode ghost let's just jump right into the action what's the whole gold repatriation move it all about and why does it matter well it matters because it's it's it seems like a global

phenomenon at this stage and it matters because since nineteen forty four it was the beginning of Bretton Woods the world sort of agreed the the United States dollar was the world reserve currency and ever since it has been but since 2008 some people began to doubt about the status of the world of the US dollar and of course the United States is printing a lot of dollars we can see a lot of yet dysfunction in the system happening in the last couple of years and a lot of countries not only China Russia but also Europe and other countries are are worried about what is

coming next or they are preparing for what is coming next and they are all grasping or they're they're all looking to their goals to yeah because most likely gold is is going to be a new anchoring system as we might know but maybe not the viewers a complete fired standard is not sustainable I mean maybe robots can can use it longer than we but we humans it's just so seductive to print unlimited amounts of money that then

work and it's it's it destroys capitalism so to say so you can see all these bubbles and Aaron capital fleeing around the world and a money-printing happening on all continents and in depth in this environment we can see a very clear reaction of of a lot of countries two words gold so of course we know Chinese hunger two words gold is immense we don't really know for sure how much the PBOC is buying because it's probably the best-kept secrets on earth but you know a lot of professionals analyste

estimate they have about 4,000 tons right now we can see rug shop that's the most aggressive buyer officially at the moment they buy oh I think about 20 tons a month on an outer almost reaching 1,100 tons right now and the the most significant part now is at Western countries in Europe are also physically repatriating their goals from from England and from New York Federal Reserve Bank New York and that is Germany and in the Netherlands and also other countries like Belgium Austria and we know now that Australia has also done

an audit at the bank of england i published today so all these Western countries are also yeah expressing their it devalued a text to go to gold or yeah repatriating so this global phenomenon is it's accelerating also I mean first it was only finish whele then Germany stepped in and now almost every month or every week we hear a story of a country that is or you know in politics they're discussing it or they they're admitting day there have been auditing gold in England or in the United States or is like the game of musical chairs where

the music is about to end and people are rushing towards yeah yeah and and the fact that it's accelerating its it's quite significant I think and also the thing is that when the Dutch example was was astonishing I think because they suddenly announced they had repatriated 122 tons from New York so first of all this is an immense way of saying we don't trust you towards the United States and second we must consider that or contemplated and in the past two years the dutch national bank day in bed in a de lanza bank the

central bank here prepared this repatriation and i did some analysis on this and in 2012 the governor of the central bank in the netherlands said in a TV show there's nothing wrong with with our gold in the united states it's safe there we're not going to repatriate and i have evidenced that a few months after that brought that was broadcasted the dutch central bank made a second line of defense around their compound around the central bank's with enormous stone blocks and and this was done yet what kind of evidence do you have about this well I've published it on my on my

blog and I've called the Dutch central bank and I said yes that's true at the end of 2012 and I mean I live around the corner of the central bank and I saw it and when the repatriation was published all the pieces of the puzzle came together and so they confirmed this to me at the end of two thousand twelve day they built this security barrier with which stone rocks Rock blocks to keep cars and trucks from entering the building then I heard from a source this is anecdotal stuff but I heard from a source that in 2013 a delegation of the Dutch central bank went to New York to

to audit the gold in the vaults of the federal reserve bank of new york the Americans showed the Dutch delegation a pile of gold and said this is this belongs to you then in the summer of 2014 this yeah you could call it a military action was prepared and then in October and November all the gold in several shipments 122 tons was repatriated from New York to Amsterdam this is my mine Ellis from the sources I have I could be wrong but you know it it fits together but we'll see at the end

of this month the Federal Reserve Bank of New York publishes their numbers about their total deposits they hold for four accounts so we can know sort of what happens how much Germany took out how much the Netherlands took out right now four years ago i was i was looking into the balance sheet of the dutch central bank and then there was no information about where they store the gold so I had the Socialist Party in Holland ask questions in them to Minister finance and also to the central bank as to the whereabouts of the gold and eventually they they came up with with these locations and then we kept on pushing and then eventually and socialist party kept on asking questions about that goes shouldn't we get to go back and and almost it was shortly thereafter and they started to

repatriate in the gold apparently so that's this quite interesting and story it almost reads like a book and so yeah so girl isn't Belgium also something going on like this or not you mean with gold repatriation yeah um not to my knowledge I think there was a there was some I think the central bank admitted to where the gold was stored something about two years ago they they they said that about forty percent but this is just from from memory about forty percent was held abroad I think that was I remember that being like something new but apart from that I don't remember anything happen recently by the way for the listeners out there who haven't who

are mostly in the Bitcoin haven't heard of cosi onsen I just really want to highly highly recommend his his work to follow him on Twitter read his research it's it's one of the most no nonsense and thorough that's that's out there if your instant gold in the future of fiat currency i think it's it's essential so thanks close for being on the show I think it's fantastic what you do thank you very much dear for the recommendation yeah really good a encodes what about Germany damn because Holland did this self action and God got a lot of gold back more than hundred tons um as far as i remember and then the Germans they only got back a very meager amount of just just five tons in

2013 and then there were some some news headlines that they wanted to stop the repatriation Bloomberg Miss Claudette's a few people so tell me bit more about the German repatriation and is it still going on it's definitely still going on indeed Bloomberg published a story and it was very misleading their motives are left for speculation but they everybody read the article as if Germany stopped repatriating the gold so Germany had a program in let's say in 2013 overpaid creating three hundred tons of gold from New York and and Bloomberg said somewhere mid-2014 Germany will stop

repatriating and the German government has full confidence in the Americans they never stopped it's really easy if you go to the website of the booms bunk you see a lot of phone numbers and email addresses of the press department you give her give him a ring and you confirm it by email they said to me we never stopped repatriating so they are still repatriating it is of course a big question why the Germans take so long about repatriating goals because obviously you can do it in a quite short time I mean some people say it takes for very long time to ship a few hundred

tons of gold but in 2013 china imported 1,500 tons of gold so that's possible and I don't know why you couldn't with a few airplanes and it would with a what a small group of people repatriate a few hundred tons in a few months so the real reason then why is Germany and taking taken so much time you think there they understand the day day no there's not enough and day or day what was the what's the whole the whole reasoning behind Germans being so slow i think it's a it's a gold is a political metal and metal and I've spoken to better building her who is the founder of

repatriate our gold that's the German initiative that in 2011 sort of you know pushed the central bank to repatriate gold and then they went ahead and repatriated I must add that the Germans also repatriated about nine hundred and fifty tons from London in i believe it was 2001 completely in secret and they they told us this just two years ago I believe but to come back to your question why Germany isn't speeding up the repatriation what Peter building or he's of course I think an insider in Germany is telling me that the booms bank doesn't want to repatriate as fast

and apparently the Dutch did want to repatriate really fast and and that's the whole difference I mean maybe the Germans want to keep keep the the Americans as friends or it's a bit sensitive or I don't know but normally they have the same policy replicas in the old days the Gilder was respected a more more less flexible to the mark and they usually also in the ECB council they speak with one mouth the Germans in the Dutch yes and we know we know for sure that the Dutch were preparing for a break of breakup of the euro because the Minister of Finance I believe they admitted that there was a plan B so do you think the Dutch are getting the gold back in order to prepare for a north and

euro or for the return of the killer I wouldn't say so we do know now I think some Dutch politicians or other politicians think euro crisis is over or I don't know but apparently that thought it was wise to come out with this news yeah we have we have stories from our Minister finance Dashiell bloom and former Minister of Finance dr who confirmed that in 2012 when the euro crisis what was at its peak the Netherlands and also Germany were preparing for everything so and

that included a to be able to fall back on a on another currency if the euro would would break and I don't think those planes are in in the bucket or in the shredder right now so it's just but it's it's all you know you can just see the the problems and the tensions grow and and it's only wise to get your gold back I'm not sure if if the Netherlands and Germany are preparing for a northern euro I think they want to stick with rest of Europe but why not just repatriate and be on the safe side and that's what we're doing and because

there's also something which is called the Washington agreement it has been signed in 1999 and it was a cooperation between nearly all European Central Bank's as you know maybe a lot of European Central being sold a lot of goals in between 1990 and now and to do this in a sort of an in a managed fashion together they designed the central bank agreement of gold I believe it's called the Washington agreed and so so these European Central Bank's which are also of course in the euro they they are on the same line so and add to that

that in 2011 the yahoo that is the former minister of finance of the netherlands was asked in 2011 why did the netherlands sell so much gold prior to let's say the year two thousand four to two thousand five and he said we sold about 1,100 tons to equalise our holdings to other important gold holding nations so this kind of makes you wonder in what degree this was all orchestrated this equalization or redistribution of gold but all those all these clues are

interesting if we look at the future monetary system and and at what part gold is gonna play Miss yeah now we got a few questions from from Digable our he asked goes Germany was critical towards Russian sanctions early on and Ukraine crisis now they are paying more easy going towards easy go into our supporting us and I Russian initiatives does goes feel a more Dutch approach with citing them up and democracy might be going on with a German getting gold sorry I don't understand the question I guess what he's trying to say is miss do you think the Germans are using a sort

of a more darts approach which means like a sort of silent demopolis diplomacy to get the gold back because they know at the heart the heart approaches maybe not going to work for German as they're too great maybe too big to to use that approach that could be of course Germany is a powerhouse in world and it would be and and there's a lot of lot more gold at stake I think Germany has about has more than 1,000 tons of gold abroad so if they would repatriate all their goal that would be we talk about a lot more gold and so things for Germany Germany is an elephant and they have to move more

slowly so it can be the day you know for political reasons choose to take it easy and do it step by step and but but I I don't know what's what's happening behind closed doors but what is also interesting is that like Austria or a in sorry Australia I just published something about Australia their annual report just came out of the central bank from Australia and they noted that they didn't audit at the bank of england in the past few months so we don't know how many countries are auditing gold now in england and in new york and there can be so much more at play at the moment yes I think that I don't know if everybody is

aware but like how at least this is this was something new to me when I did my research is how often the central bankers meet internationally I mean it's a very small club of people they all know each other I would think once the word goes around and it becomes a trend to start auditing your gold and I wouldn't be surprised if there's a lot more countries than what we were publicly aware of so far and something I was wondering about is about Germany it seems to me that it's somewhat of a public secret how fragile the German financial system is you look at Deutsche Bank it's the biggest bank in Europe and it's also the most leverage bank in

Europe and so I was curious goes well do you think it's possible that there is somewhat of a tip tip for tat going on between Germany and the u.s. in that you know the US because of their they basically their boss of the dollar and of a lot of financial assets that they might cut a deal with the German central bank like if we make it easy for you financially to to kind of keep these problems somewhat under control in the in your financial system in your banking system maybe in return you guys can put less pressure on us to repatriate your gold is that a possibility yeah that could be I think I think that's how the

world works also if you diplomatic documents are always released three years after after that so if you read back now diplomatic documents from the 70s this is exactly how central bankers communicate with each other it's just dealings and the example you just described can it can it can be really can be the case and I also think that of course the central bankers talk to each other even stronger the they all meet at the the Bank of International Settlements in imbecile quite often and there are no journalists loud there no other politicians and not know ministers

of finance I even believe it's it's a separate country this little building so of course the central bankers talking chatter and you can also ask yourself why the gold prices so low and China is allowed to buy so much that can be because of course the United States and China also have a have a really strong trade relationship and they're in a marriage and you know the United States once do it has a lot of debt and they won't want to devalue the dollar but China has four trillion in dollar reserves and they don't want to see those reserves devalued so but they control so to say the United States I mean they Russia cold china in the heat

of the moment in 2008 and Russia said to China let's pull the plug out of the dollar and then China said no we're not going to do that because it would evaporate our savings but but they told this to America China said to America later on Luke we saved your ass and we can stop buying Treasuries we can dump them we can do whatever we like sure we can we can take some pain but cha and it has a lot of control over the United States so who knows what what what what the deals are between them so to come back to your question I can't answer it but I I think at the world works like this and of course it's all making deals between central bankers and politicians

hmm and I'm talking a bit more about Russia cause then and since you already dressed undressed it briefly and what's going on with with the ruble right now and how does that relate to kohls I saw today on 0 as did Russia apparently is starting to sell gold which is sort of counter to what I thought they were doing could you elaborate an elaborate a little bit on the rush situation yeah that's a I heard the Russians were selling gold about a week ago when Yahoo came out with a with an article and then we we have another great Dutch analyst here he's called Frank nopers he wrote an article about it and he checked effects and it wasn't true so I'm not sure sure if Russia is really selling gold also given the fact

they have been by there the most aggressive buyers of gold in the last couple of years I mean they buy gold and publish it on on on their website every month so i'm not sure if they are selling gold they also have a lot of dollars why not first sell some more dollars I believe they have the 450 billion dollars reserves and so i'm not sure if they're selling gold I don't think so actually we have to be careful for for the in the media war now I think Russia sonotek and there are WikiLeaks documents from five years ago which state that Russia wouldn't feel comfortable if NATO would move more towards the Ukraine and Russia expressed

in those it was at the NATO meeting I believe oh i am sorry i don't know this for sure i'm going to say but in these week in leaked documents that you can find them on my website russia has stated that if NATO would move more towards the Ukraine that would be a very sensitive development and there could be civil unrest or even a civil war in the Ukraine and what do you know exactly this is happening and I think who is the biggest beneficiary of the whole Ukraine crisis and of mh17 so I'm sorry I have to speculate a lot this this broadcast but it's the United States was the biggest beneficiary you now see a

breakup between Russia and Europe they're both suffering from it I mean here in the Netherlands we we export a lot of milk and vegetables and fruit towards Russia and so we're who were hurt obviously the Russians are hurt so I think and Janet Yellen yesterday said at the meeting that the ruble tumbled because oil prices dropped whoa yeah oil drug but I don't see all the other oil-exporting nations in a collapsing right now or their currencies maybe a little bit but not to the degree which is which the ruble is its collapsing so I think the United States has an interest in you know divide and

conquer too I don't know the details but obviously and also Putin today said in his press conference that the whole crisis was provoked by yeah by who he didn't say but we all know what he meant so fast fast forward in six months was or maybe even unless what's going to be the outcome are we going to see an uprising of the of the Russian people because possibly that something that the US after 22 wage economic warfare hoping that the people will kind of you know with their empty stomachs will revolt against Russia lead Russian leaders and then they have another breakup of the Russia which what's the outcome of this game for what do you think is going to happen well the only know I think about

it is that ninety-five percent of the Russian people love Putin my girlfriend is Russian and so I got to get some sources from from Russia and I she can translate some things for me the people love Putin and if you look back since he came in power which is probably 15 years ago you really did a lot for the country he he lowered the national debt in terms of you know percentage of depth towards GDP you know he's maybe not democratically chosen but the people love him so I don't think they're gonna

is going to be in a revolution in Russia like we saw in the Ukraine or in Hong Kong which no I don't think so right and to what do you think what will be the impact on bitcoin and bitcoin price has been going down a lot I would expect you know with currency crisis like we see now and in Russia that people would use basically possibly as a vehicle to to keep their wealth out of the system and possibly ordinary Russians for example but I'm not seeing that I think what's going on yeah like well first of all I do think that when people look at ways to protect themselves against capital controls they do also look at the value of the asset

and Bitcoin has been in a downtrend for the past 11 12 months so obviously I think that it's just logical that there wouldn't be like an immediate spike but I do think there is increased interest in Bitcoin we see that definitely happen in in in Russia and how's it going to say I think in general what we're seeing with this oil crisis is how fragile fiat currencies really are if you just take a look at the foreign exchange reserves of several oil-exporting countries they're really under pressure like Australia now only 60 billion down from 80 billion in 2007 Russia was at 500 billion in 07 now

only for 404 and 15 Argentina 50 billion dollars and forex reserves in 2007 now it's below 30 billion Venezuela obviously also in big trouble and these I mean simply put the foreign exchange reserves are that is the money that the central bank uses to defend the value of the local currency so once that runs out the game is up and you have hyperinflation it's as simple as that and so we're really seeing now with the oil crash everything is shifting and a lot of currencies that look like they're quite strong like a norwegian krona for example it's really doing their they're hurting really badly and you can see

people on the internet just regular people that are now trying to find a solution for what to do with their savings so I think this this really is going to be a huge boost for Bitcoin I think first we're going to see some more smart money move into Bitcoin that's already happening because offshore bank accounts are not what they used to be as well and people say that bitcoin is not anonymous but if you hold it in an offshore company or if you have some kind of solid construction that's legally sound then even if government can identify there might be yours they still cannot take it then they cannot pressure an institution to take that money from you so I think this is going to be this is going to be the fuel behind the next big

rally in bitcoin bitcoin as a safe haven acid and bitcoin as unconscious capable money okay can I ask a tour or something about journey so I was wondering I think we both agree on the fact that the current monetary system and fired money is not sustainable for free humanity and we probably move towards a new system and maybe it's gold maybe it's bit going I don't know and what I found really interesting is that now a couple of companies are linking gold to Bitcoin so they make sort of I saw one thing popping by which is called a bit gold

isn't this the ultimate solution because you have all the advantages of goals and all the advantages of Bitcoin or am I missing or something um well I do think we will see like the rise of like boch chain technology will go into all areas of the finance and that will include acid exchange you will include a oil markets gold markets so you will have like commodity contracts that are traded on blockchain networks so Bitcoin like networks it could be on the Bitcoin network it could be the odd side chain that they make colored coins what it's called so I do think that's that's

definitely going to happen because it's much more robust I'll also to keep to keep public records it's a very robust and cheap system to do that as far as like choosing a cold backed had a cryptocurrency over a purely digital cryptocurrency I think there are some liability challenges because the gold that would back the the bit gold for example would still need to be stored somewhere they would still be these auditing requirements and if that would become like a significant size then likely you'll end up in vaults that are like Brinks or g4s like really widely

known firms widely known vaults and then again individuals are exposing themselves to these risks of confiscation of theft and Bitcoin itself because it's it's so well it's it's non material it can be stored anywhere and i think that would that that is what makes it more robust in the long run i do think that goal is going to shine as a debt settlement assets especially between government over the next decades for sure but as far as money goes I don't see a significant advantage to choose physical gold even if it's traded on a blockchain ledger over a purely

digital asset but I mean obviously I would love for the market to decide I mean let's a thousand flowers blossom and let people come up with the systems like bit gold and and and there's also several Bitcoin gold exchanges so people will be able to go from Bitcoin the goals are easily in the future even today already I think that's really really exciting I think we can just agree that central centrally planned paper money is is just a very very bad idea yeah that's correct I would just say you know the thing I always from my economic perspective are highly encouraged Bitcoin because it's free

market development this is you know the free market always thinks of something that you know works best for everybody it's you can think about this by by the government or but but of course I I guess miss in 2011 I lost five bitcoins and this is something you know bitcoins can vanish that's the thing you know so it's also your beauty because it so it doesn't weigh anything you can transport unlimited amounts amounts of capital to the other side of the world and on the other hand I think you know the Volt's like brings in g4s as long as it's in the private sector and you know these

companies are competitive so they have to be trustworthy there was obviously in the Indians in the end it's about who has the keys right and even though they're private companies when they're based in a certain jurisdiction eventually it's the suffering of that jurisdiction that can that can confiscate the keys and open the vaults that's true that's true and that's what I like about Bitcoin if you look at it because yeah if you don't trust yourself to not lose bitcoins you can work with Bitcoin banks and there is a lot of competition there and what you can do with Bitcoin that's impossible with gold is you can work with multi cig transactions so you can store maybe the

access to the bitcoins will are only possible if you have two keys out of three in total so one key is given to you close the customer and then two keys are stored in separate jurisdictions so even if there is and you can even you can make systems that are like five signatures out of seven or whichever combination you like so it's possible to make to really make bitcoins even if they're stored by a third-party unconscious skateable from a political perspective and I think that's really exciting because it means that you can really just trust the company to do the procedures right and at a low even at a low storage fee because the only thing you need is a couple of USB sticks

stored in a vault somewhere yeah I think that's that's really exciting but then on the other hand if you say well I like something in my own hands and I like something that's solid and real you can I mean this is obviously maybe a bit of an outlandish idea but you can take a tungsten bar and engrave your private key into that and then bury that in your yard I mean that's going to be hard to lose but it is a way to physically store your bitcoins for if you want for generations but like I mean I think it's important to also acknowledge that bitcoins can be stored physically that they can actually take the form that we like about gold but you know still I think gold is

scarce and that's why it has value it has a 6,000 year long tradition so I I definitely don't I highly recommend gold as an investment I just don't know like if we're talking 100 years from now weather will be the bedrock of the financial system still that that I'm not sure about do you think there there's a possibility we there can be a system of gold being the store value and Bitcoin the medium of exchange yeah no absolutely I think it's possible I just don't know which one is going to win in the market rental cottage yeah exactly we'll have a have a free market between

currencies just like in the information markets used to be incredibly centralized with only like radio and television and then with the internet everything just exploded and anybody could just like you have your own news website Paul has this news website it's just completely exploded and some of the old values are still accessible that you have you have old style type journalism still accessible that there's a whole variety of other ways and I think in the same way old style gold money and gold banking and gold contracts will still they will have their their role I just think it won't be a central to the world as it will it is today but i do think

golden in the next few years is going to have a very important role to play for sure in with the current environment that you're describing so so brilliantly on your blog right so I've got going to wrap up then guys basically we are in favor of monetary diversity and a free market so a lot of different types of money can comply sermon and flourish so I think it's is good words to end and the show with so it goes first of all thank you very much for being on the show and tell people where they can find you yeah sure yeah my am i right four billion starcom it's just building started coming you can buy some gold or silver or you can go through my blog and read the my latest

research my company is based in a singapore which has really good environment for gold storage and gold purchases no a Texas whatsoever the government is really in favor of goals and also my company has zero storage fees until 2016 because there is no crime we can offer this so go to building star website is the storage can I ask the storage is it in the end of free trade zone now the free trade zone is something in China that is in shanghai and singapore is it's a different country across the pond so to say i remember researching Malcolm it and I thought it was a special zone with

in Singapore that their vault and specific was located in but I could be confused oh well maybe you're right and I don't know it's Malcolm it has a lot of volts across Asia and I know there recently about a year ago opened one it was knocked over 2013 opened one in free trade zone of Shanghai a very large capacity fall so maybe that one I don't know of any free trade zone in Singapore actually i'll yell then i'll look it up and it's it's likely that i'm mistaken so i'll find it out greenhouse curious ok thanks and thank you too woodsy ren and people can find you best on twitter right at to domestic yes yes and there is news in the make but it'll be a few

likely a few months but i'm really excited there is i'm going to be active in different ways in the Bitcoin sphere early 2015 so stewards return to the bitcoin a community then because you had a suppressed go for a few months perfect ok well this year will not be a i'm not going to do houses show for next two weeks because of christmas and new years but we'll be back aight of gnu with under nails antonopoulos as our main gas very much looking forward to that one so thank you guys and see you next time thank you guys