Fraud and Financial Terrorism

De Week van Bitcoin · 7 Oct 2015 · 30:20

Max Keiser and Stacy Herbert, hosts of the Keiser Report, speak at a Reinvent Money event. Keiser walks through a 1980s Wall Street look back trade that, in his account, funnelled gains and tax losses to favoured clients for kickbacks, then recounts inventing the Hollywood Dollar and the Hollywood Stock Exchange, a virtual currency and trading system whose technology he says later fed derivatives pricing. He describes his first reaction to Bitcoin, calls it a surrogate for gold, argues adoption is driven by financial crisis, and answers audience questions about art and early digital money.

Speakers

Topics

From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.

Transcript

[Music] I'm Max Kaiser. Nice to see you all. How's everybody doing? Roderdam is freaking cool. Wow. I've only been to Amsterdam. I've been missing a beach. Put your bag down now. All right. It's my lovely wife, Stacy. We do the Kaiser Report together. Of course, nobody watches this. Please keep it up. Yeah. Well, uh, as usual, my preparation for this afternoon, uh, consisted of, uh, about five minutes ago eating an orange out in the lobby, uh, to come up with something to regail you all with. Uh I I've been listening to the speakers

today and there's a a lot of conversation about bankers are crooks, bankers are fraudulent, they commit all these horrible things, they are derivative wielders and but there's a not much information on the ground in terms of how an actual banking um corruption or banking fraud takes place. So I thought it might be interesting for the audience because I worked on Wall Street for many years. I'm going to walk you through actually how I stole money on Wall Street. How's that sound? Sound good? So, this is an actual case study.

This is not an abstraction. So, this is um I was working on Wall Street in the in the 1980s. And um so this would be a typical way that we would orchestrate a massive fraud. So the the the what we called this was a look back trade. So this is kind of what we would talk to each other and say, "Hey, we're engaged in in a lookback trade." Basically, what this would would entail would be you come into the office usually drunk, coked up. It was the 80s and uh you know, you have to understand that Wall Street at that time when I started on Wall Street there was had

been a bare market for 16 years. It was very difficult to make money on Wall Street. Most the office was half empty. brokers there were working nights as teachers and taxi drivers. It was considered to be a crap job to be a stock broker at that time because the market had gone down for 16 straight years. It was like a wasteland. It was a graveyard. So then as a 22year-old when I started working at Payne Weber which is now owned by I think UBS. But you know, you went from the party atmosphere of college into this boardroom of a of a brokerage firm right at the moment of the biggest bull market in history's birth. So suddenly the market which was not even above a thousand on the Dow Jones, it had struggled to get over a

thousand for decades. Suddenly it made this started that move from eight or 900 on the Dow Jones to the 18,000 where it's been recently. And that's been the history of this enormous, incredible bull market that has just fundamentally changed society in a huge way. But back in the early 1980s, it was still a new thing. And so the job was to take every bad behavior I had as a college student and to transport that into my new job as a stock broker. So basically the we the party just was accelerated by making I think the year before I had a part-time job as a proofreader at a rubber stamp factory

and then I first year at Payne Weber I think I cleared 250,000 and that was having absolutely no knowledge whatsoever from a stock or a bond or any I had absolutely no idea but there was just so much money that flooded in that you a reesus monkey could uh could do well. But um there were a lot of interesting tricks. So the look back trade um was basically you come in and you find stocks that have a very high beta that are very volatile um that are whipsawing in price. And when you see that kind of action, it means that the options market, you know, the options market rides on top of the the stock

market, if you will. you see a lot of volatility in the options market as well. So you come in and basically you buy a 100red or 200 options on a really high beta high volatility stock. Um then you go to lunch. Uh you come back from lunch and you're sitting on either a really big profit or a really big loss. The key is that when you put that trade on initially is you don't give the account number. So, there's collusion with the options trader down on the floor, and there's also collusions with the uh compliance officer, who gets the biggest Christmas bonus every year, by the way, of any brokerage firm. The compliance officer

is the one with the big fruit basket at the end of the year because you've got to keep grease his palm pretty liberally. And so, you don't give that that account number when you put that trade on. You come back from lunch now, you're sitting there with either a huge loss or a huge gain. Now, if it's a huge gain, obviously it's easy to place a huge gain. You simply call a client and say, "I've got a huge gain I want to dump into your account." You know, wink wink. You owe me the kickback. And the client, of course, says, "Yeah, okay, that's cool." The usual then. Now, if it's a huge loss, it's also quite valuable because every corporation at the end of the quarter is looking for tax losses to minimize their taxes for the quarter. And this is called

corporate services. So, you call up the uh tax compliance guy at that company, huge company, big companies, and just say, "Hey, man, I've got this, you know, $5 million loss I need to place somewhere." And uh they say, "Great, you know, put it in my account." Therefore, they their tax uh have been diminished. And of course, there's a huge kickback. And uh so that's a look back trade. And of course, the commissions on this are huge. So, uh you can do this all day long. you can make hundreds of thousands of dollars in commissions a week every couple of weeks doing this. It's pretty easy. You know, that's that's that's an actual fraud. So, and then people say on Wall Street, they say there's derivatives, there's all these different they go into very arcane descriptions of

how to defraud people. And I just thought it would be interesting for folks to know how a retail stock broker in just a in a simple way commits a fairly simple fraud. I'm going to tie that into the bigger concept of reinventing money because um I worked in pre-sales at Capital Films. We used to sell films as uh Simon was on his chart there. He was talking about that's where crowdfunding started in pre-selling films which is what I used to do. And we made one of the films we financed was Rogue Trader about Nick Leon and how he took down Baron's Bank through what sounds like a look back trade gone horribly wrong. And um I wanted to however talk to you about the Hollywood dollar because this is a money that you

invented. It actually had a fiat exchange rate with a US dollar. So why don't you talk about that and then we'll go on to Bitcoin and crowdfunding. But talk about inventing this monetizing Hollywood celebrity or buzz and and how you came about inventing the Hollywood dollar and the Hollywood stock exchange and bonds and star bonds. Yeah. Because this is also your the technology you created there is still used today by the likes of Blackstone and JP Morgan to price derivatives on otherwise intangible things not i.e. not oil, not pork, not pork bellies, whatever. So they they they use that technology to price. It's patented technology. Patent number

5750176 if you want to look that up. US patent office for a virtual specialist. You invented this in 1994. Yeah. Okay. So tell us. So yeah, it's a virtual it's a virtual trading system for trading virtual securities with a virtual currency um on a virtual market. And yet it has since become the basis for what they call media derivatives or the advanced derivatives trading. They all reference this this patent and this technology. But when I after um in 1990 I kind of retired from my Wall Street job. So I went from 83 to 1990 and then it got so boring just ripping people off all day. There's no skill to it that I took off and I went to live in France and have some fun. So I spent about five

years in France and uh just kicking about having fun and then um my friend who had since become a big shot in Hollywood uh visited me and he bought an idea for a screenplay a treatment for a screenplay that he sold to Harvey Weinstein at Marramax. And so he said why don't you come to LA and produce this film. So I went to LA and they put that film in a turnaround which means that they essentially abandoned the film and I had nothing to do. So, I went back to my old Wall Street buddy and I said, "You know, this town, Los Angeles, is the boringest town in the world and nobody knows anything about you. I try to talk about the stock market and everyone's just like, "Duh, what money?

Duh." So, I said, "Why don't we create the Hollywood Stock Exchange? Well, it's just based on box office revenues. We'll make movies, the um this the stocks, we'll make the the stars, the bonds." And he said, "Okay, that's great." You put up a half a million dollars. And I went to an integrator called Cambridge Technology Partners and they spent they eventually spent over $40 million on this project. But uh we started off with half a million dollars. This is uh before web 2.0. Well before web 2.0 where you could just click and snap and post and you know you just take stuff off the shelf and create you know that environment you actually had to we had to create software from scratch. So um to trade a virtual security on a virtual exchange with a virtual money was a a

challenge to create price parody over thousands of these securities. So I created something called the virtual specialist technology which is uh the ability to u it's based on the Hollywood dollar which is the first digital or electronic dollar that the New York Times wrote about and the fully convertible into US dollars when we used to trade them on eBay for one to a million was the exchange rate and that we were working with and you never had problems like Bitcoin is now having where they're like you can't trade this for dollars. No, there was there was quite a novelty at that time and they didn't see it as a threat. The threat came from the MPAA that was uh felt threatened by the idea that we were controlling the marketing window of the movie industry because the movie

industry was all based on the opening weekend's box office grosses that they spend all the you know if a movie cost $100 million to make they spend a hundred million dollars on marketing and they try to get that opening window of first three days of opening to be big and then that is ancillary markets TV cable foreign so the hundred million or that huge marketing budget is all based on hype and perception. So the Hollywood stock exchange was saying, "Well, that next Tom Cruz movie that opens up in a year is actually worth based on this market, it's going to have a $90 million domestic run, which would be a disappointment for the studio, based on the market." And so the studios quickly figured out that this was going to eat

their lunch. and they eventually got on the board and they dismantled the company and we got into a huge protracted, you know, problems and they they basically pulled the plug on that the same way that they did with Kim.com in New Zealand. So basically you invented a stock market that had more volume than the the leading volumes exchange in the world. And it was because of this because I knew you had created the Hollywood dollar that when John Matonus reached out to me in um like late 2010, early 2011 saying he was going to be in Paris where we made Kaiser Report and he said he was explaining about this thing called Bitcoin and all I could figure

out was that it was a digital currency. So I said, "Max, some guy is the we're having this guest on who's going to talk about a new digital currency and you know about digital currency, but when you did the interview, you you saw the process of discovery that you were like this isn't." Yeah. At first, I thought it was just another kind of ripoff of my technology uh as there had been many like the policy analysis market by John Po Dexter in Washington created the terror futures market. the um uh another market in Ireland called Intrade was ex HSX employees ripping me off again uncredited and uh a few other ripoffs and I thought, "Oh, this sounds like another ripoff." Uh but then during the interview, the whole beauty of

cryptocurrency dawned because the thing about a virtual currency is that it's a surrogate for fiat. It's a it's a fiat surrogate whereas crypto is a surrogate for gold. It truly is. It's an actual surrogate for gold and that it's remarkable and so it is such a beautiful the ideas behind it are actually aesthetically stunning and a lot of people who got into the first year of Bitcoin actually had mental breakdowns. It was so beautiful. It was like you're seeing you know some of the most remarkable art ever for the first time.

And if you talk to those people at those early years they had their eyes were you know bugeyed. one being Charlie Shrem who I I believe is completely and unfairly treated by uh in this industry, regulators etc. but he was somebody who was knocked out by the beauty of it and it is one of the most beautifully architected man-made creations in history and um that's become I think more and more clear but during the John Matonis interview yes we I I realize that this was something and well just like when you created something which on the surface like Hollywood soccer chains seemed like a game people used to say it was a game but you said it was deadly serious it was like a market and when we

aired that interview with John Matonas the reaction was very surprisingly negative. There was a very violent reaction from mostly from gold bugs I might say but it was a there was a huge reaction against it which only encouraged us to research it more to see what were people were so afraid of the gold bugs and the libertarians at first hated it now they all love it now they realize it's except for professor ficeta who doesn't like bitcoin you know who try to get him um but they they've kind of come around and there was a hugely negative reaction to it uh across all all especially in the place like Britain where the there there are you know the British are yeah yeah

property price well they're property speculators and they're essentially subjects to the queen they're not they're not free in the sense that well what that's what you do notice from a lot a lot of things online is like people prefer to be subjects wherever they are they don't even need to be in uh living under a monarchy they like they prefer like a you know a top down approach they prefer JP Morgan to control lot easier to be to be in prison to be a slave. This is the thing. But um then we now you know with Hollywood Stock Exchange part of your patent actually talks about basically what Kickstarter became. You were talking about pre-elling the ticket pre-selling it and and financing project this way.

This is the original business plan all back into let's get a million users and then sell them a ticket in advance to fund a movie. So, um, that was that was the the business plan I submitted. But, um, but the MPA was not having anything to do with that. They they shut it down because it was too much of a threat to their marketing, their model. And the MPAA is the most powerful, one of the most powerful lobbies, second only to the defense industry in America. And you you if you want to go to jail real fast, you would defy uh Chris Dodd in the Motion Picture Association of America as Kim.com. They the MPAA got the futures market member. So Caner Fitzgerald bought Hollywood Stock Exchange, bought the technology and they tried to launch

a real uh futures market out of Chicago and it got shut down by they spent $20 million. They were going to do a cash market, launch it in Chicago. And at the the 11th hour, Chris Dodd, who was then a senator, as part of the DoddFrank bill, added into the legislation, outlawing box office futures, became outlawed in America, which is remarkable because they're allowing Bitcoin futures now via Chicago. There's the only industry in America that's protected in this way that you cannot every other industry in America has a futures business that can move the price but the Hollywood industry is protected against futures by this law and then shortly thereafter Chris Dodd was made the head of the MPAA.

uh more corruption there and uh so they they outlaw what it but they did interestingly enough there was a this became known as the prediction market industry after I created all this and there was one called hubdub by a guy named Eckles I think Nigel Eckles Nigel Eckles and he had one called Hubdub and it wasn't working he then started something called FanDuel which uh is now a billiond dollar industry billion dollar company which is a daily sports betting fantasy betting, but um there was an exemption in the Chris Dodd bill that carved out for sports. So they uh they and this guy was a former consultant I think a booze Allen. Okay. Well, we have to u throw

this out to the audience. Yeah. But questions reinventing money because I did get a lot of questions from the people when I was out there about how how to go about reinventing doing this. Throw it out. Do you want to throw it, Max? You want to throw it? Do I get to throw it? Oh, great. This is cool, man. Great. Let's see how way in the back. Way in the back. Way in the back. Put your hand up, baby. Put it up. Nobody. What's up, man? Okay, here we go. Here. Close. Oh, he never played baseball. I did. I used to be on the baseball team.

I have a repetitive stress. He's a hockey from from watching the price of my stocks collapse. It can't be that loud. What? Is it working? Yeah, it's working. Great. Next, Stacy. Uh, huge fan of the show. Uh, I would like to to to say to you, uh, my question is, uh, on the technical side of Bitcoin. I was wondering, Max, what's your take on the current uh block size debate that's uh engulfing the Bitcoin sphere? Oh, yeah. Well, I was talking to Tony Galipia about this who runs uh Bit Pay and um I'm in the camp that thinks it's basically non-event in many ways. I know

that there's this conspiracy theory out there that there's the takeover. Um but I think the protocol will withstand this challenge. So, I'm not overly excited by it. I don't understand enough about the whole I know minors don't like it. So, uh I think therefore it won't happen. So, yeah, minor don't like it, but I think uh it's a it's a consensus protocol. So, if there's no consensus to take it over um you know, why why mess with something? It was, you know, I mean, there's I I think that when bit Bitcoin first hit, all the really smart people in San Francisco and Silicon Valley completely missed it. And because they want to

sound like they're not idiots, they came back and said, "Oh, Bitcoin sucks, but there's something called the blockchain." And we invented that. And we're still smart as smart as you thought we were two years ago. But that's like saying, "I love grilled cheese sandwiches, but I hate cheese." Right? So they're they're just talking out of their bottoms and uh there's a pendulum is swinging back to Bitcoin now away from proprietary blockchain idiocy banking nonsense. Yeah, Max, Bitcoin's cheap, but two whatever it is 213 is cheap. You you speak about your fraud that you committed as if it was nothing. Yeah. Um I don't know much about your personal life. Did you suffer any consequences

from that or? No. The business model of Wall Street is fraud. And the business model is that we keep 90 cents of every fraud dollar we make. That's the stated model. That's the model that the justice the former attorney general of America said that Wall Street is beyond prosecution. Will never prosecute Wall Street. They can do whatever they want. They've legalized criminality. the um back to the Clinton, they repealed GlassSteagall that was saying I love fraud. They turned the digital millennium uh the the um the act of 2010 where they essentially made derivatives trading which was formerly gambling.

They said no no this is actually investment uh I forget the total name of this bill that's like saying we love fraud. Wall Street is fraud. America is fraud. The world is fraud. Banks are fraud. Central banks are fraud. We live in an era of fraud. It's all based on fraud and they get a percentage of the fraud. That's the business model. To suggest that there is any moral or ethical aspect to anything that's going on now is to be completely naive about the fact that we live in an era dominated by financial terrorists. Terrorists, terrorists, jihadis of banking. They're here to kill you and themselves. They don't care because they're trained at madrasas called Princeton, Harvard, and Yale. They believe in an ideology, not the Quran, but Adam Smith, that they completely misread and interpret as something to

justify their blowing themselves up. And the cost of terrorism is cheap. 9/11 only cost $500,000. The ability to borrow money and take over a company by Warren Buffett is zero. He's borrowing money at zero. He's taking all those jobs away. He's creating economic destruction because of financial terrorism. And that's an era that we live in today. Why are we going to stop it? There's only one way to stop it. Raise interest rates right now. Make the cost of terrorism too high. Do it today. If you don't, you're a [ __ ] terrorist. Johnny is a terrorist. Mario Draggy's a terrorist. The Central Bank of Japan is a terrorist. These are the real terrorists. Not the immigrants, not the people dying in the water.

[Music] Hello. Here comes a question. Well, a small question. Max, I mined I mined a few Mex coins. Oh, here I am. I mined a few mexcoins at the time. What I should do with them? Max, so what what was going on? Uh, it's called uh curiosity and knowing what you're talking about. So, we had been talking about Bitcoin uh for about three years and then along comes suddenly people were tweeting me, have you heard about this coin or that coin?

And I was like, what are all these other coins? And um uh so we had done an episode about some of these altcoins coming up and we were contacted by some students at the University of Bristol where a well-known um cryptographer teaches and was their teacher was their professor and he said uh I'll show you how to create a coin and we'll do it live on television. So I was like okay show me and it was actually well it it's actually it was a rather longer process than I thought. There were many questions how many um coins you want in creation, what sort of uh algorithm, what sort of hashing, what sort of all this stuff. So I so I went through the

physical process myself and anybody here can actually go and do it themselves to create your own coin. It doesn't mean anybody will use it, but you know create your own coin to see what the process was. So I I wanted to show the audience the process of making a coin and what went into these altcoins and what differentiated one from the other. So it helped me as a non coder and tech person to understand what was actually different between each of these altcoins. So yeah, that was that process. Well, it helped me mining. But what's that? It helped me how to mine coins. It taught taught you how to mine.

Yeah. But well, just keep them. You have to do it to uh figure out. You have to just do it to learn. That's the best way. I think that's fine. So I keep them and just keep them. Have you started mining other coins since? No. No. Or should I? That's interesting. Fair enough. Next. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Hello. Okay. Uh first of all, hi Max and Stacy. I'm a huge fan of the show. Hi.

Um when I look at uh uh um regulators or even judges, when I see if they if they put on new new uh legislation like the Washington uh Washington bill, it shows that they do not understand the technology but still they are able to put up uh legislations. Um are you afraid that um or at least I am afraid that um they might put up uh new legislation that will you know um get us behind in in the Bitcoin scene. I mean I think that's the reason why uh Simon Dixon uh moved to to Hong Kong to have more you know more more freedom in that

space. So yeah. Well, I mean, just as Max was explaining about the Frank Dodd bill having a weird carve out for futures markets only in Hollywood box office futures, but then given an exemption to sports, it's uh you know, they can possibly try to uh say only J the one JP Morgan Goldman Sachs, their their specific private blockchain will only be the legitimate one. And uh but I don't think that will work. Yeah. Well, I think the adoption rate of Bitcoin has been driven in large part by some of these crises. So when the crisis in u Cyprus hit, you had a huge adoption rate. Price did did very well and um we're about to enter into another period of of very um unstable global finance

and banking rumors that Deutsche Bank which is has the largest derivatives book in the world with close to 150 trillion could go the way of Lehman. So you have this huge potential again and the cryptologology and the the protocol is ready to accept this bulge of cash as it comes rolling in as is the gold market and the silver market. So I think that we'll see the I've thought the adoption has been driven by crisis not by the cool factor.

Great. There's room left for one final snappy powerful question. Uh, who still dares to ask Max a question? One more left here. A lady. Here you go. Hi. So, um, pretty cool that you talk about like the pre-cryptographic area uh or era, sorry, in 1996. So I heard also something about this era from just another guy and he talked about that there was this pre-cryptographic digital money um that was created in an artistic scene and no well I'm pretty much interested in that kind of correlation.

So my question is actually do you or did you um experience some form of creativity or artistic scene when you did or if not do you see any creativity form of involved with that time or now? Um it's interesting crossover with the art world because um just reading recently about how a lot of artists are going the route of the startup where they are their art is they're trying to monetize their art in a way that we're seeing in in the startup world and as part of that I think crypto is makes that very um easy. Um, when we just

moved to London recently from Paris, um, Stacy put on the wall an artwork I created back in 2011, which was some cutouts I had done from magazines. And then I was overlaying that with some images. And in the image was a Mount Gox uh, Bitcoin address, which I totally had forgotten about, but I was using these addresses as part of visual art that I was creating at that time just for fun. Um because yeah also with in terms of the art back in the pre-cryptographic age is um with your Hollywood sock exchange you did have Dr. Zeros who did who did print the Hollywood dollar right I mean you had all these characters that were followed and were actually like

cartoon characters that people followed and listened to and they would pronounce make pronouncements there anthropomorphize various aspects of banking so there was max broker mac daddy was a banker Dr. Zuros was the central banker and misinformation was the analyst. So kind of following in um you can find those characters still online. Walt Disney's kind of tradition a bit. So right. Well guys, uh thank you so much. Is there something sort of a final message you want to give away to the audience before they go home? Maybe something to to reflect on. No, I like the fact that it's at Arasmus and you know you're you're free to choose, you're free to invent, you're free to do your own

thing. So, I think that's a good thanks to Paul who's been a big supporter of ours for years and managed to do a great event. Right. Well, thanks guys. Uh [Music]