eth_multicall Meeting, May 13, 2024

eth_multicall and eth_simulate Meetings · 13 May 2024 · 6:51

A meeting of the developers working on eth_multicall and its successor eth_simulate, held on 13 May 2024. Client and tooling teams compare implementations and work on the specification for simulating transactions.

Topics

From eth_multicall and eth_simulate Meetings, hosted by Ethereum Foundation.

Transcript

so uh I'll begin uh We've shipped dat image that you've tested we are doing the reviews reviews are in progress one was done already and another one is ongoing by look and we've got a few issues on trailer from Kari and we are fixing them and I think the updated image will land tomorrow so I think by tomorrow you'll get an updated docum iment that will be where the trailer issues will be fixed and the results of the first review will be in and also we'll update the uh the master Branch contents as

well M that's it with us hey um yeah as for me I um implemented um the new the new strategy without Phantom blocks um I I was just working on publishing a new Docker image that works for amd64 so uh I'm going to push one within within the hour uh but yeah I haven't gotone around to to checking the the errors that

kilari reported but those were from before the Phantom block change so I'm actually curious if like how things are going now that um we have this update yeah I need to run the test again when both are running phant non Phantom blocks and then see how how the E mind and get are are they still agreeing on each other or not do we have anything else to discuss I don't think there's anything

new for a while T is NE mind still planning on going into pushing into Master soon uh yeah basically we'll get the second review from lucash we'll do the fixes on top of that review and after this fixes will land we'll be able to push it to master here I was worrying about that because after that then I'm sure there there will be still some discrepan if you get the ne mind but then I'm not sure how how big deal that is but if someone will start to use them it Sim like right away

way and then there might be things arise that it's different from get and N mind like we haven't been able to test that hash differences for for example because we have been keeping changing stuff um I would say don't worry we we won't announce it or even if we will we will say it's still in in development like in a beta stage so P just make come and that's it yeah I'm fine if it's advertised that it's a still then it sounds good but yeah then I find that's in the main branch but I hope people know that it's in the beta and don't expect it to work completely everywhere I don't know what the status

for get on that if they're planning on pushing it to master at the same time or later um I would like [Music] to B basically make sure that spec is final and it's working before I ask for the others to merge it so I would I would wait a bit more okay do have anything else how is the testing going what's the

status I was late a bit oh I added quite many test that n might test couple OFA cases for the get that we need to be fixed and then quite many for neet mind but then as the net mind is progressing then we sometimes find bugs in the G because then there's discrepancies and then all not all of those bugs are in nether Minds so that's why I have been hoping that the nether mind and get are of getting closer and closer to each other so it's easier to test them because I can can easily see that the output are different but I feel that there's still a lot cases where the neet mind is

not that that we know it's different results from the get so I'm hoping that those will get get fixed yeah we'll fix and update an image soon yeah so after those are fixed then I I run it again and then I can report new because there were quite many bucks but I think some of them were cost by one of the same issue so I'm hopefully that when that one is solved then it a lot test will pass after that but if you running my test shoot then you should see right away which your fixed un fixed which

are yeah I see also Dem I guess we don't have anything else CA dropped off nothing from me okay talk to you next week then yep see you later see yeah bye bye