The ECB, central bank power and community banks
De Week van Bitcoin · 4 Jul 2020 · 54:27
Richard Werner, professor of banking and finance and author of Princes of the Yen, talks with Paul Buitink about central banks and the European Central Bank. Werner argues that central banks create boom and bust cycles on purpose, that the quantity of credit rather than interest rates is the key policy tool, and that about 4,800 banks have disappeared in the eurozone since the ECB began. He describes his project to set up not-for-profit community banks in the UK, starting with the Hampshire Community Bank, and the regulatory progress so far.
Speakers
Topics
From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.
Transcript
hello everybody my name is Paul Burton and today I'm going to have a conversation with Professor of banking finance Richard Werner who wrote the number one bestseller in Japan princess of the N he has also developed the theory of money creation called quantity theory of credit he is also the first economist to empirically prove commercial banks do indeed create money out of thin air when they issue a loan we're going to talk about the way central banks and governments are managing the economic crisis particularly ECB well also definitely I'm going to talk about central bank and digital currencies I Richard welcome thank you very much for having me and I'm glad it's finally worked out yeah yeah it took us a few years so it took it to come to your date but this weekend we made it work so very very glad with
that and first a bit more about your background what are you currently up to there's a few things obviously as a university professor there's a lot of tasks there online teaching for instance and writing papers to be published in academic journals which is a very slow process but there are also various projects I'm leading the project established not-for-profit local community banks in the UK starting at the Hampshire Community Bank we've just had our challenge session with the UK regulators the Prudential Regulation Authority in the financial conduct authority and passed it so we're moving a step closer to getting our
authorization which is very exciting and of course there's others have just launched a new journal academic journal called the journal of banking finance and sustainable development you can see that on the webpage the publisher is called College Press so college press dot o-r-g dot UK and the journals on there that's just gone out at this week actually and what else I mean there's so many projects running interesting as we go on yeah especially this is this local bank initiative I'm look forward to hearing all the diesels about that
because that's actually one of the one of the main topic I I wanted to address with you and I see on Twitter you've been very critical on central bank policies especially issue B policies that over time have led to the disappearance of many smaller banks so could you elaborate a bit more on what exactly is it that you don't like about ECB policy well that's quite a few things but let's start with the the anti small bank or anti bank policies essentially since the ECB was created and started business 20 years ago since then 4,800 banks have disappeared in the
eurozone alone and that is under the ECB's policy and now I'm a firm believer and fan of well one thing Paul Samuelson did and it's probably the only thing I like and it's called his theory of revealed preference in a nutshell don't believe what what people say they're doing and why they're doing things they're doing they may not even know properly and in words or in terms of you know intellectual concept themselves watch what they're doing that actions reveal what they're doing of course
that's you know you could also have a Christian interpretation you know Jesus said by the fruits of the tree you will see is it a good tree or a battery the result matters so actions deeds and the results and because anyone in the markets is always looking at you know what is the actual action you know you can say so many things there's so much hot air and the financial markets being produced by people what are the actions and use that principle to analyze central banks and really we should start by looking at their fundamental claim central bank's always tell us what's their goal what are they trying to do while we're here
to achieve stability stability of prices stability of the economy stability of growth stability of currency stability there's stability that is all stability stability some speeches we had did word counts and the time a number of times they mention the word stability quite amazing anyway now look at the fruits look at the result look at the actions what is the revealed preference the revealed preference is quite the opposite stability is exactly what we're not getting from central bank's we're getting we're getting cycles business cycles and in fact the time of mere business cycles has also passed when the
era of boom bust cycles being created by central banks the and and at the same time you see have to be aware these central banks they had they've become extremely powerful in the last 50 years they became the most powerful actors and of course everyone in financial markets is aware of that and but it's interesting from a political economy perspective they formally become so powerful as never before in history in human history and and they can do what they want now they may sometimes say oh we're doing this because the government is telling us to do well if they choose to but they don't have to and often they will say no we're not doing this
so again reveal preference you know what they're doing is what they want because this is particularly true for central banks they have so many options they've so many tools they can invent new tools now so we've got these very powerful players and the ECB is the most independent and most unaccountable central bank and in the world not necessarily in history because as I wrote in my book princes of the yen and that was in 2003 I did an analysis of the structure of the ECB and how it's designed and its powers and I can you did that it was not modeled on the Bundesbank
that was the official story let's the Frankfurt the German the German central bank is very successful that's ECB is just a success it's just a bigger sort of bundesbank and well I came to the opposite conclusion what made the Bundesbank successful they took away and what the bonus banks predecessor highly unsuccessful predecessor the Geiss bank what made their ice Bank the most disastrous central bank in the world that's what they reintroduced in the ECB so the ECB is not just the continuation of the bonus Bank is actually the revived an iceberg which is the title of the
chapter in Princes of the yen and that's published in 2003 and I predicted that for these in these reasons you know read the details I expect the ECB to follow in the footsteps of the rice Bank totally unaccountable and power corrupts absolute power corrupts absolutely and central bankers maximize their power if they create cycles and it will create a bank credit driven acid bubble acid bubbles in the eurozone and which lead to banking crises and large-scale unemployment massive recessions and of course I mean it was published 2003 but Freddy from 2004 the ECB started to implement this 20 30 % credit growth and Ireland Portugal Spain and Greece huge
credit booms busts and then of course large-scale unemployment 50 percent youth unemployment so and and what is the what is the main objective damaged in the show you say they create cycles and what is what is what they want to achieve with those cycles then I started out discovering this and you know initially I didn't know anything about this and I had the usual you know fairly naive view that you have when you study economics at the University at LSE Oxford all the mainstream stuff but I was then in Japan for years and I realized we're just looking at reality well this is quite different what's happening here is very different from these theories and in a nutshell what I discovered and
documented in every detail from different angles in the book princes of the yin is that the Japanese central bank created this huge acid bubble and very long recession intentionally in order to achieve its actually goals that it had previously made known and I pulled all that together so there's not with hindsight just saying okay you know just a new interpretation of the data with hindsight no actually you could go back and you could see that they had actually key people had said this and then you follow the data and follow their actions and the key policy tools which is all about what is the key
policy tool of central bank's it's not interest rates interest rates is the price of money and I did also an empirical analysis of that they always say that lower race lead to higher growth higher race lead to lower growth and the UM you know the economy follows these interest rate policies empirically there's absolutely no evidence for this whatsoever the reality is that interest rates follow growth and they're positively correlated so interest rates are not the key monetary policy tool of a central bank like it's not even possible what is it it's the quantity of credit creation and this is but it's and with that policy you could you could see what they were doing and so the Bank of Japan was creating this massive acid
bubble and then it was tightening and creating this massive recession why the goal was as they had declared actually before all this happened and that's you know I used that as sub tablet of the book the structural transformation of the economy which was essentially a US plan and the Bank of Japan was their agent in Japan and to implement this because they the Bank of Japan plan was almost verbatim the same as what the Americans have been demanding in the negotiation with Japan structural impairment initiative Japan has to change we need to you know and what was the story there well because obviously pan was too successful Japan was highly successful and the Americas didn't like
it that wasn't the plan so they had to change officially the Americans were advising the Japanese in the 70s and 80s on how to improve their economy well Japan was doing so well and did they really need American advice and how to improve the economy oh you you are quite inefficient and this is all this you know you need to deregulate liberalize and privatize and then you get even more efficient oh really is that really what America wants it I don't think so of course the goal was to destroy the Japanese post-war high-growth system and not to have to deal with this threat anymore of course the other threat this
created was that other countries would adopt the model and other countries did adopt the model early on it was Taiwan and Korea that adopted this and they you know just exactly the same thing happen of course and but then more in the in the 70s and 80s increasingly developing countries are saying hey do we really have to adopt this IMF World Bank policy advice it's really not leading us anywhere good and we've seen this this Japan and then Korea Taiwan they're doing something different shouldn't we perhaps do that oh no no you don't know that doesn't work it's very inefficient and of course that's the other reason why they needed to destroy the Japanese model and so they see you're saying like
central banks have a certain goal in mind and and in order to to achieve that goal sometimes a crisis is needed yes of course a crisis yeah I mean how can America persuade and then of course it was acting through the Bank of Japan but but also partly it was open in these political negotiations trade negotiations which concluded Japan needed to change its economic structure the you know everything really and and how can America justify this logic like we were doing this to help Japan to make Japan even more successful you know it's just totally implausible the truth was is to destroy the high growth successful
system and there's no better way to do this than to introduce the IMF World Bank advice they had been given to developing countries for the last half-century over the last 70 years namely to deregulate liberalize and privatize and wipe out any domestic industries by totally opening up very early on and essentially you get bought up and taken over by foreign interests so that's what Japan was supposed to do and of course after going and going back to ECB what how could you draw the parallel then to what's happening over the past 20 years with with the ECB and the policies they have implemented exactly actually in its in Princes of the yen I already show that this Asian
crisis was also run by the central banks the Bank of Thailand Korea Indonesia which did the same thing and the goal was again structural transformation to open up these economies for Western interests and essentially get rid of the high-growth successful system and give it a bad reputation and this is what many people think today well this East Asian Highgrove didn't really work did it and so that was that was the goal there and what about Europe well essentially the ECB followed the Bank of Japan plot in in great detail and partly this this very similar goals and partly of course
transferred to Europe this there were some different concrete goals of this structural transformation that they had in mind and the similarity is their neoliberal agenda of deregulation liberalization privatization which allows essentially the central bank to be the key Asian and part of these reforms is always to make the central bank independent which the central bankers of course like the Bank of Japan when it created the bubble and then bursted and started the recession it was still not independent so it had to work by stealth it worked because of the this false economics which made most people blind to what's really happening and central banks have been doing a lot to support this false economics and their
research departments I mean they are the biggest employer of economists in the world and they produce very misleading economics in their research departments is some of course some people they're very you know well-meaning and they're you know young you know graduates and they get hired and they think they're doing the right thing but it's very easy then to get manipulated into this new classical fiction economics using the deductive methodology with hypothetical axiomatic approach you can come up with anything really on that basis and so this central bank research was used to to propagate this and in Europe and this this neoliberal agenda was also a goal
of the central banks of course you know ECB has been pushing that deregulation story and so on its own but at the same time you say too much regulation is currently a problem and killing and small banks and actually benefiting the big bang sighs well but that's the irony see this is the contradiction that you're not supposed to notice these contradictions so central banks say we need deregulation that was a privatization but what about the central banks as regulators were you introducing a 2008 massive new regulations killing banks so it's well it's the same institution saying on the one hand no labor market all needs to be deregulate unions no it's very very bad we need to get rid of them and we don't need to
have regulation but at the same time the central banks because they're bank regulators they're introducing massive amounts of regulation and unprofessional and I've been trying to keep up it's just extraordinary the amounts of and these documents that they create his new bank regulation is not the 600 pages of EU bank regulate is another you know 550 pages and each small bank is supposed to not only know this and understand it but constantly implement this and as constant every year there's new stack of new rules and regulations it's just unbelievable of course the small banks have to give up yeah so really one of the reasons is of over 5,000 banks have disappeared because of the stifling and
ever-increasing yet Basel 1 to infinity yeah they just can't afford it they need to hide too many people just to keep up with these regulations and complies in the report unbelievable reporting well the small banks were never the problem they didn't create the banking crisis you know everybody we needed we needed smaller banks everyone after 28 said too big to fail that's the problem we need smaller banks and 12 years later we only have bigger banks exactly because the reality is the central bankers as bureaucracies they're big and they like to you know big players want to play with the big boys they actually do like to just speak with Goldman Sachs people and Blackrock and and so on the biggest institutions that's sort of their level small banks
that you know they're too arrogant is that to actually you know that's too small tiny we don't want to deal with them because the other factor that there's been killing banks small banks in particular are the interest rate policies now I already mentioned interest rates are not really the key monetary policy tool for the economy but they are a tool to influence the banking system and they have been used systematically as a tool to hurt banks the profitability of banks of course it's very much a bending precisely under interest rate level yes and also the yield curve you see if you flatten the yield curve and push it down to zero or have even an inverted yield curve that means no future for banks and you're killing them then then the smaller ones
are forced to merge with bigger ones they get taken over and then we get more and more mean the banks become bigger and bigger and fewer and fewer banks we get this really bad banking system but let's just compare actually you compare the UK which shows us the future of banking systems there's five big banks and more or less nothing else in Holland we have three okay so yeah and a few smaller ones is also very similar but compared to Germany where there's still over 1,700 banks and the majority of them are not-for-profit local community banks but of course you know we're
witnessing the last days for these because I mean they've been under so much pressure it's amazing they're still they're still there but so 70% of deposits in Germany are with these not-for-profit local community banks UK style high street banks which in the UK are over were close to 90 percent of bank deposits in Germany are only 13 percent of bank deposits and 70 percent are with these 1,500 not-for-profit community banks but of course their number has been falling every year because of these problems now what what does this create well there's there's two great benefits of the
already there's more benefits but the key to benefits are when you have a problem like a crisis or a shock to the system which one is actually a more able to to withstand the shock the bigger boys hosted rated system with the big banks or the ones with diversified many local many many local banks actually for shocks the diverse audience yeah he's the one that is resilient that's the right way exactly thank you the resilient system is the one that's decentralized and when the 2008 shock happened in Germany there wasn't even a proper recession unemployment essentially didn't right it didn't rise because it was mostly Germany's the bank uses mostly small banks they were not
involved in this crisis and they continued to lend to SMEs and that's the second point why do you long as bankers in Germany all this with everything thanks Dale they're no they're not local bags I'm not talking Ilan's banks they're big banks okay because they invested in all these yes and they went trust as as the other big banks like grace the bankers disappeared and various London spanglish where these are the big banks I'm talking about the 1,500 very small local banks like folks Bank life isin bank and SH Bacchus and punk you know these local they is nothing to deal with all the regulation and apparently they are able to doesn't that contradict in your earlier point that it's difficult or impossible for small banks to survive
the ECB regime Notah Begay speak to any of these it is very hard for them to survive and as I said it's amazing that they have survived but they've been struggling and I've been in touch with them I've like spent almost three years at one doing a you know as a professor doing an intern with a bank on the board level going to all their board meetings and and formally I was the also participating in their credit decisions there was deputy head of the corporate loan department I which is great I mean just you is so interesting and I learned so much but and also went to all their association meetings where they meet with all the cop you know the the cooperative banks regular meetings and there they've all
been saying you know what this is the last few years we can't survive this much longer you know Grayson they have been surviving to the extent that they have because they're so well organized in the system is such a strong system that it's taken so far 12 years for the ECB to to crush them and they haven't quite crushed them but it's now last stage and so perhaps I can make my peers and there be there be gone I can also people are willing to pay a little bit more perhaps to make use of those banks and in order to support those banks is that also true yes you EE that's important for people to realize that's able to support these banks and ultimately though if the central bank is
against them in their central bank has been against them then it just the future does look dire but just to complete one more point so the other factor that makes a system as decentralized as many small local banks attractive is of course that's you know is for for the users of the banking system because banks should just be a utility that provides good service that it it does that job whereas the big bang's don't now there's a fundamental rule in banking big banks want to do big deals with big players they lend to big companies big banks don't really want to deal with small firms but who's the main
employer that's true for for Germany for the UK for the US for Japan it is SMEs SMEs are usually the employer of between 66 percent of total employment in the UK where they've been suffer ringing for a long time that's why it's a lower number to something like 75% in Germany or even 80% in Japan and the nail is the same thing they called the engine of the economy always yes and they are they are now and and look at Germany I mean German economy has been quite successful for the last 200 years and the SME sector really has been a key engine of that just look at the exports
of course exports is is a good expression of competitiveness and a big percentage of German exports are due to small family-owned firms with names that you've never heard of but their global market leader in their narrow niche and they export across the whole world how is that possible this is not true for the UK absolutely not what's the difference well the difference is here we have a concentrated banking system consisting of these five big banks 90% of deposits there and they don't lend to SMEs and that's that's well studied and research and every two three years we'll get another banking commission report on the problems of the UK banking system I like
this one the Colwyn Commission report proclaimed that after study and interviews and and research conclusion the problem is that the big five dominate banking in the UK they only lend to the big firms they don't lend to SMEs and they don't give long term loans only short-term loans so there's a big credit supply problem for small firms : Commission and this was publicized in 1918 rinse and repeat Hoover essentially exactly over century ago but nothing was ever done about this well the alternative is of course the German system where you have many small local banks and who do they lend to small local firms but the only banks
they will ever lend at the risk of sounding stupid but the ECB did provides for more than 1.3 trillion in loans to banks also with an incentive for them to lend out to SME right they could even get an interest yes back they get money for free if they would lend out to SME yes yeah you see is that a good policy - well the same has happened in the UK the government has tried because the problem is recognized so they've tried to bribe banks and they have this funding for lending scheme which is what the ECB was looking at when it introduced its own scheme actually its first done here in the UK and essentially it doesn't work you can even bribe the big banks they will still not lend to SMEs it's just not worth their while I mean it's quite
obvious you know if you're a big bank balance sheet of you know 2000 billion pounds and you want to grow because you're a shareholder owned by 5% I mean you need to increase your balance sheet by billions double-digit billions 50 billion so what what do you what do you do for that I mean if you actually want to lend to SMEs and that's one thing you could do that and you need millions and millions of 20,000 pound size loans and each time you have to do this analysis credit analysis check their usage of the funds is you know what are they doing and so on
but it turns out that that cost and that time is exactly the same whether you give out a 20,000 pound loan or 200 million loan I wish you were trying to automate the whole process and and some of these fintechs are actually owned by the bigger banks so they're trying to find a way to to make it possible to lend soon as me in a very cost efficient and easy way well you don't think that's that's going to make any difference no but but frustrate just to completely your earlier question so the irony is that you know that the ECB has been saying we want to encourage the banks to lend to SMEs and and we're bribing them you know by these programs but it's not
working because even the bribe is not big enough in the system and policy framework the ECB has created which is a flat yield curve or inverse you curve negative interest rates this lending is not profitable on the one hand but on the other hand also you're killing banks you're killing banks and they get big and big and the fewer banks you have and the big the banks are the less they're gonna lend to SMEs and that's what the ECB has been doing now for over a decade and therefore but just think we're able to rise you know increase lending it's just not gonna work the real problem is this systemic problem of the ECB is positive sorry but if they're golden too because it's you started the conversation with saying
that ECB has an anti Bank policy and then we talked about the small banks okay slowly but surely the small banks are disappearing they're either bold or they merge or they stop so we have a few big banks left in the UK it's five dominating the landscape here in Holland we have three big banks I think 80% of the deposits I believe so but what is then the next step is is it the ECB's goals to eventually do away with things at all or do you think they want to keep a few big banks in the end well yeah maybe it's time to talk about the end game what is the end game and I know you're 40 minutes over halfway so it's - yeah well to understand the end game and of course this is also what what what's
happening in in the eurozone with the ECB is the central banks are looking to compete against their regulated now just reflect on what's happening the central bankers are regulators of banks and the ECB has even become more and more powerful and being a regulator by the way I should add one thing I've been warning for four years one reason why central banks haven't why center banks and this habit of creating crises crisis after crisis because we're rewarding them after each crisis we make them more
powerful so we have the problem of regulatory moral hazard which is that the regulator's have an incentive to have a regulatory problem at crisis because each time we say oh we have a crisis what's the solution let's give more power to the regulators and this was actually a reason well let's get into out of the reckless you know because this was the reason I get into in these things in the first place because after the crisis which I thought was primarily also because of low interest rates and central bank policies that was highly surprised naive as I was that central banks were rewarded with even more power to create yet the next crisis so I totally see your point there
exactly and so this is happening so the ECB has been given more regulatory powers and I'd be warning of that before the crisis and then they they they were not they were so shameless to ask for more powers the ECB said and they gave very misleading representations even to the European Parliament that oh this crisis we have in Ireland Portugal Spain and Greece well it's because we didn't have enough powers as regulators it's not true in Ireland the central bank was the regulator and that is part and parcel of the ECB system has always been in Spain who was the bank regulators the central bank so it was absolutely not true and of course the single biggest impact on bank performance is the central bank's activities and so that
there's no way the ECB can denies responsibility but that's what it what it did oh it wasn't asked it was just bad banks doing these things you know I'm a critic of banks of the big banks and the wrong type of banking but I've always emphasised that like the 2008 crisis we should not blame the banks not even the bankers of course you get these excesses and criminal activities but now don't don't blame the players blame the game right it is the regulator's what did we tell the facts do you guys go out and maximize profits and that's all they did so how can we blame them it's the regulars that set the incentive structure in the environment so so here we are so the ECB is now even more powerful as bank regulator and what are
the bank regulators now doing they're now coming out and they're saying and in fact in the background think about it if you just have this again revealed preference idea and and this is you know the regular is this central bank's being bureaucracies they want to constantly increase their power how else can they increase their power they're really so powerful are they gonna stop well apparently not they've come up with another way to yet increase their power another factor a whole factor into a new dimension namely and this is the currency's the regulator is saying well actually we think well of course they're not saying this like this in public so and we're giving you the straight talk
first and you recognize how they put this out to the public so the central banks are saying we're regulators of the banks we now think we should Richard compete with the regulated the banks that we regulate we as regulars should now step into the market and compete against we want to out-compete the banks of course talking about unfair competition talking about conflict of interest how on earth can can this be right when the regulator who's got power over all the other players and can kill them as it turns out considers himself as a competitor they want to step in and compete against the banks and it's a
historical moment in history and certainly financial economic history because so far the activities have been quite delineated the central banks are focused on one thing and the banks on another we're now seeing is the ripping up of this what Charles good at cause the concorde at this implicit agreement between the central banks and the banks each has their own area the central banks are now stepping straight into the turf of the banks why what is this competition about well they put it in terms of central bank digital currency in order to obfuscate what's happening because that sounds like okay it's just like paper money is what they issue and so now it's gonna be digital paper money
and so it's similar no it's very different and actually one is a Central Bank digital currency it is a current account at the central bank that's all it is that's really all it is yeah okay you can do this through some kind of distributed ledger technology or whatever I mean that's just the technology that's but in terms of economic reality and the accounting also shows this it is of course just a current account at the central bank but it's a retail current account its banking so in other words the central banks are saying we're to be a bank and anyone can bank with us how on earth are the banks that you know the normal private sector commercial banks how they gonna survive if the central bank with all the backing of the
state and all the regulatory powers the central bank has over its competitors is gonna step in and do this but Samba commercial banks have also always survived the cash problem as well means that central banks have always issued cash which is also competing with banks and they've been perfectly able to to compete with that as well so don't you think yes but that was the delineation that you know the the central banks have paper money cash but the digital currency is run by the banks you see that's the other series Asia a lot of people actually ask for this right Richard a lot of there's a popular support in many different countries for these types of initiatives and of course it really depends on on how they're
going to build it and under which conditions but for example in Hollands I know the people very well behind the own scale that are actually pushing for some sort of central bank digital currency and I believe they have the right intentions how would you how would you mind that then you think it's driven by something priced if the bureaucrats aren't the central planners aren't funding them directly or indirectly but it's it's mis-selling it's it's classical mis-selling it reminds you very much of what happened in the 1990s in the 1990s we were told by various players including the central planners but oh we need to we need to well I should say the other
way around what they actually were doing was they were abolishing the European currency in the 1990s they were preparing the abolition of the European currency and they were selling it cleverly as the introduction of the European currency now we have European currency and it's is the European currency that was market determined based on competitiveness and performance and the markets determined that is the European currency of course I'm talking about the deutsche mark and other countries started to join and peg themselves to the deutsche mark and became a block but it was all voluntary and based on market performance and central bank performance and the blooms
bank was a good central bank when it still was one I mean it's not it's a shadow of its former self now of course and then they told us oh we're gonna we're gonna introduce the European currency where actually they were abolishing the de facto European currency we had the d mark and introducing this euro which is a complete miss selling and the same thing is happening happening with central bank digital currency why because we have digital currency we are using digital currency every day it's bank transactions banks have digital currency they create 97% of the money supply which is digital currency three percent is central bank product paper now in most countries and 97 percent is digital currency produced by banks and that's
what we have but monetary reformers they argue like that we are new now too much depending on commercial banks and when we introduce central bank digital currency at least you reduce some of the dependency and that's it's a good thing at least that's what that's what they argue don't you agree with that and that you at least make the commercial banks less powerful in the system but they are not powerful in the system it's the central bank and doesn't it strike you as strange that these critics and these monetary reformers that criticize the system in order to improve it that they never hit upon the reality the whole thing is run by the central planners at the central banks and the power of the
center bank you give them no they never notice eyes the central bank's yeah well there's also a for example in Holland they once you create a new institution so they would give power to a new institution but of course powerful people will run that institution probably but you could also make sure that through procedures and representation that a new institution is actually run by the people instead of by the the central premise who currently have the power there's all sorts of different setups you could you could consider if you implement such a scene right well the the key dimension to keep in mind here is centralization versus decentralization always keep that in mind now and of course to analyze things
scientifically we have to look at empirical data the empirical data is not on the future because we don't have that yet it's on the past so what is the empirical data telling us about this question of monetary system centralization versus decentralization now we have the system that many central bankers today seem to favor we already had that in the past is the system the monetary system of the Soviet Union there was one bank one central bank and that one central bank was the only bank and that created all the money and centrally issued it it was also digital currency a lot of it some paper but mostly digital as well
and this system was a disaster it did not work very well now compare this to another very large country by population much larger that also had the same system as the Soviet system and as China the China initially had a soviet-style economy but in 1978 a new leader came to power in China Deng Xiaoping and he analyzed the situation and he concluded that the Soviet system is doomed to failure and that's of course dangerous he concluded for you know for the country and it's better to abandon this
system and instead he looked at other countries that had a more successful monetary system such as Japan and Germany and the US and he concluded well we need to decentralize banking and so when he came to power 1978 what what was the key one of the key things he introduced was he found it thousands of banks thousands of new banks local banks small banks regional banks specialized banks all across China and the rest is history that's how you get high economic growth America when it had high economic growth it had close to twenty thousand banks and and
how you get economic growth and as we said earlier that's also resilient you why grieve the money creations well you one more difference decentralization but it did but then if I follow your logic do you believe them that by introducing Central Bank digital currency for example in the eurozone the end result will be a1 Bank Soviets fell financial system where the ECB has gained all the power and all the other banks have disappeared even the big banks is that the end result of course there's no other there's no question about it in fact there's actually a study now just come out by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia saying just that that once we introduce central bank digital currency the banks will
disappear and they will either disappear through the political process that's what the monetary reformers like positive money want they want to abolish banking because once you take the power to create credit from banks they're not banks anymore so you know they're non banks because it was eggs to be intimately abolition they're not banks anymore what's your concrete money that's what makes banks differ that's what make banks banks so they want to abolish banks so either political process abolishing them or as we had in Switzerland this referendum the population decided to keep money creation decentralized and keep the decision-making decentralized and not centralized control in the hands of the central planners or the market will once
you introduce the regulator as a player that will create through market forces the same situation where all the other players will die out when we know them they don't forget history and will lead to another crisis in in the future because if we worth one bank left the central bank eventually there will also come crashing down as we've seen from the best so the central planners probably know that this debt experiment will end up eventually in disaster so that's not how they think that's how they think that you have to think that there's a theory called the theory of bureaucracy and which quite useful is from politics political economy and and that needs to be applied to central
bank's of course a bureaucracy wants to become ever more powerful so from the you point of the central planners the story is we need more power who's creating money oh it's the bank's we don't like that we want to be the monopoly we want to create all the money so let's start competing against the bank's and of course you know you see the central bank there's a crazy plan is quite old I mean they've been discussing this for over 10 years and therefore we should now that it's very clear what their plan is they've come out into the open we should review their past policies for the last ten years in this light because then we'll see that maybe they weren't actually
doing a good job as regulators maybe they're already biased by the fact that he wanted to kill banks because they're gonna join the fray and become competitors and and of course that's what what actually happened but it reveals that they were not doing a good job as regulators therefore why should we give them more power it's the same regulatory moral hazard bad regulation is being rewarded by giving them more powers there's not there's no question about this that so from a central bank's viewpoint they want to compete against banks and they know that the banks will disappear and of course they can help this disappearance in many ways and they've done this and they've done that huh yeah so they know that will get
power but in the end they also must realize that power eventually they cannot handle but that's not how central planners think central bankers do recognize there's risks but each time they will say well we can mitigate this risk how by increasing our control so you see once you have central bank digital currency we will abolish of course cash banks will be either disappeared or will be formally abolished so all the combination will be College and then how can we control things further well we will have negative interest rates of course and we can help ourselves from people's pockets then we can actually essentially usurp the Treasury Department's finance
departments there will be a takeover by the central bank of the government because and here's the other strand that we haven't mentioned yet which is all linked to this at the same time what's being propagated in the last 10 years is this idea of universal basic income now that's a very old idea it goes back over a century social reformers socialist campaigners had said there's a hundred years ago we need this whatever people's dividend or something like a people's salary universe basic income you know okay why is this idea which used to be radical communist socialist a hundred years ago suddenly now propagated by the billionaire class literally you've got
the billionaire families coming out and Zuckerberg and all these people ubi is a good idea we're supporting this idea and of course now with this kovat crisis and inverted commas all these trends are being accelerated whether sentiment is you can see or this basic income was essentially being paid out in the u.s. already or you know in in various ways being introduced now the idea is this essentially makes people totally dependent and the control of the system is increased and the universal basic income is essentially then this you know you get some credits in your central bank digital currency account with the central bank and it's all
centrally dished out the reward but also the punishment no more privacy about crises well we now have total control if there's some troublemakers will switch them off yeah we see what people are doing we see where they where they are what they're buying and selling or here's a critic of central bank's well sorry there's a technical problem with your digital currency so it's a bit like what we already see in China and with the social credit system and it's worse it's worse actually the Chinese to be fair to them they on the front of digital currency they thought about this apparently because what I realized when I studied this is that they've designed their central bank district currency in order to ensure that the great
innovation that things are being introduced forty years ago in China will continue in other words they're not going to harm the banks and they're a digital currency system is designed to work with the banks not against the banks so it's worthwhile for us to study that because that should be the model really and the social credit rating of course you know that's maybe something it's also pian yeah but uh okay so I think it's very interesting and the points you make and you of course you're an academic but you also practice what you preach because you're setting up local banks in the UK but it strikes me that there will be a very difficult uphill battle because you're
still held you still have to participate in the banking system in the UK you still have the Bank of England you still have all the stifling regulation don't you believe there is a better solution could be or would be to come up with your own local currency whether it's a cryptocurrency or just some local currency in order to really set up something parallel to the existing power structure yes yes well I think that's that's that's an issue I mean if you pursued that and you think it's through you will find there is there's some obstacles to that and and and for example like some people you mentioned earlier you've been trying to introduce alternative currencies the problem is
always to get people to actually use it and therefore you have to work in steps and in phases and the first step is to create that local community and a local common financial infrastructure and that is exactly what local community banks are doing that has to come first then you can talk about you know what to do next with with local currencies yeah interesting well I know I've already used up a lot of your time but it's such a fascinating conversation it could go on for hours and do you think Kofi it could be two more localism because people travel less people tend to possibly look for more local solutions in supply chains you believe there could be a positive side effect of the kava crisis
well the the policy decisions of course are towards acceleration of the whole control and central planning agenda but I think in people's minds a lot of people have started to think well hang on we have to watch out these central planners are not necessarily thinking of our good of our you know that of ordinary people and therefore who's gonna help me it is your local area it is your neighbors it is your family and I think a lot of people have realized that but that that wasn't the plan but I think that's you know that that is a development so there is hope and I think yes with the right local activities we can turn this into something that
accelerates local community development that's a hope for a message to end a conversation with I think Richard or is there anything else you wanna you want to add well I think that's fine we'll just have to have another conversation next time yeah I think so yeah because there's so many things to discuss but I definitely would advise people to at least watch a documentary too princess again because it's it's an it's an it's a classical read it's been watched many times online millions of times and your book of course was a best-seller in Japan so if you don't have the time to read the book at least watch the documentary I'll put it in the show notes and yeah it would be nice to have this conversation again Richard in the future and because yeah there is one thing I'd like to mention having thought
about it quickly when you said is there anything else well actually there is one thing and that is in our movement to establish community banks we need supporters and we need help of course it would be nice if we could receive help from very powerful players maybe the big banks and I've been trying to reach out to big banks too to try to understand that by helping us they're helping themselves and here's my logic I'm actually quite shocked that the commercial banks the big banks don't realize what's happening they're
doing nothing in order to fight for their survival they're about to be annihilated they see smaller banks disappearing and they think oh that's fine we're big but actually you know that's you know sooner becoming for that for you as well you know for the big for the big boys and when it for them to survive when the the laws are being put before Parliament to abolish banking entirely there there will be some debates hopefully still but for the big banks would be very hard to argue all no we are doing a good service to society therefore we need to survive nobody's gonna believe them but if they can say okay we've been bad in the past but if
you abolish us you'll also punish these community banks you see they have a chance then of surviving and people saying no actually we don't want that so maybe we shouldn't abolish banking and that's why they should support small local community banks you're not really threatening the big banks but they're for a corporation with the big banks would be in their interest and so perhaps if you know some big bankers watching this you know do I'd like to reach out and do get in touch cool well it would be a very interesting in lions then so maybe we would see big bank if it's pitchforks at some point now I'm sure a lot of bankers civil watch this interview as well and if they can help out community banks such as your
initiative that would be great of course so thanks thanks a lot Richards and have a good weekend and yeah let's see maybe we can do it again in the future very great ok thanks for the pleasure bye-bye
