Convergent - Achill Rudolph, Logan Saether (Hacked Personal Attention Token) - GoerliCon 0|16
GoerliCon 0|16 · 31 Jan 2019 · 14:12
Achill Rudolph and Logan Saether present Convergent, a personal token project that began at ETHBerlin, in a short talk at GoerliCon. It looks at creators, artists and freelancers who issue tokens linked to a future service or artwork, and answers three common critiques: why not use ordinary money, whether it amounts to selling oneself, and what happens when a promise is broken. Convergent uses a bonding curve with a buy and sell spread, so funds stay in a reserve and the issuer earns a small fee. The Q&A covers securities law and speculation.
Speakers
Topics
From GoerliCon 0|16, hosted by Department of Decentralization.
Transcript
okay thanks everyone there's just a really short flash talk about a project that I worked on at the East Berlin hackathon this was six months ago almost five months ago and we've been working on this project ever since and it has come along quite a bit but still it hasn't really breaking through and this is kind of a moment where I want to take a step back and say maybe it's just a stupid idea maybe I shouldn't do it so this is a talk about why personal tokens is a bad idea and I hope maybe together we can actually rescue it so the way I got this idea was that there are more
and more people out there who are actually launching their own tokens and the first guy to maybe to do this like pretty successfully was a Polish youtuber and he launched his own token with a classical ICO during the hype and he raised two million dollars without telling anyone what he was going to actually do in exchange for that token he just launched it told people that they can buy it and he had enough followers to actually raise in a substantial amount of money so there's another artist that did something similar but at least she told people what you can do with the token that she launched she said if someone gives me that token which I called Bitcoin you can get a piece of my art in the future
in exchange for that so she launched that token a lot of people bought it and in the end she basically pre-sold a lot of her not yet created art and it seemed like a really successful way to fund artists but there's also freelancers and experts especially in the crypto scene who are doing this more and more so just recently there's a guy called matt vernon from the australia he calls himself dead boy on social media and he said one token of deaf boy tokens is worth one hour of my time so you can always redeem that token by sending it to me and then I will do one hour of consulting work on your project so all in all it seemed like a few people who
are doing this but still we're not sure if this is a good idea and if everyone should be doing this but it there is a pattern here there are a lot of creators and artists who say I have a service that I offer to the markets and I'm going to launch a token and link that token with the service and then people can invest in my future creations so the project that I was working on was basically trying to make this possible and easy for everyone because those people that are now launching their own tokens they have to have a lot of knowledge they are already experts and need to know how to write a solidity contract otherwise or maybe they're using extender to the contracts but still it's pretty hard for a
designer or an artist who has not been in touch with the technology side of blockchain to launch their own token so we got a lot of support but also a lot of backslash for this idea and I want to just go through three of the big critiques that we got and most people start off saying hey this is really stupid idea why not just have someone pay me and regular currency I I don't want to have like millions of currencies in the world to pay for each and every service that's why we have money but the cool thing with the token and that's the reply here is that with the token the service that you're offering it doesn't have to be a
real service right now it can be an imagined a future service it can be a service that doesn't exist yet so if you just use normal money you can always pay for all kinds of services you can buy an art piece from an artist but that art piece kind of has to exist already and with the token the artist can say I make this token represent a future not yet created painting of mine and the artists can sell that and if people believe that at some point the artist will actually create that painting that is backing the token then the artist can raise money based on their future expected creations this is a superpower kind of that individuals usually don't have usually people individuals sell services that
they just created that they actually have in their hands and you sell your time if you are in unemployment you sell your time to your employer right now companies on the other hand can actually sell future services they have this ability to issue stock and thereby say I'm going to do something in the future guys and give me money now and I will do that and then you get a part in it now this is something with the token an artist can do or anyone actually could do the other really big outcry that comes when we talk about this idea is this is slavery this is like selling your self to capitalist investors and
they're gonna exploit you and so there are people who are really giving us strong reactions crypto bro crowd is busy reinventing indentured servitude welcome to the future of human race it's amazing how we can always make our actual universe worse than the worst dystopia we can think of so little heck why are you your hating so strong on it and I think a lot about it is it slavery when you pre sell your future services again when you sell your time to your employer you also don't sell just one hour you sell like one year of your life or you contract you to sign a contract for
three months is that slavery when you pre commit to providing a certain service for a certain payment I don't think so but what I get is that there is a situation where someone could buy up all the tokens of a person and let's say I'm selling my time and I say one token is worth one hour of my time and it's super cheap in the beginning so a lot of people buy my token and suddenly someone owns all of my time that's a problem like but in on the other hand I have willingly chosen to offer my time and I've set the price of the token so if you want to avoid the fact that someone buys up all your time and then tells you what to do with it well you can just
make that token really expensive or you can make it become more expensive as more people buy the token so that's something that we are actually building into our solution we are using a bonding curve instead of a classical ERC 20 token so whenever someone buys your personal token that token price goes up and in the end it will be very expensive to buy all of your time so another last a possible attack vector that always gets pointed out is there's no way to actually hold you accountable to your promise you just say I'm offering a token and that's worth one hour of my time but what if you just say no
someone actually buys your token they give it to you and you say no I'm not working anymore sorry that token is worthless yeah that can happen and I think one thread on reddit described pretty well what would happen like someone would just not get their service and then they would resell the token they would sell the token because it's not worth anything and people would agree that it's not worth much so it would just kind of collapse but then the big very justified critique is but the person who has launched the token has already raised money with it they have already collected the ico funds if they've done the ico with it and then it's too late
right because you already got scammed that's very true so that's also why we use bonding curse in a bonding curve system you don't get the money for a sole token but rather the money stays in a smart contract and it stays in a reserve and in this way you only get a tiny little fee whenever someone buys a token you don't get the full price for the token but that's something that's something I don't want to put into this short 10-minute presentation what I do want to say is that we have actually taken all these critiques and responded to them and are building a life beta version that's coming out in two weeks from now so I'd love to hear from you guys if you're interested to launch your
own token on that beta version and if yes please get in touch too real collect some emails on the end of this thank you people have tried doing similar kinds of things with like four university students where where companies can like invest in basically debt instruments that that kind of take like a portion of someone's future income for a pay it and stuff these things always end up getting you know regulated as securities or you know have you talked to like a securities lawyer is a personal token of security in the case of student depth usually it is a regulated with contract so there it
is really important for the student to actually pay the investor once he starts earning money in our case there are no contracts there is no legal system binding people to actually provide the service here and so I think that makes a big difference because now this is just a way to say I trust that you will actually give me a painting later on there's no contract signed and there's no notary that was involved so it's it's very much in the gray zone but I think it's harder to classify it as a security than in the case of student depth yeah I would think that by saying that some you know by saying that I'm going to provide
you some service in the future it's like a verbal contract which you know yeah is enforceable in a court of law so I don't think it's enforceable because let's say someone rupal contracts are enforceable yeah but if you say like I can say right now I'm going to offer one hour of my time for this token and I can change my mind later on and not do it who's going to enforce my promise that I put on reddit's the court I don't I don't think that these kinds of promises on the internet are enforceable yeah mm-hmm I would just consider talking to a lawyer before you get hit with securities yeah thanks thanks cool Chris you kill you obviously have a lot of
passion for this idea but it feels like you're kind of like struggling to take the next step but like what's your plans for taking this forward and actually question - is that where can I get a Kia loin yeah so it's on the life on the rinkeby net right now a Hills creation is called and it's on convergent dot CX but I would like to take your email address and show you the main net version where we get life and that's actually our next step because we realize it's really hard to test something like this on test nets when there's no real incentives there's no real excitement you know and so we want to go live with a very very minimal version on the main net where there can be very small money amounts involved but
it's already much more engaging so in two weeks we're launching and this is our next step I want to be there when you press the big red button on me thank you thank you well anybody else got a question or comment on this issue Alex Alex Alex okay what do you think about speculation because other people can make more money on your work then you actually do yourself what is my advantage of a credible talk right so yeah we think of it as a way for early supporters to also become part of your success it's it should be part of the system that you can speculate because we
want people who support you in an early stage when you need it most to be able to benefit from your success if you end up making it so we want that to be part of it but also we don't want it to be the primary objective and so what we're doing is that we are building a fee into the system where when you sell the token you have to pay a little bit of a fee to the artist so selling is kind of discouraged and people who buy in they need to actually believe that you will succeed because then your token will be valuable enough to out way that fee okay but I thought the value I don't know ease or die is in some kind of escrow
until it's redeemed yes so I don't get any money when someone invests in my token but he can earn money from selling the token and then actually I mean he's actually not investing in me until the token gets redeemed yeah there's a there's a nice little extension that I didn't talk about so it's very good that you're asking this question which is that the escrow has a special structure it has two curves for buying and for selling and the buying curve has a higher price so when you buy a token you need to put in more money then you get when you want to sell and the difference between this Buy and the sell curve is what goes into the artists pockets so whenever someone buys token you do actually get some amount of money but not all the money
that was put in for the token most of the money that was put in for the token goes into that escrow and then there is a spread between this buy in the cell that goes to the artists what percent is that we are thinking about 5% okay well thanks a lot controversial idea [Applause]