Can we avoid another financial crisis?
De Week van Bitcoin · 9 May 2017 · 35:56
Economist Steve Keen of Kingston University talks with Paul Buitink and Delft researcher Martijn Jeroen van der Linden about his book Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis. Keen argues that mainstream models leave out banks, debt and money and assume equilibrium, which is why economists missed the last crisis, and that demand is the turnover of money plus new credit. He names countries with high and rising private debt, including China, Australia, Canada, Korea, Belgium, Norway and Sweden, and explains his move to Patreon funding as an independent economist.
Speakers
Topics
From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.
Transcript
one hi everybody my name is Paul and today we're going to interview Steve Kean I'm going to do together with Martin Yun velinda who's working on its PhD on monetary reform at the Del University of Technology it's a great honor to have uh Steve Kean again we last interviewed him in November 2015 Steve is professor at Kingston University in London and author of books such as debunking economics and his latest can we avoid another financial crisis hi Steve welcome good to be here just showing the cover of the latest B there as we talk about it yeah Jack y right excellent I I was trying I tried to find
to find debunking economics as well um but it's somewhere hidden in my bookshelf but I couldn't find straight oh perfect go good so we got them all um Steve uh how have you been too busy uh this reminds me one of the old jokes you often see about uh about about by I've seen some female friends of mine for just so many men so little time in my case there so many economic fallacies so little time exactly so your your book is amongst others about um economic fallacies and you've also of course addressed some of these fallacies in in your book the banking economics um but let's let's um discuss the main ones again from your latest book and also for
us to better understand how we can avoid another icial crisis so what are the the main fallacies you see in in modern economic science well the main thing I'm focusing on this book is the fallaces over money and also the F combined fallacy with money and equilibrium so neoc classical mainstream sorry people who are not economists would think economists must be experts on money the ironic thing is when you get inside economics you realize they've actually persuaded themselves that money doesn't matter so far from being experts on on on money they're people who think you can model the economy without including bank stad or money in it and that is simply absurd the public attitude that that can't be right is correct uh and that's of course why they
didn't see the financial crisis coming because they weren't even looking at the at the point from which the crisis emanated and they can't they still can't understand and you can see this in the literature today they still can't understand why Banks debt and money have any impact on the economy so what I went through in the book here is is why that's uh when you have a a realistic view of money why that's obvious that they have enormous impact and it's also tied up with the whole fetish they had for modeling the economy as if it's in a continuous state of equilibrium or if it's Disturbed from equilibrium doesn't go too far we always return to it and of course the fact that that's complet those two views are completely wrong is first of all they didn't see the financial crisis coming and secondly why
they can't understand why the aftermath has been what they call secular stagnation but with what is really credit stagnation yeah but if if I read your book it's it seems all quite obvious to me and also for many laymen it seems obvious to have a proper definition and inclusion of money debt and banks in any kind of economic model in order to forecast things correctly so how come then after the crisis that uh these models haven't been updated or haven't been replaced by better ones because if if we understand it how come government bureaucrats or other people running the economy and don't understand it the economy is not like a bridge if you designed a bridge badly it tends to fall over and kill people and uh and
that makes it rather obvious it hasn't wasn't welld designed in the first place with the economy it's such a an abstract Concept in its own right even though of course we we wouldn't live without it uh it's such an abstract concept you can't get your hands on it and you can therefore you have to rely upon a model of it now if you rely upon a model uh it's exactly the same story as looking at the universe you'll start with a you start with a set of observations that lead you to a model and of course the obvious observation when you're when you're a chimpanzee lying back on a tree in Africa uh is that the stars and the Sun and the Moon and the planets orbit the earth and therefore the Earth must be the center of the universe and you have a wonderful model built up on that
basis and of course because the model doesn't precisely fit the fact you include a little Quirk that all the planets you can see I think you can see four planets with the naked eye those four planets rotate on their own spheres which you call epicycles and with that model you can very accurately pick where the stars and are going to be of course because they could continue orbiting and where the planets are going to be because the orbits on their orbits you can actually mathematically work out in either direction you have a wonderful model why change comes along and tells you that uh in fact um that that there are there are comets and the Comets undermine your theory they'll say comets are atmospheric phenomena see the heavens are perfect and comets are moving and
changing and therefore they must be they can't be in the heavens which is which are perfect they must be in the atmosphere now that's an analogy obviously but fundamentally that's the same situation that neoclassical economists are in they've got a model where money plays no role where Banks don't exist where debt is irrelevant the only Deb that matters is government debt not private debt they can't see why it matters at the macroeconomic level then they presume the system is in equilibrium and will return to it uh when you try then to take all that and and fit the real world into that it doesn't so all you do if you if you try tinkering with the model there's no point you've got to throw the model out and start with the astronomical case with one where the sun is the center of
the observable universe at the time and from that you can progress but economists are still clinging to what I'd call TM economics and why is that because in the of of the financial crisis many people have also criticized mainstream neoc classical science uh even Paul RoR for in for instance but why don't they change their theories or and their models well they you're human fundamentally it's because they're human uh and they don't have the benefit of other humans we call scientists of having a set of experiments that can contradict belief and uh if if you if you know history of economic thought and history of philosophy of science you'll know there have been episodes in the past where Humanity uh in other disciplines has been confronted by a
complete contradiction to their beliefs and the reaction was to effectively you know ostracize the person who criticized the beliefs rather than saying oh great thanks very much you've improved our understanding of the universe let's go on to a new Theory so for example we all know that there are what are called irrational numbers you know the square root of of two was an obvious IR rational number um that was a travesty when it was first found that there was in fact such a thing as an irrational number by The pythagoreans Who one of the elements of the Pythagorean School of geometry was that all numbers can be described as a ratio of two integers now when one of their members proved that this of five is happens by drowning in the
Mediterranean but uh of course because they couldn't get rid of the obvious proof ultimately that the square root of two and the square root of three and the square root of five were all irrational numbers they finally developed uh accepted that complete change in their mental framework and developed the mathematics that led to Newton and Newton LED through to complex numbers and we now things about the square root of negative numbers um but physics had a similar thing with Max plank solving What's called the the the black body radiation Problem by doing it happens integration in the complex plane and finding the solution involved a uh a constant which meant that energy came in
in small discrete units he called Quant now he gave up trying to persuade his fellow physicists of that and finally call that wonderful phrase that science advances one funeral at a time yeah so the reason why they haven't changed their minds is a they haven't been enough funerals and B uh we we we don't have an experiment like that which which gives you something which strongly contradicts the underlying theorem so they they will continue going back to their belief system no matter what I think it's clear or yeah yeah so if we would um use the models that you advocate for what what does what does it say now what do your models say about the the current uh economy and and because you asked the
question of course can we avoid another Financial CR is another financial crisis coming soon or what is your what is your your own forecast there well it depends on the country you're in if you're in uh Japan or America or the UK or Europe you've already had a crisis Japan back in 1990 America in 2008 the UK and and Europe 2008 2010 and that crisis was caused first of all by a boom which was driven by Rising private debt and what one of the main elements of my my argument that is novel in terms of it's something which I've had to persuade my own post Kyan School of over time is that total demand in the economy is the some of the turnover of existing money Plus
Credit Now the mainstream model when they think about banks at all they they just dismiss them by this model where they treat Banks as intermediaries and say that a bank doesn't actually originate loans a bank introduces a saver to a borrower and then charges Commission on the exchange between the two that is to quote it from of mine from the past that is total total and it's been called as by the bank of England exactly yeah the bank the bonders bank and the Norwegian Central Bank have all come out said that's nonsense they said Banks actually originate loans and when they originate loans what they do is they rather than like if if you if you just have a loan between one non-bank person and another that simply shuffles the
money between two different people bank accounts without increasing the aggregate volume of bank accounts when when you have a bank originating loan it creates debt on one side of its Ledger and an additional liability to itself on the other which is a increase in a deposit account and that increase into deposit account is spent yeah but everyone knows that the central banks have have all admitted that and and also for example the work from Kum office is is very important there so that's a given now right but cons but given given that fact um there's still no appetite for the alternative models as the by Minsky yourself and other oh no they they always want to squeeze it back in equilibrium framework so it isn't just
living out Banks debt and money it's also believing the economy either it's they made a modeling choice in the 19th century which was RA rational at the time that if you're going to try to model thing as complex as the economy you'd have to assume it's an equilibrium to make it feasible and if you read people like Jans and Marshall and uh and JB Clark when they wrote about it they thought well we know it compromise Dynamics talking about equilibrium phenomena restricting ourselves just to equilibrium is a crutch of techniques we currently have and we'll leave it to our successors to do the Dynamics well the century and a half later virtually what they call Dynamics any mathematician would laugh out of court
yeah and they they have a they have a dynamic process they presum it returns to equilibrium even when the model they're building it on which is in the case of the dhg models it's the Ramsey growth model from the 1920s the Ramsey gr growth model had an unstable equilibrium they simply presume the economies inhabited by Godlike creatures who they call rational uh who can work out the only path to get to an unstable equilibrium and that is a mathematical travesty if you have an unstable equilibrium it is unstable but they well it's unstable but these these rational agents can work out what the the root is to this unstable equilibrium and get there despite its instability in which case why do you need a market they have
a model of an economy consisting of gods yeah why do you need anything Gods can coordinate themselves any way they damn well like so it ends up they're simply not realiz aware of how absurd their modeling structures are because all the things they hope they could prove mathematically largely relating to the stability of equilibrium so a market economy could find out the equilibrium on its own uh they've got to presume everybody in the market economy is God to find out what equilibri is and get there yeah and your own models um from 25 onwards a few years afterwards you basically saw the previous Global Financial Crisis coming or at least what was going on in the stage you could you could predict based on GDP and private
depbt numbers um if you EUR model again I think you Al you also talk about it in your book what are the sort of the zombie countries or the countries that um have the highest likelihood of running into a big financial crisis again again yeah well that's countries like China clearly Australia Canada which you'd expect and some other countries you wouldn't expect including Korea Belgium Norway and Sweden and possibly uh uh Singapore Thailand and Malaysia uh these are countries which all have a substantial level of private debt so a minimum of close to 1.5 times GDP and in some cases 2.6 times GDP and they're also they're also having a debt Rising faster than GDP which means credit
growth credit credit is is larger the change in debt which is credit is larger than the change in the increase in GDP Al so you have a growing debt burden in those economies and part of what caus causes a crisis is the level of debt is too high to begin with and the demand in the economy is too dependent upon that debt level continuing to rise so all you have to have to have a crisis is the rate of growth of debt slowing down to the same as GDP so simple stabilization of the debt ratio is enough to cause crisis and uh this will happen at some point because no economy can sustain in infinite amount of debt the maximum any economies ever sustained I think was the
Netherlands economy which had in terms of a large economy about 2.4 times GDP was its debt level so these countries Australia Canada Korea uh China or all between two and 2.4 times 2.5 times GDP as a debt level what R they have a crisis and what can they do to avoid this is there also to answer the question in of your book is there something they can do to to kind of uh um Stop This Disaster from from happening they can they can't stop it from happening because the only way it can stop it from happening is to continue having debt Rising faster than JD so it has to happen question is when it happens what can you do to attenuate
the damage and the easiest thing to do well easiest but the the way that gives you the lowest level of pay is to use the state's capacity to create money to cancel debt debt-based money and what I call a modern debt Jubilee use the government's capacity to create money to give everybody effectively a tax credit and then if those people who receive the tax credit are in debt and their debt is reduced by the amount of the tax credit but if people are not in debt so if they we invited com Savers they get a cash injection they can spend and that way you don't crush demand in the economy to when you reduce the level of private debt but otherwise if you rely upon normal private sector uh Dynamics then when people try to reduce the debt
they'll also reduce GDP the debt ratio won't fall particularly but you'll end up in a depression and how uh should governments put this in practice Yeah it's actually been done once by Australia and that was in 2008 literally was a tax credit so this is actually happened after I scared the pants off the Prime Minister there uh by being interviewed on the leading current affairs program one day and he was interviewed on the same program the next day and hared by the interviewer about My Views and one week later he came out with the stimulus program part of which involved restarting the housing bubble so they doubled and trebled the amount of money they gave to first home buyers to encourage them back into the market
again that was by far the most effective thing they did but they also gave every household that had paid their taxes a rebate of roughly $1,000 just turned up in your bank account and of course people people spent that money and by spending it they stimulated the economy so on that basis plus the unfortunately the housing bubble restart Australia is one of only two countries to avoid a recession back in 2007 2008 the other being South Korea of course though they avoided it was by continuing to increase their level of private debt yeah which is why they now face the crisis again uh in the next couple of years yes a Australia has just just been buying timed in borrowed money yeah so Martin and I live
in Holland you just uh you just mentioned Holland um as as also a country with a high private debt level um people could also argue well we also have a lot of assets um and also a lot of pension reserves is your metric a gross debt number or a net private debt number it's always gross because net debt is one of these little tricks that says oh I'm going to value my houses that's current price and subtract that from the amount of debt that I get and hey I've got I've got I've got no no net debt at all the current price is actually maintained by the increase in private debt so if you have a if you suddenly have a people ceasing to borrow money uh for their houses then the house
price will crash and then what looked like a good financial situation beforehand net debt know zero or positive or or the net debt negative suddenly becomes net debt massively positive because the asset prices collapse in value you but you still ow the same amount of money on them so it's very P for example are pensions could you or could or should you deduct thatb from the Deb level because of course that is also no no because it's also because the reason is using grow gross that is credit okay if that's one saying if you have to focus upon the role of credit in the economy so if you net out and credit itself increases the value of assets so if you take out more housing debt you drive up the value of house prices and if you work the net between the two you
get a small change but if you take a look at the gross alone you can see how much more leverage is driving up house prices and how much that Leverage is also necessary for maintaining demand in the economy yeah so Holland is also to or not so Holland is also toast then in your book as a as as a candidate country for another crisis yeah the Netherlands actually describe as I I describe the world divide the world into two major categories the what called The Walking debt of debt those are countries that had a debt crisis either Japan back in 1990 or most of the rest of the world in 2008 and now they've got declining levels of private debt compared to GDP and for a while they had negative credit
as well and then in the situation they're going to be just like Japan has been for 25 years zombified by the fact they've lost credit demand from their economy generally speaking so demand's going to be deficient um but they they can't reduce the debt level itself because of that feedback when you reduce debt you also reduce GDP so they're stuck with a high level of debt to GDP not much credit based demand and stagnant economies they're the walking debt of debt the other main category are economies that avoided the crisis back in 2008 which by continuing to borrow so Australia when the crisis hit had a on the bis figures had a private de level about of about 1.8 times GDP it's now between 2.1 and 2.2 times GDP so it Bor its way out of trouble but of course now
when when its credit slows down it'll have that much larger an impact than it would have had if that had a crisis back in 2008 there are some countries which don't quite fit there and the Netherlands is one and actually call it shring to zombie it's both it's both a zombie and not a zombie all at once it may become a zombie once more because you are so dependent upon credit demand and you have a GD a credit level I think of about 2.3 times GDP or dead level 2.3 times GDP yeah so that's what really surprises me so after the financial crisis there hasn't been a real Del leverage so we have still high levels of private Dept so and also there so if you look at Minsky or also other poian literature then you would would expect much more
deleveraging and why didn't that happen well mainly because we didn't have a second world war if you look back at the Great Depression I mean if take a look at the level of debt in America when The Crisis began in 1930 and then compare that to uh the end of 1945 the level of debt fell by factor of three or four pretty much like but when when when the second world war ended uh that period began with a level of debt about onethird the level that it was when the when the 19 when The Crisis began in 1930 even though that for a while there actually Rose because of deflation so you had a very very low level of debt and a large reason for it was the enormous government stimulus uh of all the government spending during the second world war plus the restraint on private
spending by all the all the rationing uh meant that for corporations pay their debt down and circuit households without subtracting from aggregate demand because the government was producing so much of the demand and if you look at the scale of deficit that was run at the time and on I think in 1940 England spent England's deficit government deficit was 35% of GDP now they they they they start to wet their pants these days and they get a deficit of 3% of GDP now if you imagine back in 19 1940 what have what happened to any parliamentarian said we can't afford to buy that bomb otherwise our children will be in in poverty forever yeah I said yeah they in poverty forever in speaking
German so pardon me so uh you know therefore there's no restraint on the amount of government spending because it was so enormous it enabled the private sector to delever without depressing the economy the economy was fully employed in the war effort um this time round rather we haven't had anything of that scale and what the governments have tried to do is encourage people back into debt so if you look at the um the the programs that particularly banki was responsible for a major factor there we thought we have to get the banks lending again and that's because they don't realize that there's too much bank that to begin with QE done the same sort of thing so the authorities rather rather than and enabling deleveraging to occur have actually been trying to encourage
Rel leveraging without realizing they've already so close to the sealing level of debt that these economies can carry that they'll never get any particular level of demand out of it right and they don't think they get demand out of it this the other weird thing I mean some of the nonsense these people believe is just breathtaking so on the one hand we should um Implement something like modern je de Jubilee and on the other hand I guess we also then need to try to restrain um private debt growth or or make sure it will be more for like productive um purposes um companies building a factory uh or something like that instead of um bubbles in the stock market or any other kind of like real estate market is that that's right but
and how what i' like to do yeah so and how would you go about that well you you have to make it unprofitable for banks to finance asset price speculation if you look at what they do right now 90% or more of the money they create uh just goes to finance real estate and share BuyBacks and that that what that what that purchase those purchases do is drive up asset prices and the logic is quite simple it's complicated mathema itics but the logic is quite straightforward if you think about what is demand monetary demand for housing it's fundamentally new mortgages and if you divide that the new mortgages which is the mon the flow of monetary demand per year for housing by the price level you get a rough idea of how many the flow of demand for new
houses every year so that gives you a relationship between mortgage credit which is change in Mortgage Debt and the level of house prices so you get a relationship as a result of that if you look at the change of that respect to time you get a relationship between change in mortgage credit which is acceleration of Mortgage Debt and change in house prices and call in a causal sense that the driving force there is the change in mortgage credit so changing mortgage credit which is acceleration of Mortgage Debt is what drives house prices so we're caught in a positive feedback loop between acceleration of debt and change in house price yeah but would you then suggest something like window guidance
or credit guidance That central banks um determine which sectors of the economy get credit and which not no I don't first of bureaucrats are easily AR maneuvered by credit creators this has always been the case I speak to plenty of people in the banking sector in the UK who tell me that they think it's quite funny they get invited to hear what new laws are going to be at the at the bank of England so when they're sitting there it's a bit like criminals being told what the new laws are going to be for controlling the drug trade um and being discussing the laws before they're actually implemented and he said we're sitting there listening to these new proposals and we're actually in the back of our minds we're nodding at the front of our faces in the back of our brain we're thinking okay how can we
evade this set of regulations so I don't think you can do it by regulation I think you have to do it by change in the legal structure of banking and I would bring in in terms of the mortgage Market I'd bring in one control which is the maximum amount that can be borrowed against a property would be some factor of the income earning capacity of the assets so not what you think the price is going to be not what you allegedly have as a you know a link between the income of the borrow and the purchase price just say for a particular house which has a rental income let's say of 20,000 EUR a year the maximum anyone can borrow to buy it is 200,000 if any borrows body borrows more than 200,000 divide they forfeit the house now if you set that up in that way
first of all you take away the encouragement we all have to compete against each other with more leverage because at the moment if you and I are fighting over the the same place we both had the same income the one of us who would win would be the one who got more Bank leverage more Bank debt so we actually have a positive encouragement to have Rising levels of debt compared to income uh but if you change to this system then the amount of Leverage we get is maxed out we but neither of us could use that example of a house selling for two renting for 200,000 Euro or 20,000 EUR a year neither of us could borrow more than 200,000 so the one who would win it' be the one who saves more money from their salary yeah so that takes away that particular Loop so so in that sense you put a
little faith in the hand of of um of the government and central banks and regulation in order to avoid another private debt buildup no I put it in the hand of I put in the hand of the the judges and the court system yeah well basically the state then well the thing is that judges if if you've seen what Regulators have done uh the Australian situation is quite Classic on this front they think of the Australian credential regulation Authority actually was sending off its press releases about controlling one of the banks to one of the banks to get the bank's approval before the press release was sent out yeah now I've never seen a judge send a note to a convicted criminal to a criminal who's being tried
to say what would you like us to try you for no but with yeah but an Austrian Economist or or like a maybe classical Economist could argue isn't the state the problem here by allowing Banks to create all that money in the first place and and supporting them with central banks and and depos insurance schemes and other kind of Bill bailouts what would you think of that argument well the banks have always been able to create credit banks have always been ever since Banks existed they've created money um so it isn't isn't a case the one thing that lets a bank create money is the social license to have a bank yeah and people who are in favor of this are saying well let's just deregulate
completely and let anybody set up their own bank and we compete between the banks and the people will choose the more responsible bank and therefore weed out the bad ones and it'll be absolutely beautiful I think it's so totally naive and it's it's it's amusing to hear austrians coming out with this stuff because they're normally ones who talk about limited information and limited knowledge and so on and yet when it comes to banking they're willing to imagine just like neoc classicals that individuals and Society a Godless entity Godlike entities who can work out what's a responsible bank and what's not and will put their money with the sensible one rather than the responsible one uh what they will do is they'll take for the bank with promising the biggest return we'll get Ponzi schemes and Booms and busts and crashes and
that's just what we had in the 19th century how anybody can argue that and not remember little things like the Tulip craze or the south sea bubble and so on it sounds a bit like the the cryptocurrency it sounds a bit like cryptocurrency investing at the moment yeah exactly they're people people do not even the austrians are happy to assum that people will be intelligent and responsible and avoid irresponsible banking they're saying everybody in the world is like Hayek everybody is responsible like Hayek crap yeah and I know your time time constrained I have a Martine is a I think a final before we briefly also discuss your Patron project but then Martine I think you have a nice philos philosophical question to kind of uh and to end with actually add one more one
more question if I'm allowed I had also the question what about proposals of for instance Michael Kumo of positive money in UK to really Implement monetary reform and in a way to end banking yeah that's the trouble um two two things wrong about that first of all even though I am very much in favor of much more government CR money creation we have right now I'm not in favor of bureaucrats deciding the amount of money in the economy because they'll get it wrong for sure yeah probably could create too little rather than too much and then when that happens the the bankers will still be there they'll just be doing something else you know card sharks or that sort of thing um they will come back and say look it work much
better when we were in control and because people forget these things uh we'll get the bankers back in there again and we back in the same bloody situation once more that's the negative reason the positive reason is that I actually think there is a role for private private entities to create money if that cre ation of money goes towards Innovation yeah because again I don't trust bureaucrats to work out what products deserve you know what what new ideas deserve to be given a financial chance I've seen enough of their capacity to stuff up innovation in academic research not to want them to be making decisions on finance but to make that possible banks have to be able to make a profit when they fund people who are going to lose money so the only way you can do that is by effectively making
a hybrid between Venture Capital which which exists now but does it on borrowed money or or equity funds and real Banking and let Banks who are entrepreneurial Banks take a take an equity position in the firms they lend to so that if five out of six fail but one succeeds they make a capital gain out of the one that does so something like that but it's just all public money I am just expect that to be um we have to find a way that that we make money create in an Innovative fashion as well as a a long-term sty responsible one yeah clear and then my more philosophic question is so you criticize in your book the bank economics and I think also your other books you criticize new newal new
classical science and in particular also the view of the homo economicas or utilitarianism and BMS view of the human being and what is you and what kind of view of the human being do you propose or do you use ear modeling well my Foundation is actually a non-orthodox interpretation of marxh dialectical philosophy which contradicts the labor theory of value and starts from an objective Theory value but then build subjective layers above that and it's something which I first did back in 19 when was that 1989 90 when I wrote my Master's thesis it's something which I've had at the back of my mind all the way as I've been doing all my own modeling on Minsky and and building my own overall economic Orient of interpretation and I think now when I
write my next book I have to give a long explanation of that because you can't get a decent foundation for a macroeconomics that of subjective theory of value yeah exactly that's what the neoc classicals have proven the the austrians waffle about it we need to get a new Foundation which enables us to start at an objective level which makes sense for the how he actually produce a surplus in the first place and distribution of income at that level but ends up being able to support subjective levels of valuation as well things like how you how new how asset prices are set how um how people value new products that sort of thing and this dialectical Foundation I've got does enable me to do that clear thank you I'm looking forward to
it I've got to ride it that's one back to the patreon campaign yeah that's that's a nice nice bridge to the patreon campaign because if I understand correctly Steve you want to stop being a professor and want to be full-time working on as a as a renegade Economist so you will funded by the crowd that's basically it I mean universities have been ruined by 40 Years of neoliberal policies over here and the last the the last dra me in Australia was back in 2012 I think it was maybe 2013 when the government decided to make the first year intake more like a market by deregulating controls on how many positions universities could offer for different subjects of course what happened was uh the UN the top ranked universities offered more Humanities
positions because they're cheap to teach and students who used to have to give five preferences one two three four five and used to put West and Sydney where I worked as one if they didn't expect to get uh into um New South Wales or Sydney because he had a high he needed a higher tertiary entrance mark to get into one of those so they they'd put some enough students would put us down as a first preference and we'd get about we got about 120 First preferences every year Well when they deregulated the numbers we went from 120 to 16 in one year not because students thought we had a economics toer they they didn't know school students are uninformed about what is actually taught at universities and simply think the higher
rank University must be better and that's why they abandoned us but I speaking of abandoning guys the same thing happened here in in in in England that ruined my the the financial viability of my program at Kingston and I've had enough of it so I want to go out and not have that crap happen a third time just be a public intellectual with support of people who want economics changed uh in the public and so far I'm about onethird of the way to replacing my academic salary so I can work full-time as an economic Rebel sounds great well everyone uh watching this show please check it out I'll put the link in the show notes uh it's patreon.com something something but I'll put it in the in the notes or maybe you can also say it now um Steve it's patreon.com proof Steve Kane perfect uh
so I would recommend everyone to take a look and also to uh check the book buy it and uh write a review online was great to have you on again Steve and hopefully your campaign will be successful and we get to hear and see a lot more from you thank you thanks M I'm off to play tenis right now so see you later bye bye thank you good evening thanks bye
