After the 2020 shutdowns: recovery, deflation and gold
De Week van Bitcoin · 24 Apr 2020 · 28:23
Author and analyst Jim Rickards joins Paul Buitink in spring 2020 to assess the economic depression that followed the pandemic shutdowns. Rickards expects an L-shaped recovery rather than a V, pointing to record jobless claims and the weight of small businesses in US output. He argues that central bank money creation will bring deflation rather than inflation because the velocity of money is low, says a higher dollar price of gold is the way to create inflation, and urges people to learn from the previous two financial crises. He also gives a sharply negative view of Bitcoin.
Speakers
Topics
From De Week van Bitcoin; community: Reinvent Money.
Transcript
welcome dear viewers my name is Bob I think and I'm very pleased to have a conversation today with author and financial analyst Jim Rickards to talk about what's next where our economic and financial system Jim welcome thank you Park great to be with you good to see you again we're in the biggest depression since the 30s possibly even worse than that balance sheets of central banks and governments are being pumped up as a result trillions of dollars euros and other currencies are being created to support the economy if we look at the u.s. first do you support the measures taken which you also have taken those measures yourself if you would be in charge well first on the depression point you're right and it seems to be
pretty well understood you know where we are right now let's say the second quarter 2020 and I'll speak about the United States it looks like on an annualized basis our economy will crash 30 to 40 percent and there's never been a number like that this isn't three to four percent that you get in a bad recession 30 to 40 percent so on an annualized basis that would be six trillion dollars of lost output let's say that we have about a 20 trillion dollar economy 30 percent of that annualized would be six trillion dollars so that much seems to be known of course you know we all know what's prompted this it was the pandemic and you can
debate responses to the pandemic Sweden has taken a fairly light handed approach South Korea took a heavy-handed approach the United States is a muddle we did a little both we were got off to a late start but then sort of moved to a more extreme form of lockdown so I'll leave that debate to others but there's there's no debate about the economic impact this quarter the question is where do we go from here is this the famous v-shaped recovery where it goes down it comes right back up again and by the end of the year everyone celebrated Christmas that's all good or is this you know the l-shape recovery where it goes down it doesn't go down further but it doesn't go up a lot either we just sort
of poke along at a lower level about put unemployment high growth remains weak etc and that's a huge difference of course my view is that we're in for the the l-shaped recovery that we've gone down you know some very large number you have thirty or forty percent annualised might take GDP down seven percent for the full year but I don't look for a robust recovery in fact this will be very little recovery at all there are a lot of reasons for that we can get into it but you know I think this is it will be years before the United States gets back to 2019 levels of output and it will be years before unemployment gets anywhere
even below 10 percent let alone back to the three or four percent levels we had just a few months ago yeah because 26 million new jobless claims over the past few weeks alone and I think we in the u.s. there's a working population of over 150 million so if I if I calculate correctly does it mean seventeen percent unemployment additionally based on these claims yeah perhaps higher I mean you're right about the numbers twenty-six million Americans have applied for unemployment benefits basically meaning they've been laid off were fired just in the past five weeks that's true but we're not done yet there you know these figures come out every Thursday Thursday morning 8:30 there may
be I don't know the number but there may be another four or five million next Thursday this made this number may be as high as thirty million will get the the April unemployment figures for next Friday basically the first first Friday in May so but you could be looking at twenty five percent unemployment that is you know obviously it's a you know extremely it's an extreme hardship for those who are unemployed the question of course is how quickly will come back and a lot of people say all right the restaurants are closed theaters concerts bars restaurants gift shops dry cleaners any non-essential small businesses and the United States are basically shut so
at some point they'll reopen and there's a sort of a movement May 15th a big date some states will reopen sooner some later but let's just jump ahead a little bit let's just say by June or July most of these businesses will reopen well it doesn't mean they're gonna hire back all these workers if you had a restaurant and you had 20 employees and you closed your doors and fired 20 employees and then in July let's say you reopened you're not gonna hire back 20 right away you might hire 10 and see how it goes you might not have as many customers your revenues might be down you might have to separate the tables to keep social distancing so the point is could you be open your doors by July yes but
it doesn't mean that you hire the 20 people back you might only hire 10 as I say so the other 10 are permanently unemployed at least you know and for for a you know extended period of time some of those people will just drop out of the labor force you might see at the unemployment figures getting good getting it better rather not because so many are being hired back but because you're actually shrinking the denominator or the fraction with people quitting the workforce permanently and then and then that assumes you're able to get back in business even if you do your revenues will be down what about the people who don't make it what about that the businesses that file for bankruptcy a lot of these businesses are not going to just reopen their doors they'll be gone and these kinds of businesses don't have
working capital they they have revenue they have expenses there can be a profit for the owner but they don't have five or ten million dollars in the bank is working capital to get through a period like this and I wouldn't underestimate the impact of small business in the United States you know people stock market investors you know stock market is shown a little it hasn't come back nearly all the way but it's shown a little bit of a rebound but you know the stock market is you know it's Boeing and General Electric and General Motors and IBM you know a lot of other large public companies but small businesses are 44 percent of total output and forty-seven percent of total jobs in other words almost half the US economy is in the
small businesses that we were just describing not in the major publicly traded corporations so if that sector was shut down which it is and if a lot of it doesn't come back which they won't and if those who reopen the doors don't hire all the employees back which they want then we're in for a very long very you know dangerous recession I would call it a depression and a very slow painful recovery yeah but if a lot of those companies have no chance of survival after the lockdown is over because of social distancing because of measures does it make sense then to keep these companies afloat or shoot they go
bankrupt and should the entrepreneurs themselves or the families be helped by it by direct cash instead of keeping these companies afloat for all these months longer like airliners for example of course we will fly a lot less in the future so how much sense does it make to keep all these people on the payroll for for many months to come well first of all I mean a lot of them are not on the payroll mean look load factors well flights are down 90% and the load factors and the remaining flights are low so the airline industry has been hit the hardest of all and they except maybe a cruise ships themeparks airlines resorts you know Las Vegas they've all been completely completely shut down now
as far as propping them up is concerned the it's not the intention of the government to do the companies or the stockholders any favors it is the attention of the government to protect employees as much as possible so we have a small business lending program it's been given over six hundred billion dollars and a huge amount of money the so-called payroll protection plan so the government's giving loans to small businesses they very you know they could be fifty thousand dollars could be several million dollars it's not intended to go to large publicly traded corporations or large companies at all and but but the deal is if you get one of these loans
you can't fire anybody and if you go several months without firing anybody the loan becomes a grant you can keep the money but bare mines not you can get the money and you can keep the money but it's for the purpose of keeping your employees on the payroll and if you fire them anyway which you have a legal right to do you have to pay the money back and so what's the purpose of a loan like that well it's it's to avoid making unemployment worse than it already is will it work okay a short-term fix probably yes and I'm not sure you know nobody likes to do this but nobody likes to be in the situation we're in so as a way of keeping unemployment from getting
worse than it already is and as a way of keeping some of the doors open it's probably necessary but I would not but it but it's it's temporary this will this would get you to a couple months this might get you through May and June now if you assume that by July everything comes back to normal then you would have to applaud the program to say it did its job but if but my view is it won't come back to normal like you've got a two-month bridge loan but it's it's a bridge to nowhere in the sense that by July or August a lot of these even with the loans a lot of these companies won't make it and as many won't qualify for the loans and even those who do and keep some employees in the payroll it doesn't mean the revenues
and the customers are coming back anytime soon I mean I'm not I travel a lot I travel all over the world but I'm not dying to jump on an airplane right now so I think I don't think we can underestimate the psychological burden this is not just economic it's it's kind of change behavior maybe on intergenerational basis I'm going back to my first question what would then be the given the fact that you expect an l-shape recovery what would be the right response from from governments going forward do they need to keep on bailing out industries or providing loans creating more money and what is the consequence of all that's monetary expansion you think well there's never been anything like it so I would be a little bit humble about predicting the
consequences because we've never seen this before but a couple things in the short run meet well should run kind of maybe intermediate run for the next year or so our biggest is going to be deflation you know the the monetarists and the Austrian economists and you know the middle of treatment people in the neo-keynesian see also hey you printed all this money you're going to get inflation that's not true printing money has nothing to do with inflation inflation is a psychological phenomena has to do with the velocity of money or the turnover of money so so can the government print money yes can we run a deficit yes can we get money into people's hands yes but
it doesn't mean that people spend the money they could get the money and they could pay down debt they could get the money and save it which they will this is this is the famous liquidity trap which you know John Maynard Keynes diagnoses they're always in the 1920s so so the government has very good capacity to spend money but they spend it by giving it to people and giving it to banks it doesn't mean that the people spend the money and if they're paying down debt and saving it which I expect and there's already some evidence to that you're not getting the velocity I like to tell people five trillion dollars times zero is zero meaning you can increase the money supply by five
trillion dollars but the velocity of money is zero then you have no economy and that may that looks like what we're walking into so you're gonna have to do something else and there are two things you can do number one we can accelerate the decoupling from China basically bring the pharmaceutical industry back to the United States bring the electronics industry back to the United States will it raise costs a little bit yeah they will but here soon this is like well well it we get it will take years but you can start today and and that can create some investment remember investment is part of GDP it's not just US has been so driven by consumption 70% of our economy is consumption how about
training a little investment you know new plant equipment etc and then those jobs I'm talking about in pharmaceutical and electronic industries those are high-paying jobs those are often union jobs social jobs that come with benefits will it raise the cost of pharmaceuticals a little bit sure but that's that's like paying you're buying a call option I mean that's the the price you pay to have secured or supply chains this will hurt China but you know China doesn't deserve our help because they're their human rights violators they're communists they're atheists they they have nothing to offer the world and it would be much better to get those jobs back to the United States that's one thing we could do you know beyond that we're gonna need some inflation that the II cannot
unemployment's a huge problem that's a personal you know tragedy for those affected but if you want to get people back to work and you want to get velocity going which is what you have to do and you want to change the psychology which is what you have to do you're gonna need inflation we're gonna be fighting deflation so how do you get inflation in a deflationary environment there's only one way to do it and it's not by printing money it's by raising the dollar price of gold because gold is not a commodity it's money it's been done twice successfully by President Roosevelt 1933 and by President Nixon beginning in 1971 in both cases they devalued the dollar against gold raise the price of gold but it's not an end in
itself it's not designed to reward investors in gold it's designed to change the psychology because if the price of that the dollar price of gold goes up guess what you know the world of $5,000 gold is the world of $200 oil $100 silver $20 copper itself or $5,000 maybe I would sell my gold to the Fed they would say you send it in with some design in a problem they'll print the money to do it by the way it's just no but just no but a market operations what they do with bonds but how great surprise them because nothing happens in isolation you don't just raise one
commodity price and everything else stays the same the shock of it would destroy not destroy but it would greatly diminish confidence in the dollar and people will say oh my goodness I better go buy that new car I better buy that new house I'd better you know get my commodities shipments in before all before the prices go up by the way this has happened this is not a theoretical this is exactly what Franklin Roosevelt president about dated in 1933 he raised the price of gold he did not do it to reward gold holders in fact he confiscated all the gold before he did it it was the ultimate insider trade but the reason was not just a value of the dollar well so the reason was to devalue the dollar but that played out in every other market 1933 in the middle of the Great
Depression was one of the best years in the history of the stock market unemployment started to come down from 25 percent to 10 percent it was still high but it came down the stock market rallied the put what Roosevelt wanted to do bye-bye see people say raise the price of gold but when you raise the price to go what are you really doing you're devaluing the dollar it takes more dollars to get your ounce of gold so what you've done is you've devalued the dollar rose about one of the price of wheat corn cotton steal it copper he wanted all those prices to go and they did and they did and the same thing happened in the 1970s with oil and every other commodity was a great commodities boom in Africa and by between August of 1971 and January of
1980 the price of gold went up two thousand six hundred percent but the price of everything else went up and that that's the point what was about this intentionally Nixon did it by accident but the point is it works and what about a lot of people talk about so helicopter money if you just create large enough amounts and send it directly to citizens and families let's say everyone receives fifty thousand dollars or Euros do you think that could break their low-velocity and would incentivize people to spend like crazy well fifty thousand a year times 300 million Americans is a lot of money so yeah what what you're really talking about is changing the psychology could that change the psychology possibly I
wouldn't want to roll that I sent going to happen by the way pitch again the 50,000 times 300 million that's that's a big number even for the United States but the point is printing money and handing out money and sending money right now our Internal Revenue Services wiring hundreds of millions of checks or a wire deposits to individual Kassar it's not 50,000 s about 1700 towers but well well it helps I'm sure it'll help somebody pay the rent this month and that's a good thing but my point being if people pay debts pay bills and save it which they will that does nothing for velocity that's not the marginal consumption that you need to actually
cause inflation but so what you have to do is change the psychology and the fastest best proven way to do that is to raise the dollar price of gold not to reward gold holders but to change the psychology and get the price of everything else doing well that's Venice fines one of them I still have currency wars thank you I bought my years ago thinking I was just reading the conclusion and in different scenarios for the financial system in case a new crisis with with come and some of the things are eerily realistic especially the chaos scenario what happens currently is sort of the payoff scenario I think what would be the consequence for the international monetary system shoot the feds decides to or the
Treasury raise the price of gold what would be the consequence for example for the euro is is there still a life for the euro yeah I expect the euro to remain I don't think the euro system is it's going to break up it's under a lot of stress right now they're suffering economically maybe even worse than the United States they'll have to get through that but but I think the euro will will be around but I guess the point I'm making it's not as if it sounds if you can devalue the dollar against gold and the euro is going to be strong the euro is going to go with it in other words an increase in the dollar price of gold is also going to be an increase in the euro price of gold now the dollar so the euro US dollar cross
exchange rate might not change very much but it's a meaningless statistic it's important if you're a currency trader it's important if you're in the export/import business I understand all that capital allocation but think of all the currencies as passengers in a lifeboat so that so the the boats sank some stragglers are in a life they have no food and water they're all a little bit desperate but they're all in the same boat so saying the euro is stronger than the dollar of the dollar stronger than the euro is is kind of an unimportant statement because they're all in the same lifeboat the only way out of this is with gold so you here's what will not happen you will not devalue the dollar against gold and have
the euro stay unchanged the euro will also devalue against gold and so will the Japanese yen and pound sterling and other major currencies though all devalue against gold together at the same time but that's the end of the currency wars meaning I said in my book currency wars you know if I divide the dollar against the euro because I want to help US exports well you're a Europe just devalues the euro oh and so it's like you know you get these competitive devaluations that doesn't accomplish anything it's mathematically impossible for all currencies to buy to devalue against each other at the same time it's a mathematical impossibility if the dollar goes down the Euro has to go up or if
the girl goes down the dollar has to go up but how do they both devalue at the same time how can you devalue the dollar and the euro and the N and sterling I'm all at the same time the answer is against gold because gold is not printed by a central bank and so that's what they'll do now the interesting thing to me is does that happen as a matter of policy where the US government makes it happen where does it just happen by market forces where you know I I think people investors have a fabulous opportunity to front on the government right now they if you say it's gonna happen eventually which it will why not get some gold now and be the beneficiary if you allow me two more questions I'm sure once possibly or not that depends
on the answers of course SDR and what what is what is your view on that because I know you were quite vocal about it in the past and there were some talks within the IMF to possibly allocate more as the ours do you think is going to happen and if so how would that affect liquidity for for example developing nations right liquidity is critical and the size that in the next well of course I said this in you know 2012 and 2016 and as recently as last fall in my book aftermath which obviously looked ahead and saw this current financial crisis
but I said you'll have a liquidity crisis and you'll have to resolve it and how do you do that well one way of course which is what we're saying is the Federal Reserve will double its balance sheet which they have they they're on the way it's ten trillion dollars I my hypothesis was that and it may prove to be true but it hasn't happened yet it's that there's an invisible confidence boundary that legally can the Fed do it yes modern monetary theorists would say hey no problem just do it you know and I think money tree but they're doing it that's the thing they are doing it so they blown you know I was estimating around five trillion dollars might cause the loss of confidence now well they've blown past that there are 10 trillion
dollars so as long as they're doing that you don't need STRs for global liquidity cuz you're gonna have plenty of dollars out there how it works remains to be seen but there has been some talk about issuing STRs exactly what you described in a very large amount perhaps one trillion STRs but here's the problem when you issue a STRs they have to be handed out to all the members of the IMF according to their voting rights and and their capital accounts it's sort of a you can't get more to one country than another just because they need it more you like them better it has to be according to the rules well that means a lot of this would go to Iran and China and the US well as well and the US is
opposed to that for geopolitical reasons so right and the US has veto power you need an 85 percent vote in the IMF to make something like that happen guess what the US has 16 percent of the votes which means if every other country in the world disagreed with the United States they could only get 84 percent of the vote so the US has veto power right now the White House is saying well not publicly but the my best information is that the US will not approve an issuance of STRs because we don't want to help Iran because of their nuclear weapons program their missile testing program their promotion of terrorism their violation of Human Rights
so I don't think we're going to cstr's in the near term because the US will will oppose it there's always there's always a country of course ready us as problems with or is at war with so in that sense as the our is not going to fly anytime soon right welcome to the financial wars and final question a lot of people have embraced over the past few years new crypto currencies such as Bitcoin I saw also Jack Dorsey from Twitter now exchange his bio and just as going into guys over four and a half million followers know Paul calls it a great option on a financial system what's your take on it yeah I think I think bitcoin is junk has
no use case it's good for it's sort of good for terrorists criminals tax evaders so that's the use case it I can see it's settling around $200 a coin maybe so it's you know it's speculative I like to go to casinos in play roulette I don't always expect to win but I enjoy the game Bitcoin is sort of a disgrace me and it's led to a lot of suicides a lot of massive financial losses among people around the world who can least afford it it's a zero-sum game and it's massively manipulated and its massive fraud other than that it's all good yeah one point I would make is that this is
our third financial crisis in a row and about a ten-year tempo and I talked about this in my book the road to ruin I talked about 1998 then 2008 and then I hypothesized 2018 I bought the book in 2016 so I was looking ahead I rose up by a couple years but here it is in 2020 and we have our third great financial crisis and I was trying to draw lessons from the last two as to what you should do to prepare for the one that we're in now and a lot of people written to me lately and that you know on Twitter or email or whatever to say you know I wish I'd read your book sooner I wish I had done what you recommended and well that's okay it's not it's not too late to to take steps
but the point I made is that in the 1998 crisis which peaked in September 1998 with the default of Russia and long-term capital management that actually started in June 1997 in Thailand with the devaluation of the Thai Baht so it took over a year to go around the world in the 2008 crisis we all remember Lehman Brothers day energy and the rescues in late 2008 but that started over a year or halts and there was a collapse of a couple of Bear Stearns hedge funds in in July 2007 so that but accommodated it peaked in September 2008 so that also
took a year to go around the world so the lesson there's the last two financial crises they start somewhere but they're not over soon they take a year to a year and a half to two peak and so if this crisis started in you know you could say February March you know take your pick of you know 2020 you know as the disease going down it looks like yes will the economy find a bottom probably yes we can debate how quickly it will come back but we may not be this may not be over this may actually have a second way we're third wave and may actually kind of reach some peak in 2021 so it's still not too late to prepare
for what could be a worse phase of this crisis okay what's a valuable spice to our viewers thanks a lot Jim for your time today and then talk to you in the future thanks Paul
